Conforming vs violating conduct under Standard IV

Conforming vs violating conduct under Standard IV

Published September 28, 2026

Conforming vs violating conduct under Standard IV

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Identify conduct that conforms to the Code and Standards and conduct that violates the Code and Standards.

On the exam You will get a short employee-employer fact pattern with a material outside activity, benefit, opportunity, or supervisory red flag. First identify whose interest is affected. Then match the fact to the right part of Standard IV and choose the required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited response in an MCQ, matrix, or yes/no question.

An employee can harm an employer without taking employer cash. Using employer time or confidential information in a competing personal venture puts the employee's interest ahead of the employer's. A third-party benefit for services to the employer requires written consent from all parties involved before acceptance. A supervisor must act on warning signs and make reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations.

Standard IV requires the employee to act for the employer's benefit and not deprive the employer of the advantage of skills and abilities, divulge confidential information, or otherwise cause harm. Under IV(B), the member or candidate must obtain written consent from all parties involved before accepting a benefit. Under IV(C), a supervisor must make reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations by people subject to supervision.

Standard IV partConforming conductViolating conduct
Standard IVActs for employer's benefit, protects information, and does not deprive employer of the advantage of skills and abilitiesDeprives employer of skills or abilities, divulges confidential information, or otherwise causes harm
IV(A) LoyaltyKeeps employer's interest ahead of a competing personal interestPuts a competing personal interest ahead of employer's interest
IV(B) Additional Compensation ArrangementsObtains written consent from all parties involved before accepting the benefitAccepts the benefit without written consent from all parties involved
IV(C) Responsibilities of SupervisorsMakes reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations by supervised personsFails to make reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations by supervised persons

Do not let a moral reaction choose the row. Ask whose interest is affected, then match the material fact to the governing provision.

Once you have identified the affected party and governing provision, $C$ records whether the conduct conforms. Use this decision rule to choose the answer.

$$ C = \begin{aligned} &\text{conforms if the applicable Standard IV duty is met} \ &\text{violates if the applicable Standard IV duty is breached} \end{aligned} $$

Meeting the applicable duty moves the answer to conforms, while breaching it moves the answer to violates. Under IV(B), disclosure alone is not enough. The member or candidate must obtain written consent from all parties involved before accepting the benefit. Under IV(A), acting for the employer's benefit moves the answer to conforms, and under IV(C), reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations do the same.

Worked example

You are an employee who provides an introduction for your employer. A third party offers you a referral fee for that service. You disclose the fee to your employer, but consent has not been obtained from all parties. The exam asks whether accepting the fee conforms to Standard IV(B) and what you must do before acceptance.

FactGiven
ActorEmployee
Employer serviceIntroduction for employer
BenefitReferral fee from third party
Affected partiesEmployee, employer, and third party
DisclosureMade to employer only
ConsentNot obtained from all parties
Governing provisionIV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements

Read the facts in sequence: the fee rewards a service performed for the employer, so it falls under IV(B). The employer has heard about the offer, but the other parties have not all consented. Keep those facts separate when you reason through the decision. The diagram traces how the service, benefit, and consent condition lead to the response before acceptance.

Loading diagram…
  1. Match the fact to IV(B) by identifying that the referral fee is tied to services for the employer. This matters because IV(B) governs additional compensation connected with those services. The result is that IV(B) governs.
  2. Separate disclosure from consent by checking whether every affected party has agreed. This matters because telling the employer supplies information, but it does not provide consent from every affected party. The result is that the required condition is missing.
  3. Apply the timing rule by checking whether consent came before acceptance. This matters because consent must come before you accept the benefit. The result is that you do not accept the referral fee.
  4. Classify the conduct by comparing the proposed acceptance with IV(B). This matters because acceptance without all-party consent breaches IV(B). The result is conduct that violates Standard IV(B).

The conforming decision is to obtain consent of all parties before accepting the fee.

Changed condition

Only the consent condition changes. In the revised case, all parties consent before you accept the fee.

FactOriginal caseRevised case
Employer disclosureMade to employer onlyMade to employer only
All-party consentNot obtainedObtained before acceptance
ClassificationViolates IV(B)Conforms to IV(B)

Predict the move before reading the last column. Changing consent alone should change the classification because IV(B) requires consent before acceptance. Disclosure stays unchanged, so disclosure cannot explain the changed answer. Before reading on, classify a fresh case by naming the affected party and the governing part of Standard IV.

Common error

You may see that the employee disclosed the referral fee to the employer and mark the acceptance as conforming. That answer feels right because transparency sounds like consent, and the employer knows about the benefit. IV(B) asks whether all affected parties consented before acceptance, so disclosure to the employer alone is not enough.

Go deeper

When you see these labels in an ethics question, read them as different levels of instruction. An employee must obtain consent from all parties before accepting a third-party benefit, while written procedures for outside activities are only recommended and cannot replace that consent. A person may proceed only while the applicable duty remains satisfied, and the Code prohibits conduct that breaches it.

Response labelCandidate readingExample
RequiredCondition must be met firstAll parties consent before acceptance
RecommendedHelpful prevention practiceWritten procedures for outside activities
PermittedApplicable duty remains satisfiedOutside activity after required conditions
ProhibitedApplicable duty is breachedBenefit accepted without consent

When you read a fact pattern, separate a warning sign from proof of a violation. Disclosure can reduce risk by putting the fact before the people who need to evaluate it, but disclosure does not erase the conduct or create consent after the fact. An employee's disclosed activity can still violate IV(A), and an employee's disclosed benefit can still violate IV(B) when required consent is absent or was obtained only after acceptance.

Actor and provisionConflict or red flagConforming response
Employee, IV(A) LoyaltyUses employer time or information for competing ventureProtects employer's interests
Employee, IV(B) Additional Compensation ArrangementsAccepts referral fee before all-party consentObtains consent before acceptance
Supervisor, IV(C) Responsibilities of SupervisorsIgnores red flags about possible violationsMakes reasonable efforts to detect and prevent

On an exam question, name the actor and the red flag before choosing the standard. Under IV(A) Loyalty, ask whether the employee has put a personal or outside interest ahead of the employer's interest. Using employer time or confidential information for a competing personal venture can violate IV(A), while protecting the employer's interests conforms. Under IV(C) Responsibilities of Supervisors, a supervisor need not catch every violation, but must respond to red flags with reasonable efforts to detect and prevent them, and ignoring those red flags violates.

Check yourself

Practice

An employee accepts a referral fee after disclosing it only to the employer. Which response conforms to Standard IV(B)?

An employee uses employer time and confidential information for a competing personal venture. Which conclusion is most accurate?

Revision snapshot

Use $C$ for the final classification.

$$ C = \begin{aligned} &\text{conforms if duty is met} \ &\text{violates if duty is breached} \end{aligned} $$

LabelExam reading
RuleStandard IV: act for the employer's benefit and do not deprive the employer of skills, divulge confidential information, or otherwise cause harm.
IV(A) LoyaltyPersonal or outside interest ahead of employer can violate loyalty.
IV(B) Additional Compensation ArrangementsAll-party consent precedes acceptance of a third-party benefit for employer services.
IV(C) Responsibilities of SupervisorsMake reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations.
ProcedureWritten procedures are recommended, not required consent.
TrapDisclosure may reduce risk but is not a universal cure.
ContrastsFee before consent violates IV(B). Disclosure plus required consent conforms. Competing venture can violate IV(A). Protection conforms. Ignored red flags violate IV(C).
Exam moveName the affected party, provision, and required response.

Apply the matching row to the fact pattern.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Conforming vs violating conduct under Standard IV

  1. 1. Ashford Wealth Partners provides discretionary and non-discretionary investment management services. Its advisers are responsible for maintaining current investment policy statements and reviewing each client's objectives, constraints, and financial circumstances annually or after a reported material change. The firm's trade-allocation policy gives client orders priority over employee transactions and requires oversubscribed offerings to be allocated among eligible clients using a documented pro rata process. A long-standing client, Elena Novak, instructs her adviser to purchase a non-traded, leveraged real estate fund. The fund cannot be redeemed for at least two years and uses substantial leverage that could amplify losses beyond the initial investment. Novak's current investment policy statement expressly prohibits leveraged or illiquid alternative investments because she expects to draw on the portfolio for a business expansion in one year. Novak has reported no change in her liquidity requirement, wealth, risk tolerance, or time horizon. She says that because she selected the fund herself, Ashford need not assess suitability. The adviser considers executing the transaction if Novak signs a document acknowledging the risks. Ashford's research department is also preparing to downgrade a listed company from buy to hold. The recommendation will be released electronically at 9:30 a.m. to all clients entitled to receive the firm's equity research. A portfolio manager proposes telephoning Ashford's five clients with the highest trading volume ten minutes before release because those clients generate the most commission revenue. He would then call other clients after the electronic distribution. Ashford has sufficient systems to distribute the recommendation to all entitled clients simultaneously. The firm has also received a small allocation in an oversubscribed secondary bond offering. Eligible client demand substantially exceeds the bonds available. Before allocation, an employee submits a personal request for bonds. The employee has no role in selecting the issuer or determining the allocation, but beneficially owns the personal account. Some client expressions of interest remain unfilled. An issuer covered by one of Ashford's analysts offers the analyst stock options worth an estimated USD 15,000 if the issuer's securities outperform the sector during the following year. The options would be granted directly by the issuer in addition to the analyst's salary from Ashford. The analyst intends to disclose the arrangement in research reports but has not requested consent from Ashford or the issuer in writing. Separately, a junior analyst at Ashford discovers that a senior portfolio manager has been consistently mismarking illiquid security valuations to inflate reported portfolio performance. The junior analyst is uncertain whether to report the conduct internally given the seniority of the portfolio manager involved. Finally, Ashford's marketing department proposes paying a flat referral fee to independent financial planners who direct new clients to the firm, without requiring the planners to disclose the fee arrangement to the referred clients. The relevant account, dissemination, allocation, and compensation facts are summarized in Exhibit 1.

    • 2. Kingswell Asset Management recently hired Priya Shah as an equity analyst. At her previous employer, Shah developed a proprietary valuation model and supporting spreadsheets as part of her assigned work. Before resigning, she copied the model, historical assumptions, and internal research templates to a personal drive without requesting permission. The files contain no client names, but they include methodology and workpapers used by her previous employer. At Kingswell, Shah modifies the assumptions and begins using the files to value companies in her assigned sector. Martin Feld, CFA, is Kingswell's head of research and directly supervises six analysts. Kingswell requires each recommendation to be supported by retained source documents, model assumptions, and a review checklist. Feld learns that analyst Sun Kim issued an earnings forecast based largely on figures provided during a telephone conversation with an industry consultant. Kim did not retain notes, verify the figures, or document why the consultant was reliable. The forecast is scheduled for distribution to additional clients that afternoon. Feld instructs Kim to reconstruct the records when convenient but initially proposes allowing distribution because Kim's prior forecasts have generally been accurate. Feld also knows that the department's review checklist is rarely completed and that no employee verifies whether supporting records exist before publication. A Kingswell marketing employee prepares biographies for a client presentation. Analyst Sofia Ortiz passed Level II of the CFA Program, is registered for the next Level III examination, and satisfies all candidate conduct requirements. She has not completed Level III and has not applied for regular membership. The marketing employee proposes three possible descriptions: that Ortiz passed Level II of the CFA Program, that she is a Level II CFA specializing in global equities, or that she is expected to become a CFA charterholder next year. Kingswell has also adopted the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. Its Global Opportunities strategy has 28 fee-paying discretionary accounts with the same mandate. Twelve accounts have five-year records, and sixteen were opened more recently. During the most recent year, 17 accounts outperformed their assigned benchmarks and 11 underperformed. Marketing personnel propose presenting a composite containing only the accounts with five-year records. An alternative proposal would include only accounts that outperformed. All account records are accurate and available, and Kingswell can include every qualifying account without unreasonable cost or delay.

      • 3. Alder Peak Asset Management recently announced that it complies with the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. The firm's board asks its chief operating officer to review several proposed practices before the compliance claim is included in client materials. Alder Peak reports equity results using a composite intended to include all fee-paying discretionary accounts following its core equity strategy. During the most recent year, four terminated accounts experienced substantial losses before leaving the firm. Marketing proposes removing those accounts from the full historical record and presenting only accounts currently managed under a revised portfolio-construction methodology. The revised methodology altered security-weight limits but did not change the strategy's stated investment objective. The firm can reconstruct the complete composite, including terminated accounts, and can disclose the effective date and nature of the methodology change. The board has not appointed a compliance officer. The chief executive proposes giving the title to the head of sales, whose annual bonus is based primarily on net new assets. The head of sales would continue supervising marketing personnel and would be permitted to resolve suspected violations without reporting them to the board. An alternative candidate is a senior compliance professional who does not participate in investment management or sales and would have direct access to the board, authority to investigate potential violations, and a budget for employee training and monitoring. Alder Peak does not take custody of client securities. Client agreements direct all cash and securities to an unaffiliated qualified custodian. After a bond held in one client portfolio is redeemed, an operations employee proposes depositing the proceeds in Alder Peak's operating account for two business days while reconciling the transaction. The client's standing instructions already identify the qualified custodian account, and there is no legal or operational barrier to sending the cash directly to that account. Finally, the fixed-income team proposes revising a diversified income strategy. The revised strategy would hold fewer issuers, permit larger positions in below-investment-grade bonds, and invest in securities that may be difficult to sell during stressed markets. The team's expected-return estimate is unchanged, but internal stress testing shows materially larger losses and higher liquidation costs under adverse conditions. Marketing proposes describing the revision only as an enhancement to security selection and omitting the concentration and liquidity effects unless realised performance later falls below the benchmark.

        • 4. A discretionary mandate requires an adviser to vote all proxies in the client's best interest. Voting is economically feasible. The adviser should most likely:

          • A. Abstain because voting would reduce advisory revenue
          • B. Vote the proxies in accordance with the mandate
          • C. Vote only proposals supported by issuer management
          Show answer

          Answer: B. Vote the proxies in accordance with the mandate

          Vote the proxies in accordance with the mandate - The discretionary mandate expressly requires the adviser to vote all proxies in the client’s best interest. - Because voting is economically feasible, the adviser should carry out that responsibility rather than abstain. Abstain because voting would reduce advisory revenue - Reduced advisory revenue does not override the adviser’s duty under the mandate to vote the proxies. - Abstaining would leave the required votes uncast even though voting is economically feasible. Vote only proposals supported by issuer management - Management support is not the test for whether a proxy vote serves the client’s best interest. - Voting only management-supported proposals would fail to assess other proposals and would not fulfill the mandate to vote all proxies.

        • 5. Anika Patel, CFA, is a semiconductor analyst at Northbridge Securities. Northbridge has written policies requiring analysts who receive potentially material nonpublic information to notify compliance immediately and refrain from issuing or changing recommendations until compliance authorizes further action. Patel covers Radian Microdevices, whose shares are publicly traded. Radian's consensus revenue forecast for the current quarter is USD 640 million. Radian's investor relations director sends Patel a confidential email stating that the company's largest customer has cancelled a multiyear supply contract, which will reduce quarterly revenue to approximately USD 480 million. The email states that the information will not be announced until the following week and asks Patel to keep it confidential. Patel believes the shortfall would materially affect Radian's share price. She considers confirming the information through suppliers before changing her recommendation. Before receiving the email, Patel had issued a buy recommendation using several independently obtained inputs. While reviewing customs import/export filings that are publicly available, she noted that shipments of a key component to Radian's contract manufacturer had declined. A former Radian employee, now working for a competitor, mentioned to Patel in casual conversation that Radian's hiring of production-line staff had slowed. The former employee's comment concerned staffing at a single facility representing less than 1% of Radian's workforce and was not material by itself. Patel combined these observations with the public customs data and Radian's published capacity data to forecast slower growth. Northbridge's research committee reviewed and approved the resulting recommendation. Radian later invites Patel to attend an investor conference held aboard a chartered yacht, offering business-class airfare, an overnight stay on the yacht, and entertainment for Patel and a guest. Northbridge is willing to pay reasonable economy airfare and ordinary business accommodation. Patel believes attending would improve her understanding of Radian's strategy and proposes accepting the issuer's offer while disclosing the trip in her next research report. Patel also writes a monthly client newsletter distributed to Northbridge's institutional clients. In a section discussing semiconductor inventories, she reproduces two distinctive sentences from a competitor's publicly available research report without quotation marks or attribution. The newsletter does not mention Radian and contains no investment recommendation. When a colleague questions the wording, Patel responds that attribution is unnecessary because the source report was available without charge on the competitor's website.

          • 6. An adviser receives a fixed fee from a tax firm for each referred client. The adviser should most appropriately:

            • A. Disclose the arrangement only to clients who use the service
            • B. Disclose the arrangement to the employer and affected clients
            • C. Obtain written consent from every client before making referrals
            Show answer

            Answer: B. Disclose the arrangement to the employer and affected clients

            Disclose the arrangement to the employer and affected clients - Under CFA Standard VI(C), Referral Fees, the adviser must disclose the fixed fee received for each client referred to the tax firm. - Disclosure to the employer and affected clients or prospective clients lets them assess whether the payment influences the recommendation. Disclose the arrangement only to clients who use the service - The adviser must disclose the fee before an affected client decides whether to use the tax firm, not only after the client engages it. - The arrangement must also be disclosed to the employer, which this choice omits. Obtain written consent from every client before making referrals - Standard VI(C) requires disclosure of the referral-fee arrangement, not written consent from every client. - The adviser should inform the employer and affected clients or prospective clients, rather than seek consent from clients who receive no referral.

          Flashcards: Conforming vs violating conduct under Standard IV

          1. 1. In Ethical and Professional Standards, what is Standard IV?

            Show answer

            Duties to Employers.\ IV(A) Loyalty,\ IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements,\ IV(C) Responsibilities of Supervisors

          2. 2. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard IV-C), what is a member's duty regarding Responsibilities of Supervisors?

            Show answer

            They must make reasonable efforts to ensure that anyone subject to their supervision complies with applicable laws, rules, regulations, and the Code and Standards. If an inadequate compliance system exists, they must decline supervisory responsibility until it is fixed.

          3. 3. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard IV-B), what is required regarding Additional Compensation Arrangements?

            Show answer

            Members must obtain written consent from all parties involved before accepting any compensation or benefit that competes with or creates a conflict of interest with their employer's interest.

          4. 4. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard IV-A), what must a member do before engaging in independent practice for compensation?

            Show answer

            Provide notification to their employer fully describing the services, compensation, and duration, and obtain the employer's consent before beginning the practice.

          Everything you need for CFA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF