Preventing violations of Standard III

Preventing violations of Standard III

Published September 28, 2026

Preventing violations of Standard III

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code and Standards.

On the exam: You get an ambiguous client-service fact pattern with an actor, material facts, affected clients, and a requested prevention procedure. You recommend a case-specific control in a constructed response or select the compliant control in an MCQ.

An ethics case does not ask for a generic policy. It gives you an actor, a material fact, and clients who may be affected. You name the exact Standard III duty, then recommend a control that changes what the manager does before the decision. Disclosure can identify a risk, but it is not automatically the control that makes conduct compliant.

ProvisionAffected partyRequired conduct
Standard III.A (Loyalty, Prudence, and Care)ClientsExercise reasonable care, prudent judgment, put clients first
Standard III.B (Fair Dealing)All clientsDeal fairly and objectively
Standard III.C (Suitability)Advisory clients, mandate portfoliosInquire, document, assess total portfolio, update
Standard III.D (Performance Presentation)Clients receiving performancePresent fairly, accurately, completely
Standard III.E (Preservation of Confidentiality)Current, former, prospective clientsPreserve confidentiality, subject to exceptions

For an advisory client, inquire before a recommendation or action, document objectives and constraints, assess the total portfolio, and update regularly. A portfolio managed to a specific mandate, strategy, or style must remain consistent with its stated objectives and constraints.

Build the recommendation as a chain. Start with who is affected, connect the material fact to the governing provision, and finish with the procedure.

$$ \text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{governing provision} \rightarrow \text{preventive procedure} $$

The opening part prevents a vague answer. The middle part names the exact duty. The final part tells the portfolio manager to stop, check, allocate objectively, update information, review performance, or restrict access. If conduct is already prohibited, the procedure starts with stopping or correcting it, not disclosure.

ClassificationConductResponse
RequiredMeet the applicable Standard III dutyApply before recommendation or action
RecommendedAdd a prevention controlTailor it to the material risk
PermittedMeet a stated exception or conditionConfirm facts and record them
ProhibitedBreach the applicable dutyStop or correct. Disclosure cannot cure.

An employer relationship, stale information, or a selective performance request is a risk signal before action. Acting despite a mandate conflict, treating comparable clients differently, or presenting incomplete performance crosses into a Standard III violation. Disclosure can reveal the signal, but it cannot cure the violation. Consent has a limited place under III.E when a client or prospective client permits information disclosure, but it does not authorize unfair treatment or unsuitable action.

Use this order when the question asks for a prevention procedure.

Loading diagram…

Worked example

You are the portfolio manager for client mandates. A scarce allocation favors the employer’s largest relationship although other clients have comparable mandates. The favored account’s written concentration constraint conflicts with the proposed position, and related exposure is already in its total portfolio. Client risk information is stale, the manager plans to show only a favorable performance period, and you must recommend a prevention procedure that names the affected parties and governing provisions.

Case elementGiven
ActorPortfolio manager
Material factsScarce allocation, employer relationship, comparable mandates
Suitability factsWritten constraint, related exposure, stale risk data
Performance factFavorable period only
Affected partiesFavored client, comparable clients, employer
Governing provisionsIII.A, III.B, III.C, III.D

Read the case elements together before choosing an action. The employer relationship explains the allocation pressure, while the written constraint, related exposure, and stale risk data require a separate suitability review. The favorable-only performance plan raises its own presentation issue. The route below turns those facts into a sequence: protect each affected client, apply the relevant duty, and pause any action that fails a check.

  1. Identify the actor and affected parties. The portfolio manager acts for the favored client and comparable clients, while the employer has the competing relationship interest. Do this first because the allocation must be judged against client duties rather than the employer’s preference. The result is an affected-party list of the portfolio manager, favored client, comparable clients, and employer, with Standard III.A and III.B governing the allocation.

  2. Apply Standard III.A and III.B before discussing consent. Do this because client interests must come before the employer’s relationship, and all clients must receive fair, objective treatment. The result is a documented, objective allocation procedure with review before the scarce allocation is made.

  3. Apply Standard III.C to the favored account. Update the stale risk information, document objectives and constraints, and assess the position in the total portfolio. These steps are required because the proposed action conflicts with the written constraint and existing exposure. The result is a no-go suitability decision, so do not recommend or take the position.

  4. Apply Standard III.D to the communication. Require a review that blocks an incomplete favorable-only presentation. Do this because the client must receive performance information that is fair, accurate, and complete. The result is a communication held back until the full performance presentation passes review.

  5. Combine the results into a client-first, fair, suitable, and complete outcome. The allocation review, current client profile, total-portfolio check, and performance review are recommended controls because each addresses a separate conflict or information failure. Proceeding is permitted only after the checks pass. Acting on the mandate conflict or presenting incomplete performance is prohibited. Disclosure may reveal the risk, but it does not cure either problem.

The decision is to withhold the allocation and revise the performance communication.

Changed condition

You keep every fact above except suitability fit. The proposed position now matches the written mandate and total portfolio. Predict what changes before reading the explanation.

FactBeforeAfter
Suitability fitConflicts with mandate and portfolioConsistent with mandate and portfolio
Allocation motiveEmployer relationship influences choiceSame
Performance planFavorable period onlySame

Standard III.C’s objection falls away, so the suitability check now confirms fit rather than stopping the proposed action. The stale information still requires an update. Standard III.A and III.B still block employer-influenced allocation, and Standard III.D still blocks an incomplete favorable-only presentation. The manager still cannot proceed, but the suitability objection has been removed.

Before reading on, write the preventive control for the remaining allocation risk.

Common error

You may write, “Give full disclosure and obtain the client’s consent.” That answer feels right because the client appears able to choose after receiving the facts. But the adviser still cannot put the employer’s or manager’s interest first, and the client’s permission does not make prohibited conduct acceptable. The governing provisions give you the test: Standard III.A requires client-first loyalty, Standard III.B requires fair and objective treatment, and Standard III.C and III.D require suitable action and complete performance. Disclosure cannot cure a breach of those duties.

Go deeper

When you apply Standard III.E, protect information about a current, former, or prospective client before you share it. The client or prospective client may permit disclosure, the law may require it, or the information may concern the client’s or prospective client’s illegal activities. For each exception, check which basis applies, share only what that basis permits, and record your decision. A client’s permission can make the disclosure acceptable under III.E, but it cannot excuse a separate breach of Standard III, such as trading on material nonpublic information or misusing confidential information.

Check yourself

Practice

recommend

Recommend a preventive procedure for the scarce-allocation case and identify the governing Standard III provision.

A portfolio manager has an advisory client with stale risk information and a written mandate. Which preventive procedure best addresses Standard III.C?

Revision snapshot

Build the answer as $\text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{governing provision} \rightarrow \text{preventive procedure}$. Name the actor, material fact, affected party, exact provision, and case-specific control. Required duties are not the same as recommended procedures. A risk signal calls for a control. A violation calls for stopping or correcting. Disclosure can reveal a risk but is not a universal cure. Consent can permit a confidentiality disclosure under III.E but does not authorize unfair, unsuitable, or incomplete conduct.

  • Standard III.A (Loyalty, Prudence, and Care). Place clients’ interests before the employer’s and the member’s or candidate’s own interests.
  • Standard III.B (Fair Dealing). Deal fairly and objectively with all clients.
  • Standard III.C (Suitability). Inquire, document objectives and constraints, assess investments in the total portfolio, and update client information regularly.
  • Standards III.D-E. Present performance fairly, accurately, and completely. Preserve current, former, and prospective client confidentiality subject to stated exceptions.
  • Prevention decision. Distinguish disclosure from consent and prohibited conduct from conduct that merely creates risk.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Preventing violations of Standard III

  1. 1. An investment manager directs client brokerage commissions to a broker in exchange for research that benefits only the manager's own personal account, without disclosing this arrangement to clients. The manager has most likely violated the duty of:

    • A. Loyalty, Prudence, and Care
    • B. Suitability
    • C. Fair Dealing
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Loyalty, Prudence, and Care

    Loyalty, Prudence, and Care - Under CFA Standard III(A), the manager must use client brokerage commissions for the clients’ benefit, not to obtain research benefiting only the manager’s personal account. - Directing those commissions to the broker for a personal benefit, without telling clients, puts the manager’s interests ahead of the clients’ interests. Suitability - Suitability concerns whether an investment is appropriate for a client’s objectives and constraints. - The issue here is misuse of client brokerage commissions, not an unsuitable investment recommendation. Fair Dealing - Fair Dealing requires equitable treatment of clients when providing investment analysis, making recommendations, or taking investment action. - The facts describe a personal benefit at clients’ expense, not unequal treatment among clients.

  2. 2. Daniel Moreno, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Atlas Advisory. He manages discretionary private-client accounts under investment policy statements that require clients to notify Atlas of material changes in objectives or constraints. Client Clara Reilly informs Moreno by email that she has adopted an immediate restriction against owning fossil-fuel producers. Her existing IPS contains no such restriction. Moreno reads the email before the market opens but plans to wait until the scheduled annual review in three months to amend the IPS. That morning, he considers purchasing shares of an oil producer for Reilly because he believes the shares offer an attractive risk-adjusted return and are otherwise consistent with her risk tolerance. Moreno also manages several accounts with substantially similar mandates. Atlas uses aggregated orders when the same security is suitable for multiple accounts and allocates partially filled orders to client accounts pro rata based on the original order quantities. Moreno submits an aggregated purchase order for shares of Lydon Technologies for five suitable client accounts. Ten minutes later, before execution begins, he submits a personal purchase order for the same security. Lydon is oversubscribed, and only 60% of the total requested shares are available. Moreno's personal order was entered after every client order. Two of the client accounts pay Atlas performance-based fees, while the other three pay asset-based fees. The trustee of a pension plan managed by Moreno is pleased with the portfolio's recent results. Without Atlas's knowledge, the trustee offers Moreno a personal cash bonus equal to 5% of any portfolio return above the plan's benchmark during the coming year. The proposed payment would be made directly by the pension plan, not by Atlas. Moreno intends to continue following the plan's mandate and believes the arrangement will motivate him to work harder. Atlas permits external compensation arrangements if the requirements of the CFA Institute Standards are satisfied. Atlas also has an arrangement with Finley Tax Partners. Moreno recommends Finley to private clients who need tax advice, and Finley pays Atlas USD 500 for each referred client who signs an engagement. Moreno does not receive the payment personally, but the amount contributes to the revenue used to determine his annual bonus. Atlas's marketing brochure identifies Finley as an external tax adviser but does not state that Atlas receives referral payments. Moreno provides the brochure to current and prospective clients before recommending Finley.

    • 3. Elena Park, CFA, is an equity analyst at Northbridge Securities. Northbridge policy states that research models, analyst notes, client lists, and unpublished reports created during employment are firm property. Park accepts an offer from another firm. Before resigning, she emails herself Northbridge's client list and copies her valuation models to a personal drive. After resigning, she plans to use the copied materials to contact clients and continue covering the same issuers. Public regulatory filings contain sufficient information to recreate the models, but Park has not yet done so. Before her departure, Park prepares a recommendation on Vireo Systems. She supplements public filings and management interviews with industry forecasts purchased from an independent research vendor. Northbridge previously reviewed the vendor's staffing, data sources, estimation procedures, and historical accuracy. Park reads the report, evaluates its assumptions against public industry data, and concludes that the methodology is reasonable. She retains documentation of this review in Northbridge's research files. Vireo's chief executive offers Park a personal cash payment if the company's share price exceeds a specified level within six months after publication of her report. Park believes the payment would not affect her judgment. She orally informs her supervisor and intends to accept the offer without notifying Vireo's board or obtaining written consent from either party. During final review, Park's supervisor instructs her to increase Vireo's target price substantially so that Northbridge can win an investment-banking mandate. The supervisor provides no new information supporting the increase. Park determines that the higher target price lacks a reasonable basis. Local law does not require analysts to document target-price assumptions, but it prohibits knowingly publishing materially misleading research. Northbridge's compliance manual requires documented support for every published recommendation. After Park resigns, Northbridge asks her to leave immediately but does not impose a non-compete agreement. Park returns her office equipment but retains the copied client list and valuation files. She also retains a personal directory containing only publicly available issuer contact information that she compiled before joining Northbridge.

      • 4. Elena Maric, CFA, is a technology analyst at Northbridge Securities. She has maintained a sell recommendation on Calder Systems for three months. Her conclusion is supported by public industry shipment data, interviews with suppliers that did not disclose confidential customer information, and her own analysis of Calder's published financial statements. Northbridge's compliance manual requires analysts to report potentially material nonpublic information immediately and permits compliance to place an issuer on the firm's restricted list. During a confidential instant-message exchange, Calder's chief executive gives Maric the information reproduced in Exhibit 1. Maric had already completed most of a report reiterating her sell recommendation before the exchange. She reasons that she may publish because her original conclusion was developed from public and immaterial nonpublic information. She proposes deleting any direct reference to the customer volume reduction while leaving her revenue forecast unchanged. Calder's CEO also asks her to postpone publication until after an investor presentation. He states that analysts who accommodate the request will continue to receive access to senior management, whereas analysts publishing unfavorable research may receive only information distributed through normal public channels. Maric's draft contains industry analysis prepared by her team. It also contains the material described in Exhibit 1, which a junior analyst copied from a report available through Northbridge's paid research subscription. The junior analyst changed several headings and chart colors but did not identify the external analyst. Maric has not yet checked the source of those sections. Separately, a Northbridge trader manages a small fund whose annual performance fee is determined using the last quoted prices on 31 December. Shortly before the market closes, the trader enters a series of small purchase orders in thinly traded portfolio securities. Internal messages show that he expects the orders to raise closing prices enough to increase the fund's reported return and performance fee. The orders are genuine orders that can be executed, but the trader has no investment view supporting the purchases. Northbridge has no client transaction awaiting execution in those securities. Maric asks the compliance department to assess the issuer information, the CEO's requested publication delay, the unattributed research material, and the trader's year-end transactions under the CFA Institute Code and Standards.

        • 5. An analyst in Country X serves clients in Country Y. Both countries permit conduct prohibited by the Code and Standards. The analyst should most likely:

          • A. Follow the CFA Institute requirement and notify compliance
          • B. Follow Country X law because it governs the local office
          • C. Follow Country Y law because the clients reside there
          Show answer

          Answer: A. Follow the CFA Institute requirement and notify compliance

          Follow the CFA Institute requirement and notify compliance - Because both countries permit conduct prohibited by the Code and Standards, the analyst must follow the stricter CFA Institute requirement. - Notifying compliance helps the analyst address the conflict between that requirement and the conduct permitted in Countries X and Y. Follow Country X law because it governs the local office - Country X’s law may apply to the local office, but its permission does not override the Code and Standards. - Following that permission would allow the analyst to engage in conduct the Code and Standards prohibit. Follow Country Y law because the clients reside there - The clients’ residence does not make Country Y’s permissive law the analyst’s controlling ethical standard. - Country Y also permits the prohibited conduct, so following its law alone would not satisfy the Code and Standards.

        • 6. Sofia Moreno, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Meridian Wealth Advisers. One client, the Hartwell Family Trust, has a written mandate requiring daily liquidity and prohibiting private placements. Moreno is offered shares in a private renewable-energy company that expects to conduct an initial public offering within 18 months. She considers the company attractive and proposes a 1% position for Hartwell, reasoning that the small allocation would not materially affect the account's overall liquidity. The trustees have not amended the mandate. Moreno also chairs Meridian's investment committee. After completing updated research, the committee decides to lower its rating on a widely held public company from buy to sell. Meridian's written policy requires material recommendation changes to be posted simultaneously to its research portal and distributed through an automated client email system. Before using that process, Moreno considers telephoning several clients with the largest positions so they can trade before the expected price decline. All affected clients are entitled to receive the firm's research service, although their objectives and holdings differ. Separately, Moreno learns about an oversubscribed public offering that she expects Meridian will recommend for several eligible discretionary accounts. The firm's personal-trading policy permits employees to participate in public offerings only after eligible client and employer orders have been satisfied and after receiving compliance approval. No client orders have yet been entered because the investment committee meeting is scheduled for the following morning. Moreno wants to submit a personal order that evening through an account beneficially owned by her spouse. She plans to disclose the account on her next quarterly personal-transaction report. In addition, a broker-dealer that regularly executes trades for Meridian's clients sends Moreno a modest holiday gift. Meridian's gift policy requires employees to disclose any gift from a client, broker, or vendor that could reasonably be perceived to affect independence and judgment, regardless of the gift's value. A charitable foundation that is also a Meridian client asks Moreno to serve as an external adviser for a new investment committee. The work would occur outside Meridian's normal business hours, but the foundation proposes to pay Moreno directly based partly on the foundation portfolio's performance. The assignment would overlap with services Meridian currently provides to the foundation. Moreno has not yet informed Meridian, and neither Meridian nor the foundation has provided written consent to the arrangement. Meridian's employment agreement permits outside work only when the employee discloses the proposed duties and compensation and obtains the firm's written approval. Moreno believes disclosure in Meridian's next annual client brochure would be sufficient because the foundation already knows both her employer and the proposed compensation terms.

          Flashcards: Preventing violations of Standard III

          1. 1. Duties to Clients\ Ethics

            Show answer

            - Loyalty, prudence, care - Fair dealing - Suitability - Performance presentation - Preservation of confidentiality

          2. 2. CFA ethics: IPS be updated at least?

            Show answer

            annually

          Everything you need for CFA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF