Learning Outcome Statement
Explain how the practices, policies, or conduct does or does not violate the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.
On the exam: This is a constructed-response item. The given inputs are an actor, material facts, policy context, and affected parties. The requested outputs are the exact Standard, a decision on whether the conduct is a violation or risk, and a recommended prevention procedure.
Your task is to connect a real action to the duty that governs it. Do not decide from whether the conduct feels fair or unfair. A policy may show what the firm expected, but it does not replace the CFA Standard. The affected party matters because disclosure can identify a conflict without making a personal priority or unfair allocation permissible.
| Exact Standard | Rule phrase | Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Standard I(B) Independence and Objectivity | Reasonable care and judgment | Outside influence may impair judgment |
| Standard III(B) Fair Dealing | Deal fairly and objectively with all clients | Allocation favors one client |
| Standard VI(A) Disclosure of Conflicts | Full and fair disclosure | Conflict may impair duties |
| Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions | Client and employer transactions have priority | Personal trade comes first |
The material fact selects the governing provision. Standard VI(A) addresses matters that could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with respective duties, while Standard III(B) and Standard VI(B) govern how the opportunity or trade is handled.
Use this compact sequence to turn the conclusion into a prevention procedure.
$$ \begin{aligned} \text{Prevention sequence} &= \text{identify conflict} + \text{disclose to correct party} \ &\quad + \text{restrict or recuse when needed} + \text{document} + \text{monitor} \end{aligned} $$
Treat the plus signs as steps, not arithmetic. Identification fixes the actor, material fact, affected party, and exact Standard. Disclosure moves the conflict to the correct party. Restriction or recusal removes the compromised decision path when needed. Documentation records the decision, and monitoring checks whether the control works. Disclosure is not consent, and it cannot authorize prohibited conduct.
Loading diagramā¦
Worked example
You are the compliance reviewer for an investment firm. You are handed a policy that lets a portfolio manager buy a security in a personal account while a client order is waiting, as long as the manager sends disclosure afterward. The manager buys first and emails the affected client afterward. You need to explain whether the conduct violates the applicable Standard and recommend a procedure that prevents a repeat.
| Fact | Detail |
|---|---|
| Actor | Portfolio manager |
| Material fact | Personal account traded before client order |
| Affected party | Client and employer |
| Policy | Disclosure after trade |
Read these facts in order before judging the policy. The actor identifies whose personal account is involved, while the material fact fixes the timing against the waiting client order. Naming both the client and employer keeps the analysis tied to the duties owed to each. The policy explains the firm's stated safeguard, but disclosure after execution cannot change which transaction received priority. The next visual maps those parties to the safeguards that should act before a conflict causes a breach.
-
Name the actor, material fact, and affected party. You do this first because the priority rule depends on whose account traded and whose order was waiting. The actor is the portfolio manager. The personal account is beneficially owned by the manager, and the client order had not yet received priority. This produces finding 1: the managerās personal trade came before the client order.
-
Apply Standard VI(B), Priority of Transactions. You do this because the Standard tells you which transaction must go first. It requires investment transactions for clients and employers to have priority over investment transactions in which a Member or Candidate is the beneficial owner. The managerās personal account is beneficially owned by the manager. This produces finding 2: the conduct violates Standard VI(B).
-
Separate disclosure from consent. You do this because a later email may reveal the conflict without changing the order in which the trades occurred. The email may identify the conflict to the client, but it does not move the client order ahead of the personal trade or make the sequence permitted. This produces finding 3: disclosure does not cure the priority breach, so the conclusion remains a violation, not risk only.
-
Recommend a prevention procedure. You do this because the control must stop the improper sequence before the manager can trade. Put the personal account on restriction while client orders are pending, require pre-clearance, disclose material conflicts to the correct party, document the review, and monitor compliance. Require recusal if the manager cannot maintain independent judgment. This produces finding 4: the procedure must remove the opportunity for a priority breach rather than rely on later disclosure.
The portfolio manager violated Standard VI(B) because the personal account received priority, and the procedure must remove that opportunity rather than rely on later disclosure.
Changed condition
Keep every fact the same except the personal trade occurs after the client order is completed. Predict the conclusion before reading the table.
| Fact | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Personal trade | Before client order | After client order |
| Policy | Disclosure after trade | Disclosure after trade |
| Standard VI(B) | Priority violation | No priority violation on facts |
You should have predicted the change from the timing. Moving the personal trade behind the client order removes the fact that triggers Standard VI(B), so the conclusion moves from violation to no priority violation on these facts. The unchanged policy may still create control risk, so assess any separate material conflict instead of treating the result as automatic permission. Before reading on, write the exact Standard and one control you would recommend.
Common error
When you see the managerās email, you may conclude that the client consented, so there is no violation. That feels right because disclosure is a familiar way to manage a conflict and the client knows what happened. Look past the email: if the managerās conduct compromises independence, gives a personal account priority, or allocates a client opportunity unfairly, later disclosure cannot cure the prohibited conduct.
Go deeper
A policy is evidence of the firmās control environment, not the Standard itself. A policy gap can create risk without proving a Standard violation.
Standard III(B) applies when distributing investment recommendations or taking investment action. The test is whether the process is fair and objective, not whether the manager can explain a preference.
| Conduct or control | Status | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Disclosure of material conflict | Required | Tell correct party fully and fairly |
| Personal trade before client | Prohibited | Client transactions have priority |
| Objective client allocation | Required | Apply a consistent process |
| Pre-clearance and monitoring | Recommended | Prevent recurrence and test compliance |
| Personal trade after client priority | Permitted on facts | Follow policy and document |
Pre-clearance, restriction, documentation, and monitoring are prevention controls unless the case says the firmās policy makes them mandatory. They support the Standard III(B) duty, but they do not replace it. Your answer should name the Standard duty first and then label the prevention step as required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited.
Check yourself
Practice
A firm has no conflict log. An analyst receives issuer hospitality, tells a supervisor, and continues the recommendation. Which conclusion best follows?
Revision snapshot
| Exam move | Recall |
|---|---|
| Exam angle | Name actor, material fact, affected party, exact CFA Standard |
| Disclosure trap | Identifies conflict, not universal consent or cure |
| Policy gap | Creates risk without proving a Standard violation |
| Prevention formula | Identify conflict, disclose to correct party, restrict or recuse when needed, document, monitor |
| Fair Dealing | Objective and consistently applied process for client opportunities |
| Duty versus control | Separate required duties from recommended controls |
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more