Preventing violations of Standard II

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code and Standards.

On the exam. You get an actor, a material fact, a proposed action, and an existing or missing control. State the conclusion under Standard II, then recommend a procedure that would prevent the conduct on these facts in constructed response or selected response.

Standard II asks you to protect the market before a questionable trade or message becomes a market event. One route uses information the market does not have. The other creates a false picture of price or demand. At Level III, name the exact Standard II provision, state what the actor must stop, and recommend a case-specific control such as a restricted list, information barrier, order hold, communication review, surveillance, escalation, or records.

StandardFact that mattersProhibited conduct
Standard II.A, Material Nonpublic InformationPossess material nonpublic informationTake investment action or cause others to act on it
Standard II.B, Market ManipulationPractice that distorts prices or artificially inflates trading volume with intent to misleadDistort prices or artificially inflate trading volume

Standard II.A applies when a person possesses material nonpublic information and takes investment action or causes someone else to act on it. Standard II.B applies when a person engages in a practice that distorts prices or artificially inflates trading volume with intent to mislead market participants. Your recommendation should match that trigger rather than merely cite a general compliance policy.

Material means the information could affect investment value. Nonpublic means the information has not been broadly disseminated to the market. An unusual order, rumor, or volume signal is not automatically proof of a violation, but it is enough to start a control review.

Use this sequence when the facts are incomplete. It tells you what to do before deciding whether the conduct crossed the line.

$$ \text{identify trigger} \rightarrow \text{restrict activity} \rightarrow \text{escalate} \rightarrow \text{document} \rightarrow \text{resume only on an authorized basis} $$

Identify the trigger by testing the information source, public status, proposed action, and apparent purpose. Restricting activity can mean stopping trading, tipping, suspected rumor-spreading, or suspect orders while review is open. Escalation sends the facts to compliance or the control owner, and documentation preserves the source, timing, instructions, orders, messages, and decisions. Resume only when authorized review confirms a permitted basis.

Loading diagram…

Read from branch to control. For Standard II.A, ask what the actor possesses and place affected securities and related positions on a restricted list, block trading, and prevent tipping until the information is public or authorized review finds no prohibited use. For Standard II.B, ask what the actor intends market participants to believe and review orders, communications, and trading patterns for artificial price or volume signals. The branches stay separate even when one case contains both facts.

Disclosure to compliance is the escalation step, not permission to trade. Disclosure to a client or affected party does not cure a false market signal or permit a prohibited plan.

Stopping prohibited conduct is required, while restricted lists, information barriers, escalation, surveillance, and records are recommended controls. For II.A, tie restricted lists, need-to-know access, no-tipping instructions, preclearance, and records to the information source and proposed action. For II.B, tie order and communication surveillance, review of unusual price or volume activity, and escalation of suspected rumors or artificial orders to the intended market signal. Do not present a control as permission to continue trading, tipping, or misleading conduct that Standard II prohibits.

Use the order below in your constructed response. Each step gives the control move before the next decision.

Loading diagram…

If the answer is no, keep the activity restricted. If a signal remains unconfirmed, control the activity without claiming that a violation is proven.

Worked example

You are handed a confidential acquisition plan as a portfolio manager. The plan could affect the value of the target investment, and a colleague suggests that you trade before the plan becomes public or tell another portfolio manager. The exam asks you to state the governing Standard II conclusion and recommend a prevention procedure.

GivenFact
ActorPortfolio manager
Material factConfidential acquisition plan
Proposed actionTrade or tip
Existing controlNo restricted list or barrier
RecordNo escalation record

Read the control gaps as part of the fact pattern: the manager has no restricted list, no information barrier, and no escalation record. That means the firm has not yet blocked the proposed trade or tip, limited access to the plan, or preserved a review trail. Start by stopping both actions, then apply the controls that address each gap.

.

  1. Identify the trigger. Treat the plan as material nonpublic information because it is confidential and could affect the investment's value. This produces the governing conclusion under Standard II.A: the manager has material nonpublic information and cannot trade or tip.

  2. Restrict activity. Stop the trade and the tip because acting or passing the information would misuse confidential information. Put the investment on the restricted list and apply the information barrier, which blocks the manager and connected people from acting. This produces a restricted investment with the barrier active and no permitted trade or tip.

  3. Escalate. Send the facts to compliance or the designated control owner because that person must review the restriction and proposed conduct. This produces a documented escalation and starts review, but it does not authorize the trade.

  4. Document. Record the source, recipients, proposed action, restriction, escalation, and decisions because the firm needs an audit trail of how it controlled the information. This produces a complete record of the control response.

  5. Resume only on an authorized basis. Keep the investment restricted until the authorized process permits resumption because the restriction remains in place while the information is nonpublic. If no authorization arrives, do not trade or tip. This produces either an authorized resumption or continued restriction.

The conclusion is that the portfolio manager must not trade or tip, so the prevention procedure is to escalate, place the investment on the restricted list behind an information barrier, and keep records before any authorized resumption.

Changed condition

Keep the review process the same, but change the proposed activity. The portfolio manager now coordinates misleading rumors with trades intended to create false demand.

FactBeforeAfter
ActorPortfolio managerPortfolio manager
TriggerConfidential acquisition planConfidential acquisition plan
Proposed conductTrade or tipTrades to create false demand

Predict the movement before looking at the conclusion. The governing provision moves from Standard II.A to Standard II.B because the decisive fact is intent to mislead through price or volume distortion, not possession of confidential information. The portfolio manager must reject the plan, trigger escalation and surveillance, and document the facts. If the evidence is only an unusual signal without misleading intent, restrict and escalate for review, but do not state that a violation is proven.

Before reading on, identify the governing provision for the changed conduct.

Common error

A candidate tells compliance, the client, or an affected party and treats that disclosure as permission to proceed with the trade or rumor campaign. That feels right because transparency and consent seem to remove the ethical problem. The proposed action still uses material nonpublic information or retains intent to mislead, so your recommendation is to stop, restrict, escalate, and document rather than proceed.

Check yourself

Practice

recommend

A portfolio manager receives a confidential acquisition plan and proposes a trade or tip. Recommend the governing Standard and the initial control action.

A portfolio manager possesses a confidential acquisition plan, tells compliance and a client, then trades before public release. Which conclusion is best?

A trader coordinates misleading rumors with trades intended to create false demand. Which recommendation best prevents a Standard II.B violation?

Revision snapshot

Standard II.A requires that a person who possesses material nonpublic information must not act or cause others to act on it. Standard II.B requires that a person must not distort prices or artificially inflate trading volume with intent to mislead market participants.

CaseDecision and control
Portfolio manager, acquisition planNo trade or tip, escalate, restricted list, information barrier, record
Trader, rumor campaignReject plan, escalate, surveillance, document

Use the prevention sequence: identify the trigger, restrict activity, escalate, document, and resume only on an authorized basis. Disclosure to compliance, a client, or an affected party does not cure prohibited trading or manipulation. A suspicious signal starts review but is not automatically proof of a violation. The exam gives you the actor, material fact, proposed action, and control gap, then asks for the Standard II conclusion and a case-specific recommendation.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Preventing violations of Standard II

  1. 1. Daniel Ellis is chief investment officer and designated supervisor at Summit Peak Asset Management. The firm has written trading controls, pre-clearance requirements, and an electronic exception-reporting system. Compliance sends Ellis a credible alert showing that a trader may have allocated favorable executions to a proprietary account and unfavorable executions to client accounts. The conduct may still be continuing. Ellis considers merely reminding the trader of the allocation policy and waiting to see whether any client reports a loss. Summit Peak's procedures authorize Ellis to restrict trading access while an investigation is conducted. Ellis has also entered negotiations with an independent pension consultant. The consultant proposes paying Ellis personally USD 2,000 for each institutional prospect referred to the consultant. The payment would not increase the prospect's stated consulting fee, but it could influence Ellis's recommendations. No referrals have yet occurred. Ellis considers disclosing the arrangement only after a referred prospect signs a contract. Summit Peak has no prior knowledge of the proposed payments. The firm's marketing director is preparing a presentation for prospective clients. Summit Peak manages 22 discretionary, fee-paying accounts using substantially the same small-cap equity strategy. The director wants to present the returns of the strategy's strongest account and describe those results as typical. Complete performance records are available for all 22 accounts, including terminated accounts. Summit Peak can construct a composite containing all portfolios managed under the strategy and can disclose the composite's construction, fees, and relevant calculation methods. The firm claims compliance with the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct, although it does not claim compliance with any separate performance-reporting standard. A junior analyst, Carla Moreno, passed Level II of the CFA Program two years ago. She is not currently registered for Level III and has not satisfied the work-experience requirement for the CFA charter. Moreno asks Ellis to approve one of three descriptions for the firm's website: 'CFA Level II charterholder,' 'CFA charter expected after Level III,' or 'Passed Level II of the CFA Program.' She has never claimed to be a CFA charterholder and remains eligible to register for a future examination.

