Preventing violations of the Asset Manager Code

Preventing violations of the Asset Manager Code

Published September 28, 2026

Preventing violations of the Asset Manager Code

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Asset Manager Code.

On the exam. The item gives you an ambiguous asset-manager fact pattern, an affected party, and a material conflict. It asks you either to recommend a case-specific prevention procedure or to classify the conduct. Give the answer in the requested form: a procedure recommendation or a conduct classification.

Protect client interests even when no obvious dishonest act appears. Treat a personal relationship, selective treatment, or an incomplete message as a risk that can pull a decision away from client interests. Convert that risk into a control that stops the conduct, corrects it, or blocks it.

StatusExample in this issue
RequiredApply Code duty and client mandate
RecommendedRegister conflict and recuse
PermittedRely on consent when allowed
ProhibitedFavor client without objective basis

Separate required conduct from a recommended procedure in your answer. Apply the required duty to act for client benefit. Usually recommend recusal or a conflict register as a control, unless the Code or mandate makes it mandatory.

Use disclosure to tell an affected party about a material fact. Treat consent as informed agreement. Do not treat either as a preventive control or assume either automatically cures biased treatment or misleading communication.

Build a complete recommendation by naming the actor, affected party, material fact, exact provision, and procedure.

$$ \text{Prevention recommendation} = \text{actor} + \text{affected party} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact provision} + \text{procedure} $$

Start with the actor, not a generic conflict label. Name the affected party next. Isolate the material fact that could change treatment or communication. Cite the exact Asset Manager Code provision. Finish with a procedure that assigns a decision-maker, review, disclosure or consent when allowed, and correction or a stop action when needed.

Worked example

You are handed a case in which a portfolio manager at an asset manager allocates a scarce issue among client portfolios. The manager has a personal relationship with a client decision-maker and gives that client's portfolio preferential treatment without a documented allocation rule. You need to recommend a prevention procedure and classify the current conduct.

FactStated condition
ActorPortfolio manager
Affected partyClient portfolios
Material factPersonal relationship with client
Governing provisionPrinciple II, Act for the benefit of clients
Missing controlIndependent allocation review

Carry these facts into your recommendation: the manager is the actor, client portfolios are affected, and the personal relationship is material. Principle II governs client benefit; the missing safeguard is independent allocation review. As you follow the sequence, check how that review changes the decision before you classify the conduct or name corrective steps.

Loading diagram…
  1. Identify the actor and affected party. The portfolio manager made the allocation, and client portfolios bear the unequal treatment. This produces two defined roles for the analysis, one actor and one affected party.

  2. Isolate the material fact. The personal relationship creates a conflict that can impair independence and objectivity. This produces one identified conflict for the next step. Apply Principle III, Act with independence and objectivity, to the decision-maker.

  3. Apply Principle II, Act for the benefit of clients. Preferential treatment without an objective basis puts a personal relationship ahead of fair client treatment. This produces one classification of violation on these facts.

  4. Recommend manager recusal, pre-clearance, an objective allocation method, and independent review. Read the client mandates first, then correct the completed allocation where possible and record the decision. This produces a four-part prevention response and one correction action.

  5. Disclose the material conflict where the Code or mandate requires it. Do not offer consent as permission to favor a client. This produces one separate disclosure-and-consent decision, distinct from prevention and correction.

The answer is a violation, with recusal, objective allocation, independent review, and correction as the case-specific prevention response.

Changed condition

You now learn that the personal relationship remains, but an independent committee applies a pre-approved objective allocation process before trades. No other fact changes. Predict the classification before reading the table.

FactBeforeAfter
RelationshipPersonal relationship remainsPersonal relationship remains
Allocation controlManager decides without ruleCommittee applies objective process
ClassificationViolation establishedRisk, no violation established

The material fact did not move. The control moved from unchecked discretion to independent review, so the conclusion changes from established violation to risk. The relationship still calls for monitoring and any required disclosure, but it does not by itself prove a violation. Before reading on, name the exact provision and prevention procedure for the changed case yourself.

Common error

When you see a manager disclose a conflict to the client, do not call the conflict cured. That conclusion feels right because transparency and consent seem fair. The manager's disclosure gives the client information, but it does not stop biased treatment or remove the material conflict. An objective control, correction, or prohibition is still required, so disclosure alone does not erase a risk or a violation.

Go deeper

When you read a conduct vignette, start with the harm the client experienced and match the provision to that harm. If one client receives worse treatment because another client was favored, Principle II, Act for the benefit of clients, addresses the client-interest harm. If a decision maker's personal relationship could influence the choice, Principle III, Act with independence and objectivity, supports recusal, even before unequal treatment occurs. If the facts also include a misleading client message, Principle V, Communicate with clients in a timely and accurate manner, supports correcting the message and giving accurate information.

Next, separate a proven breach from a control you would recommend. A conflict register, pre-clearance, recusal, independent review, and record retention are recommended unless the Code or mandate makes a particular control required. If biased treatment is established, recommend that the responsible party correct the treatment or stop the conduct. If the conflict exists but effective controls protect fair treatment, classify the facts as risk rather than violation. On the exam, a missing control alone does not prove a Code violation unless the Code or mandate required that control or the facts show client harm.

Check yourself

Practice

Which recommendation best prevents the Asset Manager Code issue when a manager has a material personal conflict?

Revision snapshot

$$ \text{Prevention recommendation} = \text{actor} + \text{affected party} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact provision} + \text{procedure} $$

  • Identify the actor and affected party, isolate the material fact, apply the exact Asset Manager Code provision, then recommend a case-specific procedure.
  • Disclosure is not a universal cure. Consent, prevention, violation, and risk are distinct.
  • Classify conduct and procedure separately as required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited.
  • On the exam, connect the procedure to the biased treatment, material conflict, or misleading communication.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Preventing violations of the Asset Manager Code

  1. 1. Halcyon Asset Management manages institutional equity mandates and is considering adopting the CFA Institute Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. Senior management has implemented most provisions but has postponed procedures for monitoring employee personal trading and has not established a business-continuity plan. Local law does not specifically require either procedure. The marketing director proposes stating: "Halcyon complies with the Asset Manager Code except for provisions not required under local law." Another executive proposes describing the firm as being in partial compliance and listing the omitted provisions. Halcyon's chief executive also reviews alternatives for compliance oversight. One proposal assigns responsibility to the lead portfolio manager, who approves trades and supervises analysts. A second appoints a senior compliance officer who does not participate in investment decisions or operations and reports directly to the chief executive and board compliance committee. A third divides responsibility among three junior operations employees, each of whom would monitor a separate department but would have no authority to require corrective action. Halcyon is preparing a presentation for prospective institutional clients. Its five-year composite currently includes only accounts that remain with the firm at the end of the period. Several terminated accounts had substantially underperformed before leaving. The marketing director proposes excluding those accounts because they are no longer representative of the current client base. All returns in the presentation would be clearly labeled as gross of fees. Halcyon's external auditor is willing to verify the mathematical accuracy of the returns, although the auditor has not assessed whether the composite definition is fair. Finally, Halcyon has authority to vote proxies for two clients holding shares in the same company. A proposed merger is expected to increase short-term distributions but reduce the company's long-term growth potential. One client's mandate prioritizes current income and directs Halcyon to vote in favor of transactions expected to increase distributions. The other client's mandate emphasizes long-term capital growth and directs Halcyon to oppose transactions expected to reduce long-term growth. Halcyon's general proxy policy favors management-supported mergers. Operational systems allow the firm to submit different votes for the two accounts and retain records of each decision.

    • 2. Crestline Asset Management claims compliance with the CFA Institute Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. The firm manages domestic equity portfolios and presents composite performance to prospective institutional clients. During a compliance review, the chief compliance officer discovers that Crestline removed two terminated accounts from the historical composite for all prior periods. Both accounts had significantly underperformed before termination. The marketing director explains that the clients are no longer with Crestline and therefore should not appear in any performance history. The remaining composite includes all current fee-paying discretionary accounts managed under the strategy. No disclosure describes the removal of the terminated accounts. Crestline requires analysts to retain research models, source documents, meeting notes, and report drafts for seven years. Priya Shah, CFA, prepares a recommendation using her own financial model and notes from issuer meetings. Separately, Shah directs a portion of client brokerage commissions to a broker who, in exchange, provides her with a market-rate investment research subscription used exclusively to benefit the clients whose commissions generated it. Crestline's compliance department approved the arrangement in advance, and clients received at least as favorable execution as available elsewhere. James Roth, CFA, supervises six analysts. He distributes the firm's compliance procedures, conducts quarterly training, reviews personal-trading reports, and investigates identified exceptions. An analyst nevertheless conceals an unauthorized trade by submitting a falsified brokerage statement. Nothing in Roth's reviews before the discovery reasonably indicated falsification. After detecting the misconduct, Roth suspends the analyst's trading authority and refers the matter to compliance. Crestline also employs Maya Ortiz, who passed Level II of the CFA Program and is registered for the next Level III examination. Her biography states, 'Maya Ortiz is a CFA Level II and is expected to become a CFA charterholder after passing Level III.' Elsewhere, the biography accurately states that she passed Level II and is a Level III candidate. Ortiz has not represented that she currently holds the CFA charter. The chief compliance officer asks whether adopting the Asset Manager Code eliminates the need to comply with applicable securities laws. Crestline operates in a jurisdiction whose securities laws impose additional client-reporting obligations not specifically listed in the Asset Manager Code.

      • 3. An asset manager has authority to vote client proxies but no documented voting policy. To comply with the Asset Manager Code, the manager should most likely:

        • A. Abstain from all proxy votes to reduce client expenses
        • B. Vote every proxy in accordance with management's recommendation
        • C. Adopt and disclose a policy for voting proxies in clients' interests
        Show answer

        Answer: C. Adopt and disclose a policy for voting proxies in clients' interests

        Adopt and disclose a policy for voting proxies in clients' interests - Because the manager has proxy-voting authority, the Asset Manager Code calls for a documented policy designed to vote in clients’ best interests. - Disclosing that policy to clients explains how the manager will exercise the authority delegated to it. Abstain from all proxy votes to reduce client expenses - Blanket abstention ignores whether a particular vote could protect or advance clients’ interests. - Voting costs may matter, but the manager must assess them under a client-focused policy rather than decline every vote. Vote every proxy in accordance with management's recommendation - Automatic agreement with company management does not establish that each vote serves clients’ interests. - The asset manager must apply its own proxy-voting policy, not substitute management’s recommendations for a client-focused decision.

      • 4. Meridian Securities analyst Dana Lee covers technology companies. During a private meeting, Orion Systems CFO Ravi Patel tells Lee that Orion has signed a confidential agreement to acquire its largest competitor at a substantial premium. The transaction would increase Orion's annual revenue by approximately 35%, but the parties will not announce it for another week. Patel asks Lee to keep the information confidential. Before the meeting, Lee rated Orion “hold”; based on the acquisition economics, she now believes the shares are materially undervalued. Lee separately researches a semiconductor manufacturer. Public regulatory filings show rising inventory, and publicly available shipping data indicate slower exports from two major ports. A component supplier tells Lee that its most recent shipment to the manufacturer was delayed by three days because of a temporary inspection problem. The supplier does not know the manufacturer's total production schedule, and Lee determines that the delayed shipment is immaterial relative to annual component purchases. Combining these observations with industry data, Lee concludes that the manufacturer's next-quarter revenue will be below consensus estimates. Meridian recently licensed an earnings-forecasting model from QuantAxis Analytics. QuantAxis supplies model outputs but does not disclose its raw data sources or permit clients to inspect the model methodology. A Meridian manager tells Lee that several respected investment firms use QuantAxis and instructs her to incorporate its forecasts into published recommendations. Lee has not compared the output with company filings, evaluated the reasonableness of key assumptions, or tested the model's historical error rate. Meridian permits third-party research only when analysts determine that it has a reasonable and adequate basis. Lee plans to resign from Meridian and establish an independent research firm. Over five years, she created detailed industry notes, valuation templates, and management-interview summaries while performing her Meridian duties using the firm's systems. Meridian's employment policy states that research records created in the course of employment belong to the firm. Lee proposes copying the files, removing client names, and using the remaining materials at her new firm. The public filings and industry publications underlying much of the research remain available from their original sources. Meridian has not granted Lee permission to retain any files.

        • 5. Anika Patel is a portfolio adviser at Meridian Advisory. She exercises discretionary authority over individual client accounts under written investment policy statements. One client, Roberto Diaz, is retired and relies on his portfolio for living expenses. His existing policy prioritises capital preservation and stable income, permits only diversified equity exposure, and describes his risk tolerance as below average. Diaz recently inherited USD 3 million, but Patel has not asked whether his objectives, liquidity needs, risk tolerance, or tax circumstances have changed. She is considering purchasing a concentrated position in a volatile biotechnology company for his account because his total wealth has increased. Meridian also receives a small allocation in an oversubscribed initial public offering. The IPO is suitable for several growth-oriented client accounts. Patel's spouse maintains a fee-paying discretionary account at Meridian, and Patel has beneficial ownership of the account under Meridian's personal-trading policy. Patel proposes allocating the available shares pro rata among all suitable accounts, including her spouse's account. Meridian does not permit employees to participate in oversubscribed offerings until all eligible client demand has been addressed. Another client, Ada Okafor, offers Patel a personal cash bonus equal to 5% of any annual portfolio return above 10%. The proposed payment would be in addition to Meridian's standard advisory fee and Patel's salary. Patel tells Okafor that she will notify her supervisor orally before accepting the arrangement. No payment has yet been made, and neither Meridian nor its compliance department has provided written consent. Patel plans to resign from Meridian and establish an independent advisory firm. Her employment contract contains no non-compete or non-solicitation provision, and local law does not restrict competition after departure. Before resigning, Patel considers copying Meridian's client files and downloading notes containing client telephone numbers and portfolio preferences. As an alternative, she could wait until after her departure and reconstruct contact information using public professional directories and issuer websites. She would then contact former clients without using confidential portfolio information or suggesting that Meridian endorses her new firm. Meridian's policies identify client files, internal contact lists, and portfolio records as firm property. They also require personal accounts beneficially owned by employees or their immediate families to be treated as employee accounts for transaction-priority purposes.

          • 6. Northbridge Research provides independent equity research to institutional investors. Elena Ortiz, a senior analyst, is preparing a recommendation on Delta Components. Delta's public filings show that warranty claims declined during the latest quarter, and publicly available shipping records indicate rising deliveries to a large customer. At an industry conference, a production manager employed by one of Delta's small suppliers tells Ortiz that the supplier's defect rate on a pilot component has recently declined. The supplier accounts for less than 1% of Delta's production costs, and Ortiz reasonably concludes that the observation, considered alone, would not affect Delta's share price. By combining the observation with public filings, shipping records, and her valuation model, Ortiz develops an investment conclusion that she considers material. Northbridge is also approached by Solara Mining, which offers to pay a flat fee for a research report. Solara will pay the fee regardless of the report's conclusion and will have no right to edit the analysis. Analyst Priya Lin proposes accepting the assignment, performing the firm's usual due diligence, and giving Solara only an opportunity to identify factual errors. Lin's valuation independently supports a positive recommendation. Northbridge's standard report template identifies holdings owned by analysts but contains no field for disclosing that an issuer paid for the research. Before Lin completes the report, Solara invites her to inspect a remote mine. Regular commercial flights and ordinary hotels are available near the site. Solara nevertheless offers business-class airfare, three nights at a luxury resort, and entertainment after the one-day inspection. Lin believes visiting the mine would materially improve her analysis. She proposes accepting all arrangements and disclosing them in the report. Separately, Ortiz downloads an industry-margin chart from a licensed research database. The chart contains the database provider's original peer classifications and analytical adjustments rather than raw governmental data. Ortiz removes the provider's name, changes the colors, and inserts the chart into a client presentation under the heading 'Northbridge Sector Analysis.' She retains the numerical values but does not cite the provider because Northbridge pays for an enterprise subscription. The database agreement permits internal use in research but requires attribution when its proprietary analysis is reproduced externally.

            • 7. A CFA Program candidate has passed Levels I, II, and III but has not yet satisfied the required qualified work experience needed to earn the charter. Which résumé statement is most appropriate?

              • A. Passed CFA Program Levels I, II, and III; awaiting completion of qualified work experience to earn the charter
              • B. CFA charter earned; official verification pending
              • C. CFA (all examination levels completed)
              Show answer

              Answer: A. Passed CFA Program Levels I, II, and III; awaiting completion of qualified work experience to earn the charter

              Passed CFA Program Levels I, II, and III; awaiting completion of qualified work experience to earn the charter - This statement accurately reports that the candidate passed all three exam levels without claiming to hold the charter. - It also makes clear that qualified work experience remains outstanding before the candidate can earn the charter. CFA charter earned; official verification pending - The candidate has not earned the charter because the required qualified work experience is incomplete. - Saying that verification is pending misrepresents an unmet requirement as an administrative delay. CFA (all examination levels completed) - Placing CFA after the candidate’s name implies a designation the candidate has not earned. - The parenthetical explanation does not make that use appropriate; the résumé should describe the passed levels instead.

            Flashcards: Preventing violations of the Asset Manager Code

            1. 1. Loyalty to Clients\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              Deals with always putting the client's interests before your own: - Design salary arrangements that align the interests of the client with those of the manager without the manager taking undue risks - Create procedures regarding how confidential client information should be collected, used and stored - Create an anti-money-laundering policy - Determine what constitutes a token gift

            2. 2. Risk Management, Compliance and Supprt\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              Managers must: - Develop policies for complying with the Code and Standards - Establish a firm wide system for identifying and measuring manager's risk positions - Appoint a client officer - Maintain records in an easily accessible format for an appropriate amoung of time (at least 7 years) - Have sufficiently qualified staff with appropriate resources - Institute a contingency plan in the event of natural disasters

            3. 3. Trade Management Guidelines

              Show answer

              Are split into three parts: 1. Processes - policies in place with the intent of maximizing portfolio value using best execution 2. Disclosures - trading techniques, conflicts of interest 3. Record Keeping - complaince and disclosures made to clients

            4. 4. Performance and Valuation\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              Deals with the reporting of investment results in an accurate manner without misrepresentation and using fair market values

            5. 5. Investment Process and Actions\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              Deals with being competent and taking reasonable action: - Never engage in market manipulation - Deal fairly with all clients - Thoroughly investigate and research different investment options - Different levels or service need to be available to all clients and fully disclosed - Conduct stress testing on investments - Must be able to explain investment strategy to clients in a way they can understand - Each client should have an IPS

            6. 6. Disclosures\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              Managers must disclose: - Any information the client would need to know to take a view on the manager and process - Potential conflicts of interest - Regulatory or disciplinary action - Investment process and risks - Fee schedules and projection for fees charges - Discussion regarding any soft or bundled commissions - Performance on a timely basis - Valuation methods - Proxy voting policy - How trades are allocated - Firm-wide risk management process

            7. 7. Trading\ Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              - Do not trade or cause others to trade on material non-public information - Always place client trades before your own - Use commission generated on products that assist with the investment decision making process - Seek best execution - Allocate shares equitably among clients

            8. 8. Asset Manager Code

              Show answer

              There are six components: 1. Always act ethically and professionally 2. Act in the best interest of the client 3. Act in an objective and independent manner 4. Perform actions using skill, competence and diligence 5. Communicate accurately with clients on a regular basis 6. Comply with legal and regulatory requirements regarding capital markets

            Everything you need for CFA prep

            Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

            GET STARTED FOR FREE
            75% OFFLimited time offer
            GET 75% OFF