Standard VI: Conflicts of interest in context

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Demonstrate a thorough knowledge of the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct by applying the Code and Standards to specific situations.

On the exam: The vignette gives you the inputs: the actors, relationships, benefits, trades, and disclosures. The item asks for two outputs, the governing Standard VI provision and the conduct’s status as required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited. It is a multiple-choice classification item, so match each fact to the provision before selecting the status. Your answer should name the actor, affected party, material fact, governing provision, conclusion, and prevention step.

Standard VI, Conflicts of Interest, is the conflict-control layer of the CFA Institute Code of Ethics. An outside benefit, relationship, or personal trade matters because it can pull your judgment away from a client or employer. Your answer should name the actor, affected party, material fact, governing provision, conclusion, and prevention step.

ProvisionTriggering factRequired response
Standard VI(A) Disclosure of ConflictsIndependence, objectivity, or duties may be impairedDisclose all matters reasonably expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with duties
Standard VI(B) Priority of TransactionsPersonal trade competes with client or employerClient and employer transactions take priority over personal transactions
Standard VI(C) Referral FeesBenefit tied to recommending product or serviceDisclose compensation or benefits received from or paid to others for recommending products or services

VI(A) and VI(C) require disclosure, while VI(B) controls priority. A conflict risk is not automatically a violation, but missing the duty or leaving the affected party unprotected is.

Use this compact rule when the question asks whether disclosure is enough. The first line protects the affected party, and the second line handles a personal trade.

$$ \begin{aligned} \text{Conflict response} &= \text{disclosure} + \text{avoid or manage when needed} \ \text{Personal transaction priority} &\leq \text{client and employer transaction priority} \end{aligned} $$

Read the plus sign as a response recipe, not permission to continue. Disclosure must be full and fair, in plain language, and in a prominent place. Avoid or manage a conflict when disclosure alone does not protect the affected party. A referral benefit must be disclosed to the employer, client, or prospective client, as appropriate.

Run the vignette through this sequence. It stops a prominent benefit from hiding a priority problem.

Loading diagram…

The flow sends you back to the affected party before you decide that disclosure is enough. Keep each provision attached to its trigger. A broad conflict question begins with the possibility that judgment or duties are impaired, then asks who bears that risk. A personal trade creates a separate timing test: compare it with client and employer activity. A benefit for a recommendation creates a compensation test. Naming the trigger first keeps the broad duty from obscuring the more specific rule.

Loading diagram…

Use required, recommended, permitted, and prohibited literally. This second map narrows the broad conflict check into three recognizable fact patterns. Match a general conflict to disclosure, a personal trade to priority, and a recommendation benefit to referral-fee disclosure. The labels describe the action the facts call for; they do not make every disclosed conflict acceptable. In particular, a personal trade cannot move ahead merely because someone has been told about it. Use the table to classify the response only after identifying the trigger and the party who needs protection.

StatusFact patternTreatment
RequiredVI(A) or VI(C) facts are presentMake the required disclosure
RecommendedConflict controls can reduce exposureUse preclearance or blackout procedures
PermittedDisclosure protects affected partyContinue only with safeguards
ProhibitedPersonal trade disadvantages client or employerDo not place it ahead

Preclearance is a recommended control, not a substitute for required disclosure. A permitted continuation still requires protection of the affected party. Disclosure is not consent. In the worked case, compare the manager’s personal order with the client order being prepared by the employer. The decisive detail is sequence: the manager buys before the client transaction is placed. That fact points to Standard VI(B), even though the example contains no referral payment. State the priority conclusion separately from the prevention step, which is to wait until client and employer transactions receive priority.

Worked example

You are a portfolio manager at Cedar Asset Management. Your employer is preparing a client order for RiverTech shares. Before the order is placed, you buy RiverTech for your personal account. The exam asks whether the personal trade is allowed and how you should have prevented the conflict.

ItemFact
ActorPortfolio manager
Affected partyClient and employer
Material factPersonal purchase precedes client order
Governing provisionStandard VI(B)
ConclusionPersonal trade lacks priority
Prevention stepWait for client and employer transactions

The wall makes the priority rule visible. Read its tiers from the top down: client and employer transactions stand ahead of the candidate’s personal account. The visual represents the ordering required by the facts, rather than a judgment about the investment’s merits. The manager should therefore pause the personal purchase while the client order is pending. This is the practical prevention step for the example, and it follows directly from the governing priority rule. Use that sequence to explain both why the trade cannot go first and what the manager should do instead.

  1. Name the actor and affected party. This fixes the duty on the portfolio manager and protects the client and employer. The result is one actor, the portfolio manager, and two affected parties, the client and employer.
  2. Isolate the material fact. The personal purchase precedes the client order, so the trades compete for priority. The result is one material fact: the personal purchase comes before the client order.
  3. Apply Standard VI(B). It makes client and employer transactions take priority, so the personal trade cannot go first. The result is one conclusion: the personal trade lacks priority.
  4. State the prevention step. Waiting for client and employer transactions to receive priority prevents the conflict. The result is one prevention step: wait before considering the personal trade.

The decision is to stop the personal purchase and let the client and employer transactions go first.

Changed condition

Keep the same manager, employer, client order, and RiverTech shares. Change one fact by replacing the personal purchase with a payment from the product provider for recommending RiverTech. Predict the new provision and prevention step before reading the table.

TestBeforeAfter
Material factPersonal purchase precedes client orderProvider pays for recommendation
Governing provisionStandard VI(B)Standard VI(C)
ResponseLet client and employer transactions go firstDisclose benefit to employer, clients, or prospective clients

The priority issue disappears because the personal trade disappears. A referral-fee issue takes its place because the provider's payment is tied to a recommendation. Standard VI(C) requires the specific disclosure, and Standard VI(A) may also apply if the payment could impair independence or objectivity. Before reading on, write the six-part answer in your own words.

Common error

You see a prominent disclosure and treat it as permission to continue any conflicted conduct. That feels right because the client has been told about the relationship, so you mistake disclosure for consent. If the facts show client disadvantage, your personal trade lacks priority, or you gain a benefit from a recommendation, test the governing Standard VI provision and avoid or manage the conflict when disclosure alone does not protect the affected party.

Go deeper

When you read a vignette, identify the actor and the conduct before choosing a Standard. Use the short map below only when the matching fact appears. A passing mention of a client or a payment does not trigger a different provision unless the vignette shows the related conduct.

Fact in vignetteNearby provision
Material nonpublic informationStandard II(A)
Client trade allocationStandard III(B)
Additional compensationStandard IV(B)

Treat the named provisions as rule-separation cues, not as extra conclusions. If none of the listed facts appears, keep your analysis with the Standard VI duties described above.

Check yourself

Practice

At Harborview Advisers, Mia manages client accounts and an employer retirement plan. A broker offers Mia a benefit for recommending the broker's fund. Mia receives the benefit, tells the employer but not the clients, and buys the fund for her personal account before a client order. A prominent client disclosure about the broker relationship is drafted, but the client order has not occurred.

Question 1

Which provision governs Mia's missing disclosure about the broker's benefit?

Question 2

Which provision governs Mia's personal purchase before the client order?

Question 3

Does the drafted prominent disclosure permit Mia's personal purchase before the client order?

Question 4

What prevention step best addresses Mia's facts?

A candidate discloses a conflict, but continuing would still disadvantage the client. Which action follows Standard VI(A)?

Revision snapshot

Use $\text{conflict response} = \text{disclosure} + \text{avoid or manage when needed}$, and keep personal transactions behind client and employer transactions. Standard VI(A): disclose all matters reasonably expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with duties. Disclosure is not a universal cure; avoid or manage a conflict when disclosure alone does not protect the affected party. Standard VI(B): client and employer transactions take priority over personal transactions. Standard VI(C): disclose compensation or benefits received from or paid to others for recommending products or services. The trap is treating prominent disclosure as permission. On the exam, the vignette hides the answer among actors, benefits, trades, and disclosures. Always name the actor, affected party, material fact, governing provision, conclusion, and prevention step.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Standard VI: Conflicts of interest in context

  1. 1. Calder Asset Management manages equity portfolios for pension plans, foundations, and private clients. Calder states that it follows the CFA Institute Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. Its chief investment officer, Keiko Sato, supervises the trading desk and is responsible for ensuring that the firm's compliance procedures are reasonably designed and enforced. To simplify short-term liquidity management, Calder deposits uninvested client cash in the same bank account used for payroll and other operating expenses. The accounting system separately identifies each client's balance, and the account is reconciled quarterly. No client has suffered a loss, and Calder's operations director proposes retaining the arrangement after adding a disclosure to client agreements. An independent custodian is available to maintain segregated client accounts at a modest cost. Calder's marketing group is preparing a presentation for prospective institutional clients. The firm's emerging-markets strategy contains 24 discretionary accounts managed under substantially similar mandates. Marketing proposes showing the five accounts that exceeded their benchmarks during the prior three years. As an alternative, it considers presenting one long-standing account that has historically tracked the strategy's target risk. Calder has sufficient records to construct a composite containing all fee-paying discretionary accounts that meet consistently applied strategy criteria. During the prior year, Calder introduced an automated trade-allocation system. Monthly compliance reports repeatedly identified allocations entered after trade execution, creating an opportunity to assign favorable trades selectively. Sato received the reports but did not investigate because no client had complained and the compliance department was responsible for routine testing. A subsequent review finds that one trader allocated several profitable trades to accounts generating higher fees. Calder had a written allocation policy, but supervisors did not test whether the policy was followed. Calder also directs trades to Arcway Brokerage. Calder's directors collectively own 12% of Arcway, and commissions from Calder represent approximately 30% of Arcway's annual revenue. Arcway provides competitive execution quality and charges commissions comparable with other brokers. Calder's client disclosures identify Arcway as an approved broker but do not describe the ownership or revenue relationship. Sato proposes increasing Arcway's share of client trading because its execution performance has recently improved.

    • 2. Elena Velasquez, CFA, is an equity analyst employed by Castellan Securities, which is headquartered in Country X. She has been assigned to prepare research while temporarily working in Country Y. Country X permits analysts to omit disclosure of small personal holdings in companies they cover. Country Y requires disclosure of every direct financial interest held by an analyst or an analyst's immediate family. The CFA Institute Code and Standards require disclosure of matters that could reasonably be expected to impair independence and objectivity or interfere with duties to clients. Castellan's compliance officer tells Velasquez to follow Country X law because that is where her employer is incorporated. Velasquez is invited to visit a remote mining property owned by Atlas Metals, a company she covers. Atlas offers first-class airfare, three nights at a luxury resort after the site visit, and entertainment for Velasquez and her spouse. Commercial flights and modest lodging are available, and Castellan has a policy permitting it to pay analysts' reasonable travel expenses. Atlas states that the visit will give Velasquez access only to information already included in public regulatory filings. Velasquez believes the trip would improve her understanding of the property but is concerned about preserving her objectivity. In a separate assignment, Velasquez analyzes a publicly traded retailer. Public information includes store locations, historical sales, and management's published expansion plan. She also purchases satellite-derived parking-lot estimates from a data vendor. The vendor lawfully gathers the observations and provides them to numerous institutional subscribers. Each weekly observation is too limited to influence a reasonable investor, but Velasquez combines the observations with public data and concludes that quarterly sales will exceed the market consensus. She documents the data sources, tests their reliability, and confirms that her model supports the recommendation. Marcus Kwan, Castellan's head trader, manages two accounts with different beneficial owners. Trading in a thinly traded security has declined ahead of month-end. Kwan proposes a series of offsetting purchases and sales between the accounts at progressively higher prices. He states that the trades will transfer beneficial ownership and will be allocated at equivalent execution prices. His internal message nevertheless explains that the program is intended to increase reported volume and establish a higher closing price before client statements are prepared. Separately, a broker who provides Castellan with substantial commission business asks Velasquez to ensure that his firm's largest client receives execution of a new buy recommendation before the recommendation is disseminated to other clients with similar investment objectives and account sizes. Castellan's written trade-allocation policy requires that all client accounts of comparable size and objective receive fair access to time-sensitive recommendations. The same broker also sends Kwan a quarterly gift card in appreciation for directing Castellan's order flow to the broker's trading desk.

      • 3. An adviser will receive USD 500 from an accountant for each referred prospect, whether or not the prospect becomes a client. The adviser should most likely disclose:

        • A. Only that a referral fee exists, without describing its structure
        • B. That the fee is paid only if the prospect becomes a client
        • C. The existence, amount, and non-contingent nature of the compensation arrangement
        Show answer

        Answer: C. The existence, amount, and non-contingent nature of the compensation arrangement

        The existence, amount, and non-contingent nature of the compensation arrangement - The adviser receives USD 500 from the accountant for each referred prospect, whether or not that prospect becomes a client. - Disclosing the payment and how it works lets prospects assess the referral-related conflict of interest. Only that a referral fee exists, without describing its structure - Saying only that a fee exists omits the USD 500 amount and the fact that payment does not depend on becoming a client. - Without those details, a prospect cannot fully evaluate the accountant’s financial incentive to make the referral. That the fee is paid only if the prospect becomes a client - This incorrectly describes the fee as contingent on the prospect becoming a client. - The accountant pays the adviser for each referred prospect regardless of the outcome, so that disclosure would misstate the arrangement.

      • 4. Daniel Cho, CFA, is a portfolio manager at Halcyon Advisory. One of his discretionary clients, Maya Ortiz, has a written investment policy statement establishing a 10-year horizon, moderate risk tolerance, and no expected withdrawals for three years. Ortiz recently informs Cho that she has agreed to purchase a business and must pay USD 600,000 in 60 days. Her USD 2.4 million Halcyon portfolio is invested primarily in small-cap equities and long-maturity corporate bonds. Cho believes the portfolio remains appropriate for Ortiz's long-term wealth objective and plans to sell assets only when the payment becomes due. Halcyon's procedures require investment policy statements to be reviewed when a client's circumstances materially change. Cho also covers a thinly traded security held by several client accounts. After completing research supporting an upgraded recommendation, Halcyon distributes the recommendation electronically at 10:00 a.m. to all clients for whom the security is suitable. Because some institutional clients have automated trading systems, they receive executions before retail clients who submit orders manually. Cho does not contact selected clients before the general distribution, and the security remains available for trading after the announcement. At 9:45 a.m., before the recommendation is released, Cho enters a purchase order for a beneficial account owned jointly with his spouse. He instructs the trading desk to execute the order only after all client orders received through 10:30 a.m. have been completed. At 11:00 a.m., after those client orders are filled, the desk executes Cho's order at a higher price. Halcyon's personal-trading policy permits such transactions when clients receive priority and the employee reports the trade. Separately, a financial technology company offers Cho USD 15,000 to test portfolio-reporting software during evenings and provide product feedback. The work would not involve Halcyon clients or confidential information, but the company plans to identify Cho publicly as a Halcyon portfolio manager. Cho provides Halcyon's chief operating officer with written details of the proposed duties, payment, and expected time commitment. The officer orally approves the arrangement. Cho accepts the offer without obtaining written consent because he believes disclosure in writing and oral approval are sufficient. No applicable law imposes requirements beyond the CFA Institute Code and Standards.

        • 5. A candidate passes Level II, remains registered for Level III, and prints “CFA, Level III” after her name. Her use of the designation is most likely:

          • A. Acceptable because she passed Level II
          • B. Improper because no partial CFA designation exists
          • C. Acceptable while she remains a candidate
          Show answer

          Answer: B. Improper because no partial CFA designation exists

          Improper because no partial CFA designation exists - “CFA, Level III” presents a partial designation, which CFA Institute does not recognize. - Only an eligible charterholder may put CFA after her name; passing Level II and registering for Level III do not confer the charter. Acceptable because she passed Level II - Passing Level II establishes examination progress, not the right to use the CFA designation. - She may accurately state that she passed Level II, but she may not print “CFA, Level III” after her name. Acceptable while she remains a candidate - Her Level III registration permits her to describe herself factually as a Level III candidate. - Candidate status does not permit CFA after her name because she has not earned the charter.

        • 6. Arun Patel, CFA, is a senior portfolio manager at Meridian Advisory. He plans to resign in six weeks and establish an independent advisory firm. His employment agreement contains no noncompetition clause, but it states that client lists, research reports, models, and other records created for Meridian are Meridian's property. The agreement is silent about preparations to establish a competing business. Before submitting his resignation, Patel registers a new company in his own name and signs a lease for office space beginning after his planned departure. He also contacts three Meridian clients from his personal telephone. He tells them that he expects to leave Meridian and asks whether they would transfer their accounts to his new firm after it opens. Two clients indicate that they probably will. Patel does not tell Meridian about these conversations. Patel has developed several valuation models while employed at Meridian. Some incorporate public market data, but the files also contain Meridian's internal assumptions, research notes, and prior client recommendations. Patel saves copies to a personal encrypted drive, reasoning that he wrote the models and can delete client names before using them at his new firm. He leaves the original files on Meridian's server. Meridian has not given him permission to retain copies. Patel personally purchases shares of a small-cap technology company for his own account on Monday morning before entering purchase orders for several client accounts in the same security later that day. The client orders are filled at a higher average price than Patel received. Patel does not disclose the timing of his personal trade to compliance or to the affected clients. When Meridian's research committee upgrades its rating on a core equity holding, Patel telephones his three largest clients to inform them of the change before the recommendation is distributed to all other clients through Meridian's standard notification system. Patel supervises junior analyst Sarah Kim. Kim frequently posts investment observations on a public social-media account that identifies her as a Meridian employee. Meridian has no procedure for reviewing employee posts. Kim recently described a speculative biotechnology security as a suitable core holding for conservative investors, although she had not reviewed the issuer's regulatory filings. Patel tells Kim to comply with the Code and Standards but neither reviews her earlier posts nor asks compliance to establish monitoring procedures. Meridian's compliance director, Lydia Lang, learns of Kim's post. Lang has authority to create supervisory controls and discipline employees. She considers sending all staff an annual reminder about professional conduct but does not plan to institute prepublication review or periodic monitoring because Meridian has not yet received a client complaint.

          Flashcards: Standard VI: Conflicts of interest in context

          1. 1. Regulation of security markets examples

            Show answer

            - disclosure requirements (provide transparency) - mitigate agency problems (ensure investor & agent alignment) - historically protect small investors

          Everything you need for CFA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF