Systematic vs non-systematic risk

Systematic vs non-systematic risk

Published September 28, 2026

Systematic vs non-systematic risk

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Explain systematic and nonsystematic risk, including why an investor should not expect to receive additional return for bearing nonsystematic risk.

On the exam: You get a client mandate, a benchmark, and a holding or portfolio, then classify the exposures, state what diversification changes, and choose the implementable recommendation.

Start with the source of uncertainty, not the size of a price move. A broad economic force can move many securities together, while a product failure, lawsuit, or management problem belongs to one issuer. Diversification can remove the second type, but it cannot remove the first, so an investor should not expect additional return for bearing the risk that can be removed.

Risk lensDefinitionDiversification effect
Systematic riskAffects many securitiesCannot be eliminated
Nonsystematic riskIssuer- or security-specificCan be diversified away
Total riskIncludes all variabilityContains both components
Active riskDeviation from benchmarkBenchmark-relative, not total risk

Use total risk when the question asks for every source of variability, and use active risk when it compares a portfolio with its benchmark. An investor can keep broad exposure while holding many issuers, so a single issuer event is avoidable without giving up common exposure and should not command additional expected return.

At this level, read the risk decomposition this way.

$$ \text{Total risk} = \text{systematic risk} + \text{nonsystematic risk} $$

Read the left side as all variability in the holding or portfolio. The systematic term stays after broad diversification. The nonsystematic term falls as you spread capital across issuers, so carrying it does not justify additional expected return. Treat the equation as a decomposition of variability, not as a command to add standard deviations mechanically.

The structure is easier to remember as an investor holding several issuers. Broad exposure reaches them all, while an issuer event reaches one and can be diversified away.

Worked example

You are handed a pension fund mandate and a portfolio report. Its objective is to meet promised benefit payments, its constraint is a policy requiring diversification, and its benchmark is a broad equity benchmark. One holding moves with market conditions and also faces an issuer-specific product recall. The committee is willing to accept risk and the fund can absorb some loss, so which exposure can diversification reduce and what action fits the mandate?

GivenDetail
Client typePension fund
ObjectiveMeet promised benefit payments
ConstraintPolicy requiring diversification
BenchmarkBroad equity benchmark
Common exposureBroad market conditions
Issuer-specific exposureProduct recall
Risk willingnessWilling to accept risk
Risk capacityCan absorb some loss

The mandate details tell you how to turn a risk label into an action. The objective gives the fund’s purpose, while the constraint determines which trades are currently allowed. The benchmark supplies the comparison point for active risk. Willingness and capacity describe the client, not the source of uncertainty. Keep these facts separate: first identify what drives the loss, then decide whether reducing it fits the fund’s rules.

Loading diagram…
  1. Read the mandate before judging the holding. This identifies what the fund must achieve and what policy limits implementation, so you do not confuse a portfolio constraint with a risk source. The result is the objective and the constraint, not a risk label.

  2. Separate the exposure sources by asking whether many issuers or one issuer drives the loss. Market conditions affect many securities, so classify that exposure as systematic risk. The product recall belongs to one issuer, so classify that exposure as nonsystematic risk. The result is one systematic exposure and one nonsystematic exposure.

  3. Apply diversification to the nonsystematic part because spreading issuer-specific risk across holdings can reduce it, while diversification cannot remove broad market movement. Spreading or reducing the concentrated holding can reduce the product-recall exposure, while a broad equity allocation still carries market exposure. The result is a portfolio action that reduces avoidable risk.

  4. Check willingness and capacity separately because preference and ability are different client facts. Willingness is a preference, while capacity is the ability to absorb loss. Neither changes the risk classification or creates an expectation of extra return for diversifiable risk. The result is a risk-tolerance check that does not reclassify the exposure or justify extra return.

The decision is to retain permitted broad market exposure, reduce the issuer concentration, and monitor any deviation from the broad equity benchmark as active risk.

Changed condition

Mandate elementBeforeAfter
ConstraintPolicy requiring diversificationTemporary sale restriction
Immediate actionReduce issuer concentrationHold and plan permitted exit
Risk classificationProduct recall is nonsystematicProduct recall is nonsystematic

Only the constraint changes: a policy requiring diversification becomes a temporary sale restriction. That change leaves the risk type unchanged but shifts implementation from reducing issuer concentration to holding it and planning the permitted exit because the restriction blocks an immediate sale. The product recall remains nonsystematic because its source is still one issuer, and diversification still removes that risk in principle. Before reading the after column, classify the product recall as systematic or nonsystematic.

Common error

You see a volatile security and call its volatility systematic, then recommend it because the client says it is willing to take risk. That feels right because a higher-risk choice seems to fit a client who accepts risk. What gives it away is the source, because volatility from one issuer falls through diversification and willingness cannot turn nonsystematic risk into compensated risk.

Check yourself

Practice

A single issuer's product recall causes the holding's volatility. Which classification and portfolio response are most appropriate?

Which statement correctly distinguishes total risk from active risk?

A client is willing to accept a volatile single-issuer holding, but the volatility comes from an issuer-specific event. What is the best recommendation?

Classify each statement.

Systematic riskNonsystematic riskRisk willingnessObjectiveConstraint
Broad economic slowdown
Issuer product recall
Client accepts risk
Meet promised benefits
Sale restriction

Revision snapshot

$$ \text{Total risk} = \text{systematic risk} + \text{nonsystematic risk} $$

Systematic risk affects many securities and cannot be eliminated by diversification. Nonsystematic risk is issuer- or security-specific and can be diversified away. An investor should not expect additional return for bearing diversifiable nonsystematic risk. Total risk includes all variability. Active risk is deviation from the benchmark. Risk willingness is a preference. Risk capacity is the ability to absorb loss. An objective states what the portfolio must achieve. A constraint limits implementation.

Exam focusYour move
Volatile holdingFind the source, not the size
Client riskSeparate willingness from capacity
MandateSeparate objective, constraint, benchmark

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Systematic vs non-systematic risk

  1. 1. An investor has risk-aversion coefficient 4 and utility U = E(R) - 0.5Aσ². Portfolios A, B, and C have expected return and standard deviation of 8% and 10%, 10% and 15%, and 12% and 20%, respectively. The highest-utility portfolio is:

    • A. Portfolio A
    • B. Portfolio B
    • C. Portfolio C
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Portfolio A

    Portfolio A - With a risk-aversion coefficient of 4, utility is 0.08 − 0.5(4)(0.10²) = 0.060. - That exceeds Portfolio B’s 0.055 and Portfolio C’s 0.040, so Portfolio A has the highest utility. Portfolio B - Its utility is 0.10 − 0.5(4)(0.15²) = 0.055, below Portfolio A’s 0.060. - Its higher expected return does not offset the risk penalty from its 15% standard deviation. Portfolio C - Its utility is 0.12 − 0.5(4)(0.20²) = 0.040, the lowest of the three. - Although it has the highest expected return, its 20% standard deviation produces the largest risk penalty.

  2. 2. The Arbordale Sovereign Fund receives revenue from a mature natural-resource sector and supports the government's long-term fiscal program. The fund's dual objective is to finance predictable annual distributions while preserving the real value of its assets after investment expenses. Resource revenue is expected to decline gradually, so the investment committee does not treat uncertain future revenue as available liquidity. The portfolio policy statement requires an annual distribution equal to 4.0% of beginning-of-year assets. Long-term expected inflation is 2.5%, and annual investment expenses are expected to equal 0.4% of assets. The required nominal return must incorporate compounding among the distribution, inflation, and expense components. The committee evaluates strategic allocations using expected nominal geometric returns consistent with that calculation. The fund has a long horizon and can accept moderate short-term volatility, but it must not assume risk beyond its governance capacity. Strategic portfolio volatility may not exceed 14.0%. At least 70% of assets must be realizable within 30 days under normal market conditions, and total alternative investments may not exceed 25%. The alternatives allocation includes private equity, infrastructure, real estate, and other investments lacking continuous public-market liquidity. All three candidate portfolios in Exhibit 1 are adequately diversified across public equities, investment-grade bonds, cash, and alternative investments. The committee also maintains a formal liquidity reserve. The reserve must cover two full years of policy distributions and all committed capital calls expected during the reserve horizon. Certain contributions arriving before the related payments may offset the reserve requirement, but uncertain resource receipts may not. The distribution amounts used in the reserve calculation are based on the fund's current USD 10.0 billion asset value. Arbordale's fiscal obligations and distributions are denominated in USD. The portfolio includes foreign government bonds and global equities. The foreign bonds are held primarily for capital preservation and diversification against equity risk, whereas global equities are expected to generate long-term growth. The committee accepts some currency exposure in the equity portfolio but does not want exchange-rate movements to dominate the risk of its defensive fixed-income allocation. Hedging costs are assumed reasonable and do not change the strategic conclusion.

    • 3. An investor refuses to sell shares she received as a wedding gift solely because ownership makes them seem more valuable than identical shares she does not own. This behavior is best described as:

      • A. Endowment bias
      • B. Representativeness bias
      • C. Mental accounting bias
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Endowment bias

      Endowment bias - Endowment bias makes the investor value the wedding-gift shares more highly simply because she owns them. - Her refusal to sell rests on ownership, not on any stated difference between those shares and identical shares she does not own. Representativeness bias - Representativeness bias involves judging an investment by how closely it resembles a familiar category, often without adequately considering base rates. - The investor makes no such comparison; she values the shares more because they are hers. Mental accounting bias - Mental accounting bias involves treating economically interchangeable assets differently because they are assigned to separate conceptual accounts. - Although the shares were a wedding gift, the stated reason for refusing to sell is ownership itself, not a separate account for gifted assets.

    • 4. A portfolio has expected return of 8.00%, standard deviation of 12.00%, and investor risk-aversion coefficient of 4. The calculated value of mean–variance utility is closest to:

      • A. 2.24%
      • B. 5.00%
      • C. 5.12%
      Show answer

      Answer: C. 5.12%

      5.12% - Mean–variance utility is expected return minus one-half the risk-aversion coefficient times return variance: \(U=E(R)-\tfrac12A\sigma^2\). - Using the stated figures, \(U=8.00\%-\tfrac12(4)(12.00\%)^2=8.00\%-2.88\%=\mathbf{5.12\%}\). 2.24% - Subtracting the full risk-aversion coefficient times variance, rather than half of it, gives \(8.00\%-4(0.12^2)=2.24\%\). - The mean–variance formula requires the one-half factor, so the risk penalty is 2.88%, not 5.76%. 5.00% - Prematurely rounding the 2.88% risk penalty to 3% gives \(8.00\%-3.00\%=5.00\%\). - Retaining the calculated penalty yields \(8.00\%-2.88\%=\mathbf{5.12\%}\).

    • 5. The Arbordale Reserve Fund is a sovereign wealth fund established to transfer resource revenue across generations. Its investment objective is to maximize long-term real wealth while making an annual distribution equal to 3% of beginning-of-year assets to the national budget. The board has a 20-year planning horizon and above-average ability to bear short-term market volatility. Because distributions must continue during stressed markets, the investment policy requires short-term government securities equal to at least two years of scheduled distributions, or 6% of fund assets. The fund may allocate no more than 20% of assets to private investments because of illiquidity, valuation uncertainty, and the staff resources required to oversee external partnerships. Leverage at the total-fund level is prohibited. The board has adopted a maximum volatility ceiling of 12% for the strategic allocation and instructs staff to select the highest expected real-return allocation that satisfies all explicit policy limits. Exhibit 2 presents three complete candidate strategic allocations developed using consistent capital market assumptions. Assets not shown in the final two columns consist of diversified public equities and investment-grade fixed income. The fund also maintains an active global equity mandate benchmarked to a broad capitalization-weighted index. The risk team models active return using value, momentum, and quality factors plus a residual component. Exhibit 1 reports the mandate's active factor exposures, annualized factor volatilities, and residual active volatility. The three factor returns and the residual return are assumed to be mutually uncorrelated. Risk contributions are measured as contributions to active variance rather than contributions to active standard deviation. For total-fund market-risk monitoring, the risk team reports a one-day 95% value at risk of USD 12 million. To provide the board with a 10-day estimate, the chief risk officer proposes square-root-of-time scaling. For this calculation only, daily portfolio returns are assumed to be independent and identically distributed, portfolio positions are unchanged, and the one-day model remains valid throughout the 10-day horizon. The chief risk officer cautions that this scaling approach would be less reliable if returns exhibited serial correlation, volatility changed materially, or the portfolio contained nonlinear exposures, but none of those complications is assumed for the requested estimate.

      Flashcards: Systematic vs non-systematic risk

      1. 1. In Portfolio Management, what does the diversification ratio measure?

        Show answer

        The ratio of the risk of an equally weighted portfolio of \(n\) securities to the risk of a single security selected at random from the \(n\) securities. A lower ratio indicates greater diversification benefits.

      2. 2. In Portfolio Management (Risk and Return), what is the difference between the risk measures on the x-axis of the CML versus the SML?

        Show answer

        The CML uses total risk (\(\sigmap\)), while the SML uses systematic risk (Beta).

      3. 3. What is Roy's safety-first criterion?

        Show answer

        The optimal portfolio minimizes the probability that the portfolio return falls below a minimum acceptable threshold level.

      4. 4. In the Safety-First Ratio formula, what does \(RL\) represent?

        Show answer

        The minimum acceptable threshold level return.

      5. 5. When applying Roy's safety-first criterion, which portfolio is considered optimal?

        Show answer

        The portfolio with the highest safety-first ratio (SFRatio), as it has the lowest shortfall probability.

      6. 6. What formula do you use to calculate the Safety-First Ratio (SFRatio)?

        Show answer

        \[\text{SFRatio} = \frac{E(Rp) - RL}{\sigmap}\]

      7. 7. What is shortfall risk?

        Show answer

        The probability that a portfolio's value or return will fall below a specific target value over a given period.

      8. 8. In Portfolio Management (Risk and Return), what does the Capital Allocation Line (CAL) represent?

        Show answer

        The line of possible portfolio risk and return combinations created by combining a risk-free asset with a portfolio of risky assets.

      9. 9. In Portfolio Management (Risk and Return), what is the minimum-variance frontier?

        Show answer

        The curve representing portfolios that have the lowest standard deviation of returns for each given level of expected return.

      10. 10. In Portfolio Management (Risk and Return), what are "borrowing portfolios" on the CML?

        Show answer

        Portfolios to the right of the market portfolio created by borrowing at the risk-free rate to invest more than 100% of the portfolio's net value in the market portfolio.

      Everything you need for CFA prep

      Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

      GET STARTED FOR FREE
      75% OFFLimited time offer
      GET 75% OFF