Learning Outcome Statement
Evaluate practices, policies, and conduct relative to the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.
On the exam: The question gives an ambiguous case involving an actor, a material fact, a policy or conduct, and an affected party. It asks for the governing Standard, a judgment on the conduct, and a case-specific prevention procedure in a constructed response or multiple-choice question.
An ethics case is a control decision, not a character test. You must connect the fact that creates risk to the duty owed by the actor. The answer changes when the governing Standard changes, even if the same disclosure appears in both cases. Classify the conduct before proposing a fix.
| Classification | Standard position | Candidate response |
|---|---|---|
| Required | The Standard demands it | Follow the duty |
| Recommended | It strengthens prevention | Add it to policy |
| Permitted | It is allowed under conditions | Check each condition |
| Prohibited | The Standard bars it | Stop or avoid it |
Disclosure identifies a conflict for the affected party, while consent is affirmative permission that can permit conduct only when the governing Standard allows it. A policy can be insufficient even when no specific violation has occurred, because a late report detects risk after the decision instead of preventing the decision.
The following memory formula turns an ambiguous case into an exam answer and a prevention recommendation.
$$ \text{Answer} = \text{actor} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact Standard} + \text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{prevention} $$
Read each plus sign as a checklist, not arithmetic. The actor identifies who owes the duty. The material fact identifies what could impair judgment or harm an interest. The exact Standard supplies the conduct test. The affected party tells you whose interest the prevention procedure must protect. Standard VI(A), Disclosure of Conflicts, requires full and fair disclosure of matters that could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with duties to clients, prospective clients, and employer. The disclosure must be prominent, delivered in plain language, and effective. It does not replace written consent under Standard IV(B) or remove a prohibition under Standard I(B). The arrow moves from evaluation to a control matched to the risk.
Worked example
You are a portfolio manager at a pension fund manager. A broker seeking the fund's order flow offers you a personal paid sporting weekend. The firm's policy asks you to disclose gifts after receipt, and you plan to accept first and tell the pension fund clients later. The exam asks you to identify the exact Standard, judge the planned conduct, and recommend a prevention procedure.
| Item | Fact |
|---|---|
| Actor | Portfolio manager |
| Material fact | Broker offers personal paid weekend |
| Policy | Disclosure after receipt |
| Planned conduct | Accept, then disclose |
| Affected parties | Employer and pension fund clients |
The table separates the offer, the late-reporting policy, the manager’s intended action, and the people whose interests are exposed. Follow that order in your answer: identify who controls acceptance, test the benefit against the governing Standard, and name the control before the decision. The path below makes the consent check visible while keeping independence as a separate stop condition.
Loading diagram…
-
Name the actor as the portfolio manager. This identifies who controls the decision, because the duty attaches to the person deciding whether to accept the benefit. The result is a judgment of the manager's conduct.
-
Isolate the personal benefit and the desired order flow as the material fact. This exposes the conflict, because the link creates a conflict with the employer's interest and gives the clients a reason to question independence. The result is a conflict that must be tested under the applicable Standards.
-
Apply Standard IV(B), Additional Compensation Arrangements. Members and Candidates must not accept any gift, benefit, compensation, or consideration that competes with or might reasonably be expected to create a conflict of interest with their employer's interest unless they obtain written consent from all parties involved. This test is required because the broker's paid weekend is a benefit tied to the fund's order flow. The result is a required written-consent step before acceptance.
-
Apply Standard I(B), Independence and Objectivity, as a separate test. This test is required because a benefit can compromise independent judgment even when a disclosure or consent process exists. If the benefit could reasonably be expected to compromise the manager's independence or objectivity, acceptance is prohibited, regardless of disclosure. The result is a stop condition whenever that threshold is met.
-
Recommend pre-clearance before acceptance. This control is needed because the manager must resolve consent and independence questions before accepting the benefit. If the facts support acceptance under Standard IV(B), obtain written consent from all parties involved, keep the manager out of the broker-selection decision during review, and reassess independence. If the benefit threatens independence, decline it and recuse the manager. The result is a pre-clearance process that ends in consent and continued review, or in decline and recusal.
The planned accept-then-disclose conduct should not proceed, and the policy should replace after-the-fact disclosure with pre-clearance, consent where allowed, and decline or recusal where independence is threatened.
Changed condition
The portfolio manager and broker offer are unchanged. The only changed input is the employer's policy, which now requires pre-clearance and written consent from all parties before acceptance.
| Element | Original case | Changed case |
|---|---|---|
| Policy | Disclose after receipt | Pre-clear and obtain consent |
| Planned action | Accept, then disclose | Review before acceptance |
| Evaluation | Cannot accept yet | May be permitted after conditions |
The policy change moves the control before the decision. You should have predicted this result before looking at the last row. Standard IV(B) may permit acceptance after its consent condition is met, while Standard I(B) still prohibits a benefit that could compromise independence. The affected parties remain the employer and pension fund clients. Before reading on, write the exact Standard and affected parties for this changed case.
Common error
A candidate sees the broker's benefit, tells the clients about it, and calls the conflict cured. That feels right because transparency gives the affected parties a chance to judge the manager's motives. The question gives it away by asking whether the conduct is prohibited or whether informed consent is required, so identify the exact Standard before recommending disclosure.
Go deeper
Suppose you supervise a team and the only policy is a post-acceptance gift log. The actor is the supervisor, the material fact is the reactive policy, and the affected parties are the employer and clients. Standard IV(C), Responsibilities of Supervisors, requires reasonable efforts so that anyone subject to the supervisor's authority complies with applicable laws, rules, regulations, and the Code and Standards. A log created after acceptance documents the event but cannot prevent the conflict that acceptance may create.
| Risk in facts | Matching procedure |
|---|---|
| Unapproved benefit | Pre-clearance and consent |
| Personal conflict | Recusal and reassessment |
| Information access | Restricted access |
| Prohibited conduct | Stop the conduct |
Use the procedure that answers the risk in the case, and treat the table as recommendations rather than automatic mandates. Standard IV(C) requires reasonable supervisory efforts, but it does not make every helpful control mandatory. If the person is outside the supervisor's authority, Standard IV(C) does not create a supervisory duty over that person. Name the governing Standard before calling a control required.
Check yourself
Practice
A portfolio manager is offered a personal benefit by a broker seeking the fund's order flow. The benefit might reasonably be expected to create a conflict with the employer's interest, but the facts do not establish compromised independence. The manager plans to accept it and disclose it to clients afterward. Which response is best?
Revision snapshot
$$ \text{Answer} = \text{actor} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact Standard} + \text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{prevention} $$
| Exam move | Recall |
|---|---|
| Standard | Name exact Standard and affected party first |
| Disclosure | Identifies conflict, not universal cure |
| Consent | Permits conduct only when Standard allows |
| Policy | May be insufficient before any violation |
| Prevention | Match risk: pre-clearance, recusal, restricted access, consent, reassessment, or stopping |
Under time pressure, classify the conduct, then give the case-specific procedure.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more