    • 2. A supervisor receives credible evidence that an employee traded personally before pending client orders. Existing controls failed to flag the trades. Which action is most appropriate?

      • A. Warn the employee and permit trading to continue
      • B. Report the matter only after confirming client losses
      • C. Restrict the employee's trading authority and investigate promptly
      Show answer

      Answer: C. Restrict the employee's trading authority and investigate promptly

      Restrict the employee's trading authority and investigate promptly - Credible evidence of personal trades before pending client orders calls for prompt investigation under the CFA Institute Standards of Professional Conduct. - Because existing controls failed to flag the trades, restricting the employee’s trading authority is a reasonable step to prevent further misconduct while the supervisor investigates. Warn the employee and permit trading to continue - A warning alone leaves the employee able to trade ahead of pending client orders again. - The failed controls make continued unrestricted trading inconsistent with the supervisor’s duty to take reasonable preventive steps. Report the matter only after confirming client losses - Supervisory action is required when credible evidence indicates possible misconduct; it does not depend on proven client losses. - Waiting to confirm losses would delay investigation and leave the employee’s trading authority unrestricted.

    • 3. Asha Patel, CFA, is an equity analyst at Meridian Securities and covers Volaris Systems, a listed manufacturer. Volaris is followed by many analysts, and its shares trade actively. During a publicly accessible industry conference webcast, Volaris's chief financial officer states that current customer inquiries are the strongest in five years. The statement is simultaneously available to all webcast participants and is later posted on the company's investor-relations website. After the webcast, Patel speaks privately with a senior manager at a component supplier that receives approximately 40% of its revenue from Volaris. The supplier manager states that Volaris reduced its next-quarter component orders by 35% two days earlier. The reduction has not been announced, and no public source reports it. Based on her knowledge of Volaris's cost structure and sales cycle, Patel concludes that the reduction would cause Volaris to miss the market's next-quarter earnings estimate by a substantial amount. She immediately drafts a sell recommendation and asks Meridian's trading desk to sell shares held in discretionary client accounts. Another Meridian analyst, Eric Liu, is independently researching Volaris. Over several weeks, Liu observes reduced nighttime activity at two third-party warehouses used by Volaris. Each observation is available from public roads and, considered separately, is not material. Liu combines these observations with published shipping statistics, publicly available employment advertisements, and Volaris's historical inventory disclosures. He documents every source and concludes that production is slowing. Volaris subsequently invites Patel and all other covering analysts to visit a new production facility. The company offers to pay business-class airfare, two nights at a luxury hotel, and a modest working lunch at the facility. Commercial flights and hotels are readily available, and Meridian's policy permits the firm to pay reasonable analyst travel expenses. Patel believes the visit would improve her understanding of the manufacturing process. Finally, Northstar Fund, an institutional client of Meridian, holds a large position in a thinly traded small-cap issuer unrelated to Volaris. Northstar's portfolio manager asks Patel to publish a statement asserting that the issuer has received a takeover offer. The portfolio manager admits that no offer exists but expects the statement to increase trading volume, allowing Northstar to sell its position at a higher price. He proposes that Patel describe the statement as an unverified market rumor.

      • 4. A retired charterholder whose membership is active writes, “I am a CFA available for consulting assignments.” This statement is most likely:

        • A. Acceptable because the charterholder earned the designation
        • B. Unacceptable because the designation is used as a noun
        • C. Unacceptable because retired professionals cannot reference it
        Show answer

        Answer: B. Unacceptable because the designation is used as a noun

        Unacceptable because the designation is used as a noun - “I am a CFA” uses the mark as a noun referring to the person, contrary to CFA Institute’s rules for using the designation. - The retired charterholder could instead write “I am a CFA charterholder available for consulting assignments,” because membership remains active. Acceptable because the charterholder earned the designation - Earning the charter permits its proper use, but does not make “a CFA” acceptable. - The problem is how the mark is used in the statement, not whether the retired person earned the designation. Unacceptable because retired professionals cannot reference it - Retirement alone does not prevent a charterholder with active membership from referencing the designation. - This statement is unacceptable because it uses “CFA” as a noun, not because the charterholder is retired.

      • 5. A firm-owned model was prepared by an analyst who has left the firm. A portfolio manager verifies the model and incorporates it into a firm report. The manager should most likely:

        • A. Remove the analysis unless the former analyst grants permission
        • B. Use the analysis under the firm's name after verifying its reliability
        • C. Attribute the analysis to herself because she reviewed the model
        Show answer

        Answer: B. Use the analysis under the firm's name after verifying its reliability

        Use the analysis under the firm's name after verifying its reliability - The model is firm-owned, so the firm may incorporate it into its report without the former analyst’s permission. - By verifying the model, the portfolio manager establishes a reasonable basis for using its analysis. Remove the analysis unless the former analyst grants permission - The former analyst’s permission is not required because the model belongs to the firm. - The analyst’s departure does not prevent the firm from using its own work once the manager has verified it. Attribute the analysis to herself because she reviewed the model - Reviewing the model does not make the manager its creator; personal attribution would misrepresent who prepared it. - The manager may use the verified analysis under the firm’s name without claiming that she authored the underlying model.

      • 6. Local law permits client brokerage commissions to pay a manager's office rent. The Code and Standards require commissions to benefit clients. The manager should most appropriately:

        • A. Use the commissions because local law expressly permits it
        • B. Use the commissions after disclosing the practice to clients
        • C. Decline the use because it provides no client benefit
        Show answer

        Answer: C. Decline the use because it provides no client benefit

        Decline the use because it provides no client benefit - Client brokerage commissions must be used for goods or services that benefit clients, not to pay the manager’s office rent. - The manager must follow the Code and Standards because they are stricter than the local law permitting this use. Use the commissions because local law expressly permits it - Local permission does not override the stricter Code and Standards requirement that client commissions benefit clients. - Office rent benefits the manager, so its legal permissibility does not make it an appropriate use of client brokerage. Use the commissions after disclosing the practice to clients - Disclosure does not turn the manager’s office rent into a client benefit. - The commissions come from client brokerage, and the Code and Standards do not permit spending them on this manager expense.

      • 7. Sophia Lee, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Meridian Advisory. One client, Robert Davis, has a written investment policy statement calling for long-term capital growth, moderate volatility, and no direct or indirect exposure to emerging markets. Davis recently received a substantial cash contribution but has not changed his objectives or restrictions. Lee considers purchasing a global equity fund for his account. The fund has attractive expected returns and broad diversification, but its current portfolio allocates 18% to emerging-market equities. Lee believes the allocation would improve Davis's risk-adjusted return and proposes documenting that conclusion before purchasing the fund. Lee also chairs Meridian's investment committee. After completing a well-supported review, the committee changes its recommendation on a thinly traded small-cap company from hold to buy. Meridian normally distributes revised recommendations through an electronic system that sends the same report to all eligible clients and advisers in scheduled batches. Institutional clients typically receive the first batch several minutes before retail clients because of system capacity. Trading may begin after the relevant batch is transmitted; Meridian does not wait for clients to open or acknowledge the message. Lee is considering whether fair dealing requires exact simultaneous receipt or a delay until all retail clients confirm receipt. On the same day, Lee decides that the small-cap security is suitable for several discretionary client accounts and for her own account. Her personal transaction has been preapproved under Meridian's compliance policy. Market liquidity is limited, and filling her order first could increase the price paid by clients. Lee has not yet entered any of the orders and asks the trading desk whether her preapproval permits simultaneous or preferential execution. Lee has accepted an offer to join a competitor but has not informed Meridian because she has not yet resigned. She does not solicit Meridian clients or perform work for the competitor while employed. Before resigning, however, she copies valuation models, research notes, and client-allocation templates that she created on Meridian's systems as part of her assigned duties. She intends to remove client names and account numbers and use the files at her new employer. Meridian has not authorized removal of the files. Lee could reconstruct her general analytical methods from her knowledge and experience without taking the documents.

        Flashcards: Preventing violations of Standard II

        1. 1. Integrity of Capital Markets\ Ethics

          Show answer

          - Material nonpublic information - Market manipulation

        Everything you need for CFA prep

        Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

        GET STARTED FOR FREE
        75% OFFLimited time offer
        GET 75% OFF