Practices and procedures preventing Standard I violations

Practices and procedures preventing Standard I violations

Published September 28, 2026

Practices and procedures preventing Standard I violations

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violations of the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.

On the exam: You will see a workplace or professional fact pattern involving a rule, benefit, communication, misconduct risk, or competence gap. The question may ask you to select required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited conduct in a best-choice, matrix, or yes/no format.

Most Standard I questions turn a workplace risk into a control. Identify the member or candidate, the affected party, and the exact Standard I provision before choosing the response. Disclosure can bring a conflict to the affected party's attention, but it is not consent and does not cure prohibited conduct.

StandardDutyPrevention control
Standard I.A Knowledge of the LawComply with all applicable rules, use stricter ruleCurrent law register, escalation
Standard I.B Independence and ObjectivityPreserve independence and objectivityGift pre-clearance, reassignment
Standard I.C MisrepresentationDo not knowingly misrepresent professional workSource verification, communication review
Standard I.D MisconductNo dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or adverse conductSupervision, documented approvals
Standard I.E CompetenceMaintain necessary competenceTraining, supervision, reassignment

Standard I.A controls rule conflicts and continuing violations. Standard I.B controls benefits and relationships that could impair judgment. Standards I.C and I.D control truthful, honest work, and Standard I.E controls competence.

Treat the answer path as a memory formula, not a calculation. Identify the duty, choose the conduct it requires or forbids, then add a control that prevents the same risk next time.

$$ \text{prevention answer} = \text{governing duty} + \text{correct conduct} + \text{preventive procedure} $$

The duty narrows the rule. Correct conduct moves the actor from risk to compliance. The procedure makes the decision repeatable through written guidance, training, supervision, reporting, or review. Disclosure can support a control, but it never overrides a prohibition.

Separate conduct status from control status.

StatusCandidate responseExample in this unit
RequiredFollow the Standard I dutyApply stricter rule
ProhibitedStop, decline, or dissociateAccept compromising benefit
RecommendedAdd a repeatable controlPre-clear gifts
PermittedProceed when no prohibition appliesDisclose noncompromising fact

Permitted conduct depends on the facts. Disclosure reports a fact. Consent gives permission. Standard I.B does not treat disclosure as consent or make prohibited conduct permitted.

Keep the provisions separate when a fact pattern contains multiple risks.

Start by matching the facts to one duty: a rule conflict points to I.A, a benefit that may affect judgment points to I.B, and a false communication points to I.C. Then check whether the facts also show dishonesty or a skill gap. This order keeps a familiar control from distracting you from the conduct the rule actually requires.

Loading diagram…

Use the map to route the fact to the governing Standard before choosing a procedure.

A good recommendation pairs the governing duty with a control that catches the risk early. Encourage the employer to put the control in writing, train members and candidates to use it, and review whether it is working. For example, a law register helps identify a stricter rule, while escalation gives the member a path when a supervisor disagrees. A control should fit the risk and make the compliant action repeatable.

ProcedureRisk it catchesCandidate action
Current law registerRule changes or conflictsCheck before acting
Written compliance proceduresRepeated workplace risksFollow documented steps
Gift pre-clearanceBenefits near recommendationsDecline or seek review
Communication reviewAltered facts or opinionsVerify sources and wording
Competence trainingResponsibility exceeds skillTrain before acting
SupervisionWork lacks reviewReview and coach
Escalation channelsSupervisor dismisses concernReport and document
Documented approvalsReassignment decisionsPreserve written decision

These controls are recommended procedures. A missing control creates risk, but it does not automatically create a violation. A specific Standard I duty can still make the underlying conduct required or prohibited.

Read the procedure column as a set of practical safeguards around the actor. A register supports rule checks; pre-clearance catches questionable benefits before they influence a recommendation; review and supervision catch errors in work or judgment. Escalation and written approvals help when the first decision maker cannot resolve a concern. These steps reduce dependence on memory, and they leave a record of how the member responded.

The member or candidate stays at the center because the duty belongs to the actor. The surrounding controls reduce reliance on memory or supervisor goodwill and give the actor a path to follow when a risk appears.

Worked example

You are handed a local rule and your firm's manual for the same activity. The local rule is stricter, but your supervisor tells you to ignore it. Choose the response that prevents the analyst's violation.

FactGiven
ActorAnalyst and candidate
Rule conflictLocal rule is stricter
Supervisor instructionIgnore the local rule
Governing provisionStandard I.A
Preventive responseEscalate, comply, dissociate if ongoing

First compare the two sources of rules, because the candidate cannot choose whichever instruction is easier. If the local requirement is stricter, it governs the activity even when the firm's manual is less demanding. The supervisor's direction does not remove that duty. The candidate should use the compliance channel to surface the conflict, follow the applicable rule, and keep a record of the response. If the supervisor continues to direct a violation, ending participation protects against knowingly assisting it. Trace each step in that order before selecting the response.

Loading diagram…
  1. Compare the local rule with the manual because both govern the activity. The comparison produces one controlling requirement: Standard I.A makes the stricter rule control.
  2. Escalate through the designated channel because the supervisor's instruction conflicts with the rule. The escalation produces one documented record of the conflict.
  3. Comply with the local rule because Standard I.A requires the stricter requirement. The result is one compliant decision that rejects the weaker manual.
  4. Dissociate if the supervisor continues because Standard I.A prohibits knowingly assisting and requires dissociation. The result is one documented end to your participation.

The answer recommends escalation and documentation, but treats compliance with the stricter local rule and dissociation from a continuing violation as required.

An issuer offers a research analyst luxury travel before a recommendation. The material fact is a professional benefit, so Standard I.B governs. Decline it or obtain an appropriate reassignment because a benefit reasonably expected to compromise independence or objectivity is prohibited. Disclosure does not cure it. Gift pre-clearance and written reassignment approval prevent recurrence.

A candidate knowingly alters a source's risk description to strengthen a recommendation. Standards I.C and I.D govern because the candidate distorted a professional communication and acted dishonestly. Stop the communication. The recommended controls are escalation, source verification, and independent review before any revision proceeds.

Changed condition

FactOriginalChanged
Local ruleStricter than manualStricter than manual
SupervisorSays ignore itSupports compliance
Immediate responseEscalate, dissociate if ongoingComply, document

Only the supervisor's instruction changes, shifting from telling you to ignore the stricter local rule to supporting compliance. The local rule itself does not change, so Standard I.A still points you toward compliance. Because the supervisor no longer creates an active conflict, you do not escalate or dissociate unless the violation continues, and you document the response. Before reading on, write the one action Standard I.A still requires.

Common error

You tell the issuer about luxury travel and then accept the trip before publishing a recommendation. That can feel acceptable because disclosure appears transparent and lets readers judge your bias, but the issuer is offering a benefit that could reasonably be expected to compromise your independence or objectivity. Standard I.B prohibits you from offering, soliciting, or accepting it, even if you disclose it.

Check yourself

Practice

Which response should the analyst recommend to prevent a Standard I.A violation?

An issuer offers a research analyst luxury travel before a recommendation. Which conduct conforms to Standard I.B?

A candidate knowingly changes a source's risk description to strengthen a recommendation. Which preventive response should be recommended?

Classify each action under Standard I.

RequiredRecommendedProhibited
Follow the stricter rule
Use gift pre-clearance
Accept a compromising benefit
Maintain necessary competence

Disclosing an issuer's luxury travel offer makes accepting the travel permissible under Standard I.B.

Revision snapshot

Use $\text{prevention answer} = \text{duty} + \text{conduct} + \text{procedure}$.

StandardRule
Standard I.AMembers and candidates identify applicable rules. Use stricter conflicts. Do not knowingly assist. Dissociate.
Standard I.BReasonable care and judgment preserve independence and objectivity. Benefits reasonably expected to compromise either are prohibited, even if disclosed.
Standard I.CDo not knowingly misrepresent investment analysis, recommendations, actions, or professional activities.
Standard I.DDo not engage in professional dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or conduct harming reputation, integrity, or competence.
Standard I.EAct with and maintain necessary competence for professional responsibilities.

Analyst finds stricter local rule. Apply I.A, escalate, comply, dissociate if ongoing. Issuer offers luxury travel before recommendation. Apply I.B, decline or reassign. Disclosure does not cure it. Candidate alters source risk description. Apply I.C and I.D, stop, escalate, verify, independently review. Prevent with a current law register, written procedures, gift pre-clearance, communication review, competence training, supervision, escalation channels, and documented approvals. On exam, classify conduct before control. Controls stay recommended unless Standard I makes conduct required or prohibited.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Practices and procedures preventing Standard I violations

  1. 1. Elena Ortiz, CFA, is an equity analyst at Northbridge Securities. She is preparing a recommendation on Vectra Components, a publicly traded manufacturer. Vectra has publicly reported that customer demand remains stable and that it has retained its major contracts. Ortiz reviews public shipping records showing a gradual increase in deliveries from Vectra's principal factory. She also speaks with several suppliers. No supplier discloses Vectra's orders, revenue, or earnings. One supplier notes that weekend loading activity appears slightly higher than usual, while another says that demand for a common industrial input has recently increased across several customers. Ortiz regards each observation as immaterial but concludes, after combining them with public information and her industry model, that Vectra's sales will exceed market expectations. Before publication, Vectra invites Ortiz and ten other analysts to tour a new production facility. Vectra offers first-class airfare, three nights at a luxury resort, and entertainment unrelated to the facility visit. Northbridge's policy permits analysts to attend legitimate issuer events but requires the firm to pay transportation and lodging when issuer hospitality is more than nominal. Ortiz believes she should accept because all invited analysts will receive the same package. During the review of Ortiz's draft report, Northbridge's research director says that Vectra's chief executive has complained that the proposed price target is too conservative. The director instructs Ortiz to replace it with a substantially higher target supplied by Vectra's investor-relations department. The department provides no valuation model, forecast, or supporting assumptions. The director tells Ortiz that his approval provides a sufficient basis for publishing the revised target. Ortiz retains her original earnings model, which supports only the lower target. Ortiz publishes the report using her original target and clearly distinguishes historical facts, third-party observations, estimates, and her opinion. Two weeks later, Vectra sends her a watch valued at USD 4,000 with a note thanking her for fair coverage. Northbridge's gift policy requires employees to report gifts exceeding USD 100 but does not expressly prohibit accepting them. Ortiz has not accepted or returned the watch and asks the compliance officer how to proceed.

    • 2. Meridian Asset Partners claims compliance with the CFA Institute Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. Sofia Ortega supervises six portfolio managers and has authority to enforce Meridian's trading and personal-dealing procedures. Compliance sends Ortega monthly exception reports identifying repeated employee trades placed shortly before client block orders. Ortega does not review the reports because she assumes compliance will investigate any serious matter. The chief compliance officer has informed supervisors that they remain responsible for reviewing and resolving exceptions involving their teams. Meridian's research committee changes its recommendation on a thinly traded security from hold to sell. The firm posts the recommendation to all clients simultaneously through its secure client portal, and portfolio managers then contact clients according to documented suitability and trading procedures. When the resulting sell orders are aggregated and executed, the security receives only a partial fill. The trading desk proposes allocating the filled shares first to the accounts that submitted trading instructions earliest in the day, without regard to each account's proportional order size, on the rationale that this approach rewards portfolio managers who acted quickly. A third-party custodian offers Meridian discounted technology services for every prospective client whom Meridian refers and who opens a custody account. The discount will reduce Meridian's operating costs by approximately USD 800 per successful referral. Meridian's compliance department approves the arrangement. Marketing materials identify the custodian as an independent service provider but do not disclose the referral benefit. Meridian plans to explain the benefit only to clients who directly ask whether the firm receives compensation. Meridian prepares a presentation showing its flagship strategy's five-year performance. The composite calculation accurately includes all discretionary, fee-paying accounts that remained open at the end of each calendar year. It excludes three accounts that terminated during the measurement period after experiencing weak performance. Including those accounts would reduce the reported five-year annualized return from 9.4% to 8.7%. The presentation does not explain the exclusion but accurately states the benchmark return and fee schedule. Ortega argues that the presentation is fair because the reported return has been correctly calculated for the accounts Meridian currently manages. Separately, Ortega serves, without compensation, on the board of a privately held company that has recently become a takeover target of a publicly traded company held in several Meridian client portfolios. Ortega has not disclosed her board position to Meridian's compliance department and does not intend to trade the affected security herself.

      • 3. Harbor Peak Asset Management manages pooled infrastructure and global equity funds. The firm's board appoints a compliance officer but allows the head trader to restrict the officer's access to order-management records. The officer must obtain the trader's approval before interviewing trading personnel and reports only to the head trader. Chief Investment Officer Daniel Morgan argues that this structure is efficient because the trading desk understands its own procedures. Another director recommends giving the compliance officer authority to examine all relevant records and direct access to the chief executive and board. Portfolio manager Mei Liu manages Harbor Peak's pooled infrastructure fund. The offering documents permit investments in listed and unlisted infrastructure assets, limit unlisted investments to 30% of net asset value, and establish a long-term total-return objective. Harbor Peak has no separate advisory agreement with any underlying investor and does not collect information about each investor's full portfolio. Several investors tell Liu that they personally need daily liquidity and ask her to avoid all unlisted assets. Other investors favor using the full 30% allocation. Liu must decide which suitability framework governs her decisions for the pooled vehicle. Liu also oversees proxy voting for the global equity fund. Harbor Peak has disclosed a policy stating that it will vote proxies in clients' best interests after considering the proposal's significance and the expected costs and benefits of voting. A foreign-market ballot concerns an economically significant merger, but submitting the vote requires temporary share blocking and administrative expense. Liu estimates that the expected portfolio benefit from participating may exceed those costs, although the conclusion requires additional analysis. A colleague proposes automatically abstaining from every foreign-market vote, while another insists that every ballot must be voted regardless of cost. Separately, Morgan learns that a trader has been allocating profitable trades to a proprietary seed-capital account and less profitable trades to client accounts after observing intraday price movements. The allocations were not disclosed to clients and conflict with written pre-allocation procedures. Morgan initially plans to send the trader a general reminder about the policy but not review earlier allocations unless a client complains. The compliance officer recommends immediately stopping the practice, investigating prior allocations, correcting client harm where identified, and testing enhanced allocation controls. Morgan has authority over the trader and the resources to conduct the recommended review.

        • 4. An asset manager follows every Asset Manager Code provision except the required risk-management process. Regarding compliance claims, the manager should most appropriately:

          • A. Refrain from claiming compliance with the Code
          • B. Claim compliance while identifying the omitted provision
          • C. Claim partial compliance for the implemented provisions
          Show answer

          Answer: A. Refrain from claiming compliance with the Code

          Refrain from claiming compliance with the Code - The Asset Manager Code permits a compliance claim only when the manager meets all applicable provisions. - Because the manager lacks the required risk-management process, it cannot claim compliance despite following every other provision. Claim compliance while identifying the omitted provision - Identifying the missing risk-management process does not make the manager compliant with all applicable provisions. - Disclosure cannot cure the omission for purposes of a Code compliance claim. Claim partial compliance for the implemented provisions - The Code does not permit partial compliance claims based on provisions the manager has implemented. - Following every other provision does not offset the missing required risk-management process.

        • 5. Sofia Nguyen is a portfolio manager at Harbor Crest Advisers. She manages discretionary accounts under written investment policy statements and also maintains a personal brokerage account that is reported to Harbor Crest's compliance department. A small initial public offering becomes available to Harbor Crest. Before the final allocation is known, Nguyen identifies which client accounts permit the investment, determines that the security is suitable for those accounts, and records each eligible client's indicated interest. The offering is then substantially oversubscribed. Harbor Crest's written allocation procedure requires pro rata allocation among suitable participating accounts. Nguyen considers instead favoring accounts that pay higher advisory fees or dividing the shares equally across every account she manages, including accounts whose policies prohibit speculative securities. Two days later, Nguyen recommends purchasing publicly traded Meridian Systems shares for several client accounts. She also wants to purchase the same shares for her personal account and considers combining her personal order with the client orders into a single block trade to reduce transaction costs. The market is sufficiently thin that a block trade would receive one average execution price unless the broker allocates a more favorable fill to a specific participant. Harbor Crest permits employee investments when they are reported and when client transactions are not disadvantaged relative to employee transactions. Nguyen has made all required personal-holdings disclosures. Nguyen also manages the account of the Waterford Foundation. As a token of appreciation for her service, the foundation's chair offers to give Nguyen a personal gift of a paid family vacation valued at approximately USD 8,000 each year, regardless of the account's investment performance. The gift arrangement has not been addressed in Harbor Crest's contract with the foundation, and Nguyen has not yet informed Harbor Crest's compliance department about the offer. Finally, Nguyen intends to resign and establish an independent advisory firm. Her employment agreement contains no non-competition or non-solicitation clause. Before resigning, she considers telling Harbor Crest clients about her planned firm. She also considers copying the firm's client files and account histories. Alternatively, she could wait until after her departure and identify prospective clients using public directories, publicly available regulatory filings, and contact information she remembers without consulting or taking Harbor Crest records. Local law does not prohibit lawful competition by a former employee.

          • 6. A manager directs client brokerage to purchase research. Which use of the resulting client commissions is most appropriate?

            • A. Use the commissions for general office expenses
            • B. Use the commissions for research benefiting unrelated accounts
            • C. Use the commissions for research benefiting the paying clients
            Show answer

            Answer: C. Use the commissions for research benefiting the paying clients

            Use the commissions for research benefiting the paying clients - Client brokerage is a client asset, so research purchased with those commissions should benefit the clients whose trades generated them. - This use connects the cost paid by those clients to an investment-related benefit they receive. Use the commissions for general office expenses - General office expenses primarily benefit the manager, not the clients whose brokerage commissions pay for them. - They are not research or brokerage services that justify using client commissions. Use the commissions for research benefiting unrelated accounts - Research benefiting only unrelated accounts does not benefit the clients whose commissions purchased it. - The fact that the purchase is research does not justify charging its cost to clients who receive no benefit.

          • 7. An analyst prepares a supported recommendation but leaves her employer before publication. No law governs record retention, and the records belong to the firm. She should most likely:

            • A. Delete the draft because the recommendation was never published
            • B. Retain the draft only if local law expressly requires retention
            • C. Preserve the draft and supporting records under firm procedures
            Show answer

            Answer: C. Preserve the draft and supporting records under firm procedures

            Preserve the draft and supporting records under firm procedures - CFA Standard V(C), Record Retention, requires records supporting an investment recommendation to be maintained, even when the recommendation has not been published. - Because the records belong to the employer, the departing analyst should leave the draft and supporting material with the firm for retention under its procedures. Delete the draft because the recommendation was never published - Nonpublication does not make the analysis and its supporting records disposable. - The analyst cannot destroy firm-owned records simply because she leaves before the recommendation is issued. Retain the draft only if local law expressly requires retention - The absence of a governing law does not remove the professional duty to maintain records supporting investment analysis. - Because the records are the firm’s property, retention should follow firm procedures rather than depend solely on an express legal requirement.

          • 8. Before leaving his employer, an analyst wants to retain employer-owned models and supporting records. No agreement permits removal. The analyst should most likely:

            • A. Take the models because he created them while employed
            • B. Leave the files and reconstruct models from public information
            • C. Take copies after deleting the firm's client identifiers
            Show answer

            Answer: B. Leave the files and reconstruct models from public information

            Leave the files and reconstruct models from public information - The employer-owned models and supporting records must remain with the employer because no agreement permits removal. - The analyst may later reconstruct models from public information without copying the employer’s files. Take the models because he created them while employed - Creating the models during employment does not give the analyst ownership of the employer’s records. - Taking them would remove employer property without permission. Take copies after deleting the firm's client identifiers - Deleting client identifiers does not make the models or supporting records the analyst’s property. - Copying the files would still require the employer’s permission, which the analyst does not have.

          Flashcards: Practices and procedures preventing Standard I violations

          1. 1. In Ethical and Professional Standards, what is Standard I?

            Show answer

            Professionalism. (I(A) Knowledge of the Law,\ I(B) Independence and Objectivity,\ I(C) Misrepresentation,\ I(D) Misconduct

          2. 2. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard I-A), what must a member do if they suspect someone is participating in illegal or unethical activities?

            Show answer

            The member must disassociate from the activity, urge the firm to cease the activity, and potentially step away from their position if the firm ignores the warning. (Reporting to regulatory authorities may be required by law, but is not explicitly mandated by the Standards).

          3. 3. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Ethics Application), if an analyst incorporates a large part of another analyst's report without citation to support their own recommendation, what standard is violated?

            Show answer

            Standard I-C (Misrepresentation), specifically Plagiarism. The second analyst is also violating Standard V-A (Diligence and Reasonable Basis) by not performing independent analysis.

          4. 4. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Ethics Application), if a client offers a member an all-expenses-paid trip as a reward for past performance, what must the member do?

            Show answer

            The member must disclose the gift to their employer to comply with Standard I-B (Independence and Objectivity). (Note: Because it is for \past\ performance, it is a gift, not an additional compensation arrangement requiring written consent from all parties).

          5. 5. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard I-C), what constitutes Plagiarism under Misrepresentation?

            Show answer

            Using reports, forecasts, models, ideas, charts, graphs, or spreadsheets created by others without crediting the source. (Recognized financial/statistical reporting services are an exception).

          6. 6. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard I-A), what must a member do in the event of a conflict between applicable laws and the Code and Standards?

            Show answer

            Members must comply with the stricter of the law, rule, or regulation.

          7. 7. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard I-B), what are the rules regarding gifts from clients under Independence and Objectivity?

            Show answer

            Gifts from clients are less likely to compromise independence than gifts from corporate issuers. Modest gifts are acceptable, but they must be disclosed to the member's employer prior to acceptance (or subsequently, if prior is not possible).

          8. 8. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Standard I-D), what specific actions fall under Misconduct?

            Show answer

            Engaging in any professional conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, or deceit, or committing any act that reflects adversely on professional reputation, integrity, or competence.

          Everything you need for CFA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF