Evaluating practices, policies and conduct

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Evaluate practices, policies, and conduct relative to the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.

On the exam: The question gives an ambiguous case involving an actor, a material fact, a policy or conduct, and an affected party. It asks for the governing Standard, a judgment on the conduct, and a case-specific prevention procedure in a constructed response or multiple-choice question.

An ethics case is a control decision, not a character test. You must connect the fact that creates risk to the duty owed by the actor. The answer changes when the governing Standard changes, even if the same disclosure appears in both cases. Classify the conduct before proposing a fix.

ClassificationStandard positionCandidate response
RequiredThe Standard demands itFollow the duty
RecommendedIt strengthens preventionAdd it to policy
PermittedIt is allowed under conditionsCheck each condition
ProhibitedThe Standard bars itStop or avoid it

Disclosure identifies a conflict for the affected party, while consent is affirmative permission that can permit conduct only when the governing Standard allows it. A policy can be insufficient even when no specific violation has occurred, because a late report detects risk after the decision instead of preventing the decision.

The following memory formula turns an ambiguous case into an exam answer and a prevention recommendation.

$$ \text{Answer} = \text{actor} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact Standard} + \text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{prevention} $$

Read each plus sign as a checklist, not arithmetic. The actor identifies who owes the duty. The material fact identifies what could impair judgment or harm an interest. The exact Standard supplies the conduct test. The affected party tells you whose interest the prevention procedure must protect. Standard VI(A), Disclosure of Conflicts, requires full and fair disclosure of matters that could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with duties to clients, prospective clients, and employer. The disclosure must be prominent, delivered in plain language, and effective. It does not replace written consent under Standard IV(B) or remove a prohibition under Standard I(B). The arrow moves from evaluation to a control matched to the risk.

Worked example

You are a portfolio manager at a pension fund manager. A broker seeking the fund's order flow offers you a personal paid sporting weekend. The firm's policy asks you to disclose gifts after receipt, and you plan to accept first and tell the pension fund clients later. The exam asks you to identify the exact Standard, judge the planned conduct, and recommend a prevention procedure.

ItemFact
ActorPortfolio manager
Material factBroker offers personal paid weekend
PolicyDisclosure after receipt
Planned conductAccept, then disclose
Affected partiesEmployer and pension fund clients

The table separates the offer, the late-reporting policy, the manager’s intended action, and the people whose interests are exposed. Follow that order in your answer: identify who controls acceptance, test the benefit against the governing Standard, and name the control before the decision. The path below makes the consent check visible while keeping independence as a separate stop condition.

Loading diagram…
  1. Name the actor as the portfolio manager. This identifies who controls the decision, because the duty attaches to the person deciding whether to accept the benefit. The result is a judgment of the manager's conduct.

  2. Isolate the personal benefit and the desired order flow as the material fact. This exposes the conflict, because the link creates a conflict with the employer's interest and gives the clients a reason to question independence. The result is a conflict that must be tested under the applicable Standards.

  3. Apply Standard IV(B), Additional Compensation Arrangements. Members and Candidates must not accept any gift, benefit, compensation, or consideration that competes with or might reasonably be expected to create a conflict of interest with their employer's interest unless they obtain written consent from all parties involved. This test is required because the broker's paid weekend is a benefit tied to the fund's order flow. The result is a required written-consent step before acceptance.

  4. Apply Standard I(B), Independence and Objectivity, as a separate test. This test is required because a benefit can compromise independent judgment even when a disclosure or consent process exists. If the benefit could reasonably be expected to compromise the manager's independence or objectivity, acceptance is prohibited, regardless of disclosure. The result is a stop condition whenever that threshold is met.

  5. Recommend pre-clearance before acceptance. This control is needed because the manager must resolve consent and independence questions before accepting the benefit. If the facts support acceptance under Standard IV(B), obtain written consent from all parties involved, keep the manager out of the broker-selection decision during review, and reassess independence. If the benefit threatens independence, decline it and recuse the manager. The result is a pre-clearance process that ends in consent and continued review, or in decline and recusal.

The planned accept-then-disclose conduct should not proceed, and the policy should replace after-the-fact disclosure with pre-clearance, consent where allowed, and decline or recusal where independence is threatened.

Changed condition

The portfolio manager and broker offer are unchanged. The only changed input is the employer's policy, which now requires pre-clearance and written consent from all parties before acceptance.

ElementOriginal caseChanged case
PolicyDisclose after receiptPre-clear and obtain consent
Planned actionAccept, then discloseReview before acceptance
EvaluationCannot accept yetMay be permitted after conditions

The policy change moves the control before the decision. You should have predicted this result before looking at the last row. Standard IV(B) may permit acceptance after its consent condition is met, while Standard I(B) still prohibits a benefit that could compromise independence. The affected parties remain the employer and pension fund clients. Before reading on, write the exact Standard and affected parties for this changed case.

Common error

A candidate sees the broker's benefit, tells the clients about it, and calls the conflict cured. That feels right because transparency gives the affected parties a chance to judge the manager's motives. The question gives it away by asking whether the conduct is prohibited or whether informed consent is required, so identify the exact Standard before recommending disclosure.

Go deeper

Suppose you supervise a team and the only policy is a post-acceptance gift log. The actor is the supervisor, the material fact is the reactive policy, and the affected parties are the employer and clients. Standard IV(C), Responsibilities of Supervisors, requires reasonable efforts so that anyone subject to the supervisor's authority complies with applicable laws, rules, regulations, and the Code and Standards. A log created after acceptance documents the event but cannot prevent the conflict that acceptance may create.

Risk in factsMatching procedure
Unapproved benefitPre-clearance and consent
Personal conflictRecusal and reassessment
Information accessRestricted access
Prohibited conductStop the conduct

Use the procedure that answers the risk in the case, and treat the table as recommendations rather than automatic mandates. Standard IV(C) requires reasonable supervisory efforts, but it does not make every helpful control mandatory. If the person is outside the supervisor's authority, Standard IV(C) does not create a supervisory duty over that person. Name the governing Standard before calling a control required.

Check yourself

Practice

A portfolio manager is offered a personal benefit by a broker seeking the fund's order flow. The benefit might reasonably be expected to create a conflict with the employer's interest, but the facts do not establish compromised independence. The manager plans to accept it and disclose it to clients afterward. Which response is best?

Revision snapshot

$$ \text{Answer} = \text{actor} + \text{material fact} + \text{exact Standard} + \text{affected party} \rightarrow \text{prevention} $$

Exam moveRecall
StandardName exact Standard and affected party first
DisclosureIdentifies conflict, not universal cure
ConsentPermits conduct only when Standard allows
PolicyMay be insufficient before any violation
PreventionMatch risk: pre-clearance, recusal, restricted access, consent, reassessment, or stopping

Under time pressure, classify the conduct, then give the case-specific procedure.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Evaluating practices, policies and conduct

  1. 1. Meridian Asset Management operates equity and fixed-income investment desks under a single legal entity and brand. The equity desk, which manages 70% of firm assets, has revised its policies to conform to the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. The fixed-income desk has not adopted several provisions, including annual employee conduct acknowledgements and documented trade-allocation procedures. Meridian's marketing director proposes stating, "Meridian Asset Management complies with the Asset Manager Code." She plans to add a footnote explaining that the policies currently apply only to the equity desk. Meridian also prepares a presentation for its technology-equity strategy. The proposed performance record includes accounts that remained with Meridian at the end of the reporting period but excludes three fee-paying discretionary accounts terminated during the year. All three terminated accounts followed the same strategy and mandate as the included accounts. Two were terminated after underperforming the strategy benchmark. The marketing team argues that former clients need not be included because Meridian no longer manages their assets. The team also proposes highlighting two individual accounts with returns above the composite while omitting lower-return accounts. A fourth fee-paying discretionary account remained with Meridian throughout the year but fell below the composite's stated minimum asset level for several months; the marketing team proposes removing that account from the presented record for those months even though it continued to follow the strategy's mandate. Barton Securities offers Meridian proprietary issuer research if Meridian directs additional client brokerage to Barton. The research would assist several Meridian investment teams. Barton charges commissions comparable to other brokers, but Meridian's trading data show that Barton's execution speeds and realised prices are materially worse than those available from competing brokers for the relevant securities. Barton will provide the research only if Meridian commits client trades in advance. Meridian clients have not directed the use of Barton or agreed to accept lower execution quality. Finally, Meridian proposes outsourcing portfolio-risk analytics to Delta Analytics. Delta would calculate factor exposures, stress tests, and liquidity measures used in client reporting and portfolio oversight. Meridian's chief operating officer argues that the outsourcing contract transfers responsibility for the accuracy and monitoring of those measures to Delta. Under his proposal, Meridian would review Delta's work only if a client complains or a material valuation error becomes apparent. Meridian has sufficient personnel to conduct initial due diligence, establish service standards, and perform periodic reviews of Delta's controls and outputs.

    • 2. Daniel Cho, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Meridian Advisory. Meridian’s compliance manual incorporates the CFA Institute Code and Standards and requires employees to report outside compensation and gifts received from third parties. A broker-dealer that executes trades for Meridian’s clients gives Cho a set of premium sports-event tickets each quarter as a token of appreciation for directing trading volume to the broker. Cho reports the gifts to Meridian’s compliance department, which reviews the value and frequency of the gifts and determines that they do not compromise his independence and objectivity. Cho continues to select brokers for client trades based solely on execution quality and cost. One of Cho’s institutional clients offers him a personal bonus equal to 10% of any annual portfolio return above the client’s benchmark. The payment would be in addition to Cho’s compensation from Meridian. Cho informs Meridian’s chief investment officer orally and plans to accept the arrangement after the client signs it. Meridian has not provided written consent. Cho maintains a personal account and manages an account for his adult sister, who is not financially dependent on him. Cho has beneficial ownership of his personal account but not his sister’s account. Meridian’s policy permits employees to participate in recommended trades only after all client orders have been executed. When Cho recommends purchasing Ardent Medical, he first submits orders for unrelated client accounts, then for his sister’s fee-paying account, and finally for his personal account. Cho also considers relying on an external research report about Sable Mining. The report was produced by a reputable specialist research firm and contains detailed commodity-price assumptions, mine-production forecasts, and valuation sensitivities. Before using it, Cho reviews the provider’s analyst qualifications, checks the report’s assumptions against independent industry data, and determines that the work has a reasonable and adequate basis. Meridian retains a copy of the report and Cho’s review notes. Finally, Cho tells a colleague that reputable third-party research may be used without review because the external provider, rather than Meridian, is responsible for its accuracy. The colleague argues that investment professionals must independently reproduce every calculation before relying on any external research.

      • 3. Elena Maric is a senior equity analyst at Northstar Research. She is preparing an initiation report on Vectra Biologics, a publicly traded pharmaceutical company. Vectra invites Maric to inspect a remote manufacturing facility. The issuer offers premium-class airfare, three nights at a luxury resort, meals, and entertainment. Northstar's compliance officer approves the trip because management considers facility access useful. Commercial flights and ordinary accommodation are available, although visitors must use Vectra's vehicles for the final 20 kilometres from the nearest town to the secure facility. Before the visit, an external consultant who previously advised the national medicines regulator sends Maric a confidential draft regulatory ruling. The ruling would shorten the protected commercial life of Vectra's principal drug by three years and, if adopted, would materially reduce Maric's valuation estimate. The consultant states that the document has not been released and asks Maric not to identify him. Maric has not traded or changed her recommendation. Maric separately speaks with a component supplier. The supplier reports a two-week delay in one shipment to Vectra but states that the delayed shipment represents less than 1% of Vectra's annual component purchases. Maric reasonably concludes that this isolated delay is immaterial. She combines the information with public prescription data, published clinical-trial results, and Vectra's regulatory filings. Her documented analysis supports a recommendation that differs from the market consensus. While drafting the report, Maric finds a competitor's publicly distributed industry report. It contains a distinctive chart comparing drug-development success rates by therapeutic category. The numerical inputs were drawn from a government database, but the competitor selected the categories, performed the calculations, and designed the chart. Maric plans to reproduce the chart in Northstar's report without identifying the competitor because she believes the underlying data are public. Maric personally owns a small number of Vectra shares that she purchased several years before joining Northstar. She has not yet disclosed this holding internally. As the initiation report nears completion, Maric considers calling three of Northstar's largest institutional clients to give them a one-business-day advance summary of the buy recommendation before the report is released to all other clients through Northstar's standard distribution system. Northstar's written policies state that employees should ordinarily pay their own travel costs, must submit potential material nonpublic information to compliance, and must identify external research used in published reports. The firm's policies do not change the obligations imposed by the CFA Institute Code and Standards.

        • 4. A former client files a public complaint against an adviser and asks a journalist for the client's account records. The adviser has no client authorization, legal compulsion, or evidence of illegal activity. The adviser should most likely:

          • A. Provide the records because the former client initiated the complaint
          • B. Refuse disclosure unless an applicable legal exception permits it
          • C. Provide only records that do not contain investment recommendations
          Show answer

          Answer: B. Refuse disclosure unless an applicable legal exception permits it

          Refuse disclosure unless an applicable legal exception permits it - Under CFA Standard III(E), the adviser’s duty of client confidentiality continues after the relationship ends. - With no client authorization, legal compulsion, or evidence of illegal activity, the adviser must not disclose account records to the journalist. Provide the records because the former client initiated the complaint - A public complaint does not itself authorize the adviser to release confidential account records. - The former client’s request to a journalist is not permission for the adviser to disclose those records. Provide only records that do not contain investment recommendations - Account records remain confidential whether or not they contain investment recommendations. - Removing recommendations does not create client authorization or a legal exception permitting disclosure.

        • 5. Marcus Dunn, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Meridian Private Capital. He manages discretionary accounts under written investment mandates and is responsible for communicating equity recommendations to clients. One client, Ada Okafor, is retired and depends on her portfolio for living expenses. Her mandate emphasizes preservation of capital, low return volatility, and diversified income-producing investments. It limits any single equity position to 5% of portfolio value and prohibits speculative securities. After hearing an online interview with the founder of an early-stage biotechnology company, Okafor instructs Dunn to invest 20% of her account in the company's shares. Dunn confirms that the company has no commercial products and that its value depends primarily on an unproven clinical trial. Okafor does not want to amend her mandate and tells Dunn to treat the trade as an isolated client-directed transaction within the discretionary account. Dunn later prepares a buy recommendation on a liquid, exchange-listed company that is suitable for all Meridian growth clients. Before the market opens, he emails the recommendation to clients whose annual fees exceed USD 100,000. He sends it to all remaining growth clients 30 minutes after trading begins. Meridian's systems could have distributed the recommendation simultaneously. Dunn records the same recommended price range for every client and reasons that all clients ultimately received identical content. An issuer covered by Dunn offers to pay him USD 25,000 to advise its management team on investor presentations outside his normal working hours. The engagement would draw on knowledge developed through his position at Meridian but would not involve confidential Meridian information. Meridian permits outside engagements when conflicts are addressed. Dunn intends to obtain oral approval from his supervisor and written confirmation from the issuer before accepting the work. Dunn also refers clients needing tax services to an independent accountant. The accountant has agreed to give Dunn complimentary tax-preparation services worth USD 1,500 for every five referred clients who engage the firm. Dunn believes the accountant is competent and the referral is appropriate. He plans to tell each client about the arrangement only after the client has signed the accountant's engagement agreement, reasoning that earlier disclosure might distract from the accountant's qualifications.

          • 6. Country X law permits disclosed employee trades ahead of client trades. A CFA charterholder's firm allows the practice. The charterholder should most likely:

            • A. Follow Country X law because the conduct is legally permitted
            • B. Follow the CFA Standard by giving client trades priority
            • C. Follow the firm's policy if it is disclosed to all clients
            Show answer

            Answer: B. Follow the CFA Standard by giving client trades priority

            Follow the CFA Standard by giving client trades priority - Country X law and firm policy permit disclosed employee trades ahead of client trades, but Standard VI(B), Priority of Transactions, requires client trades to take priority. - When applicable law is less strict than the CFA Institute Standards, the charterholder must follow the stricter requirement. Follow Country X law because the conduct is legally permitted - Legal permission does not remove the charterholder’s obligation under Standard VI(B) to place client trades first. - Country X law is less strict on this point, so following it alone would not satisfy the CFA Institute Standards. Follow the firm's policy if it is disclosed to all clients - The firm’s permission cannot override Standard VI(B)’s requirement that client trades take priority over employee trades. - Disclosure to all clients does not make trading ahead of their orders consistent with that requirement.

          • 7. After failing the Level II examination, an analyst does not register for another examination but continues to state “CFA Level II candidate” on his résumé. He should most likely:

            • A. Change the statement to “Passed Level I of the CFA Program”
            • B. Retain the statement because he previously registered for Level II
            • C. Remove all references to participation in the CFA Program
            Show answer

            Answer: A. Change the statement to “Passed Level I of the CFA Program”

            Change the statement to “Passed Level I of the CFA Program” - He may accurately state that he passed Level I of the CFA Program. - Because he failed Level II and has not registered for another examination, he is not currently a candidate and must remove that claim. Retain the statement because he previously registered for Level II - Prior registration does not preserve candidate status after he receives his Level II result. - Continuing to claim “CFA Level II candidate” would misrepresent his current participation in the CFA Program. Remove all references to participation in the CFA Program - CFA Program rules permit accurate references to completed achievements, including passing Level I. - He must remove the unsupported candidate claim, not every reference to his participation in the program.

          Flashcards: Evaluating practices, policies and conduct

          1. 1.

          Everything you need for CFA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF