Ethics has enough weight to change your Level I result, because a short stem can turn on who received a benefit, who possessed information, whether a client received a fair opportunity, or whether an action harmed the integrity of the market. The questions are often short fact patterns with an actor, a material fact, and a policy or action, yet those few lines can test whether you can separate an ethical concern from an actual violation, identify the duty owed to the client or employer, and match the conduct to the right Standard rather than to a broad feeling about fairness. Without a repeatable method, you may choose a personal moral reaction, treat an employer policy as permission, or accept disclosure as a cure, especially when the actor sounds well intentioned or claims that everyone in the firm follows the same practice. A gift can look harmless until its size affects independence, and a conversation can sound ordinary until you ask whether the information was public and whether someone could trade on it. Treat each question as a controlled investigation, locating the actor and the person or market that may be affected, isolating the fact that changes the analysis, identifying the duty that reaches that fact, and deciding whether the conduct met the Standard. This sequence keeps you from condemning an awkward action that is allowed or excusing a polished action that creates a conflict, misleads a client, or places the professional's interest ahead of the client's interest.
Loading diagram…
These outcomes work together. You evaluate the facts against the exact Standard, then explain why the practices, policies, or conduct do or do not violate the CFA Institute Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct, while keeping the actor's responsibility separate from the firm's reputation, the client's reaction, and the fact that no one has complained. The explanation also points to prevention, so a good answer does more than attach a label to the conduct. It shows what control, conversation, approval, disclosure, record, or escalation would have addressed the risk before the client, employer, or market was exposed. A candidate might see a manager receive an outside benefit and focus only on whether the benefit changed the recommendation, but the exam may ask whether the arrangement created a conflict that should have been disclosed, declined, or submitted for approval. A candidate might see a disclosure and stop there, even though disclosure can reveal a conflict without removing the duty to act fairly or protect confidential information. When you practice, state the path from fact to conclusion and then name the prevention that fits the fact, such as seeking written approval for a personal activity, declining a benefit that threatens independence, restricting access to sensitive information, correcting a misleading presentation, or escalating a suspected breach through the firm's compliance process. The best prevention is not the longest policy list. It is the action that blocks the conduct or manages the conflict described in the stem.
The Code is not optional personal advice, and an employer policy cannot automatically override the Standards, so a supervisor's instruction does not remove your own professional responsibility when you know the conduct conflicts with a requirement. A firm manual can tell you how to request approval or report a gift, but it cannot turn an otherwise prohibited action into a permitted one, and a client's request cannot erase a duty owed to that client or to the market. A law, regulation, or workplace rule in the stem is a fact to evaluate, not an automatic answer, so ask whether it applies to the actor, whether it sets a more strict requirement than the Code, and whether the Code or a Standard imposes an additional duty that still governs the professional's conduct. The same policy can be a useful control in one fact pattern and an inadequate defense in another, depending on what the actor did and which requirement the question asks you to apply. The giveaway is a conflict between requirements, so identify the governing requirement before judging the actor. If applicable law and the Code point in different directions, comply with the more strict requirement that applies, and seek guidance when you cannot resolve the conflict from the facts given. On the exam, wording about a manager's permission, a local workplace rule, a client's instruction, or common industry practice often makes one answer feel practical, but that wording is not proof that the conduct is acceptable. Ask who made the rule, what duty it can control, and whether the actor still owes a stricter obligation under the Standards. That final check helps you choose an answer based on the professional requirement rather than on convenience, custom, or an unsupported claim that disclosure solved the problem.
Applying the Code and Standards to scenarios - Rule: identify the actor and material fact, then apply the exact Standard; under Standard I(A) Knowledge of the Law, follow applicable requirements and the more strict one when they conflict. The exam gives a short conduct or policy fact pattern and asks you to classify conduct as required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited. The trap is letting personal morality, employer approval, or common practice replace the governing Standard and affected party.
Identifying violations and recommending remedies - Rule: connect the material fact to the exact requirement and affected party, explain whether conduct violates it, and choose prevention that addresses the risk; disclosure is not consent or a universal cure. The exam may name a Standard, present matrix rows, or ask for a yes-or-no conclusion and remedy. The trap is giving a bare conclusion or treating disclosure as a fix without checking whether the underlying conduct remains prohibited.
The conduct words carry different force. Read them as the stem states them, then check the exact requirement and its conditions.
| Conduct category | Rule effect |
|---|---|
| Required | The rule demands the action |
| Recommended | Good practice, not automatically mandatory |
| Permitted | Allowed when conditions hold |
| Prohibited | Forbidden, even after disclosure |
Disclosure can feel like the safest repair because it gives the affected party information. It does not create informed consent, and it cannot remove a duty that prohibits the conduct. When the stem says disclosed, ask what the exact Standard permits.
A recommendation can feel like a command, especially when a compliance manual uses strong language. That does not convert a recommended procedure into a mandatory duty, and a control risk does not by itself prove a violation. The words must, should, may, and must not tell you which conclusion the facts support.
Locate the governing area before judging the action. The map gives you a compact memory route, while the full Standard names appear in the revision snapshot.
Loading diagram…
The map groups the Standards by professional duty, so use it to narrow the search before deciding whether a specific rule applies. A short stem may contain several plausible concerns, but only one fact usually controls the classification. Name the actor, isolate that fact, and then test the conduct against the relevant Standard. This keeps the map from becoming a list to memorize without application.
| Question shape | What is given and asked | The trap |
|---|---|---|
| Short fact pattern | Actor, material fact, policy or action. Decide violation. | Personal morality replaces the Standard |
| Named Standard | Rule, affected party, conduct. Explain violation or no violation. | Conclusion without a rule-based reason |
| Matrix grid | Several conduct rows. Mark each violation. | One rule applied to every row |
| Yes or no | A single action and named Standard. Choose yes or no. | Disclosure treated as a universal cure |
| Law or policy conflict | Law, regulation, or workplace rule. Decide governing duty. | Employer approval overrides the Standards |
Evaluate asks for a classification against the rule. Explain asks you to connect the material fact to the rule and affected party. A matrix asks you to repeat that application for each row, while a yes-or-no format compresses the response.
Law and regulation trigger Knowledge of the Law and the more strict requirement. A workplace policy is another fact, not an automatic override of the Standards. When disclosure appears, ask whether the rule permits informed consent and whether the underlying conduct remains prohibited. The response format changes, but the reasoning does not.
Practice
A jurisdiction permits conduct that the CFA Institute Standards prohibit. A member follows the jurisdictional rule. Which conclusion best applies?
A portfolio manager discloses a personal holding before recommending a security. The manager then trades to move the market price. Which conclusion best applies?
A question states that a compliance procedure is recommended rather than required. The member skips it, and the facts show no separate prohibited conduct. How should you evaluate the conduct?
Which sequence best applies when a fact pattern asks whether conduct violates the Code?
Candidates often choose the answer that feels most ethical. It feels safe because the stem sounds like a moral judgment, but the giveaway is an answer that never names the governing Standard and affected party. Say the rule aloud before you choose.
| Rule or decision | Apply it this way | Common trap |
|---|---|---|
| Application path | Actor, material fact, exact Standard | Jumping to personal morality |
| Conduct category | Classify as required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited | Treating recommended as mandatory |
| Standards map | I Professionalism. II Integrity of Capital Markets. III Duties to Clients. IV Duties to Employers. | Memorizing labels without finding the affected party |
| Standards map continued | V Investment Analysis, Recommendations, and Actions. VI Conflicts of Interest. VII Responsibilities as a CFA Institute Member or Candidate. | Treating one Standard as universal |
| Knowledge of Law | Comply with applicable law, rules, and regulations. Follow the more strict requirement when they conflict. | Letting permission override duty |
| Disclosure and consent | Disclosure is not consent. It is not a universal cure for prohibited or otherwise improper conduct. | Assuming disclosure ends the inquiry |
| Violation versus risk | A violation is not the same as conduct that merely creates ethical or compliance risk. Identify the exact governing requirement. | Calling every control gap a breach |
Use the snapshot as a final check after you have read the facts. First locate the actor and affected party, then distinguish a breached requirement from a control weakness that only creates risk. Check whether the conduct category is mandatory, recommended, conditional, or forbidden, and whether disclosure changes anything under that specific rule. For a conflict between requirements, apply the more strict one that governs. Your conclusion should name both the rule and the fact that makes it apply.
.
Application path: actor → material fact → exact Standard → required, recommended, permitted, or prohibited conduct → conclusion → prevention. It keeps the conclusion tied to a rule instead of personal morality. A permitted action needs its conditions, a recommended procedure remains recommended, and a prohibited action cannot be repaired by disclosure. Finish by naming the prevention step that addresses the material fact.
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more
1. Harborview Asset Management is revising its ethics and compliance procedures. Analyst David Morse plans to leave the firm after completing a recommendation that is no longer active. The supporting file includes interview notes, valuation spreadsheets prepared on Harborview's systems, licensed third-party data, and the published report. Harborview's policy identifies records created within the scope of employment as firm property and requires them to remain with the firm. The policy permits employees to retain copies of models developed entirely before employment if no confidential information or licensed firm data are included. Morse proposes deleting the supporting file because the recommendation has expired and keeping only the published report. He also wants to retain an unrelated valuation template that he created before joining Harborview. Morse expects to establish an independent advisory practice. He plans to recommend a specialty bond fund managed by his brother-in-law to prospective clients whenever it fits their objectives. Morse believes the fund is a strong investment and does not intend to mention the family relationship unless a client happens to ask. At Harborview, research director Mei Chen supervises twelve analysts. One analyst, preparing a sector recommendation, relies exclusively on a licensed third-party data vendor's proprietary valuation model and issues the recommendation without performing any independent review of the vendor's assumptions or testing the model's output against Harborview's own data. Separately, compliance flags brokerage records showing that another analyst placed a personal trade in a security shortly before issuing a buy recommendation on the same security, then filled client orders only after the personal trade had settled. Junior analyst Sara Lee recently sat for the Level III CFA examination. Several days later, she discusses specific test questions from the exam with colleagues in a study group so they can prepare for a future sitting. Lee separately drafts a client-facing summary comparing two bonds and blends her personal opinion about future interest-rate movements with the bonds' stated coupon and maturity dates without indicating which statements are opinion and which are fact.
2. An analyst overhears an issuer director state that an unannounced tender offer at a substantial premium has board approval. The analyst should most likely:
Answer: A. Stop trading and submit the information to compliance
> Key point: Do not trade on material nonpublic information; stop trading and report it to compliance. Why Stop trading and submit the information to compliance is correct - An unannounced tender offer at a substantial premium with board approval is material nonpublic information. - The analyst must not trade on it or cause others to trade, and should submit it to compliance. Why the other options are wrong - Trade only in accounts without tender-offer restrictions: Trading restrictions apply regardless of the account; changing accounts does not make the information public. - Wait for management to confirm the information privately: Private confirmation would still be nonpublic information; contact compliance rather than seeking further confirmation.
3. Northgate Asset Management manages separate accounts and two pooled funds. Its compliance manual incorporates the CFA Institute Code and Standards and requires employees to disclose personal accounts, obtain preclearance, and delay personal trades until all known client orders in the same security have been completed. Research director Arjun Patel negotiates with a broker that offers a specialized biotechnology database in exchange for client brokerage commissions. The database would be used exclusively by Northgate's Biotechnology Strategy. Patel proposes directing trades from Northgate's Small-Capitalization Fund, Fund S, to the broker because Fund S generates more commissions. Fund S is prohibited by mandate from investing in biotechnology companies, and the database would not assist its investment process. The broker's proposed commission rate is comparable with rates charged by other brokers providing similar execution quality. Portfolio manager Linh Nguyen identifies a publicly traded security suitable for several client accounts. On Monday morning, she submits the client orders. All orders are fully executed by noon at prices within the portfolio managers' limits. Nguyen has previously disclosed her personal brokerage account and receives preclearance from compliance after the trade desk confirms completion of all client orders. She buys the same security for her personal account shortly before the market closes. No additional client order in the security is pending or known to Nguyen. A public pension plan asks Northgate analyst Samuel Lewis to conduct a weekend training program unrelated to his assigned Northgate clients. The plan offers Lewis a fixed teaching fee plus a success fee linked to whether the plan later hires Northgate. The arrangement could influence how Lewis performs his regular duties and could affect Northgate's business. Lewis intends to accept the arrangement, disclose it to the pension plan's board, and inform Northgate after the training has concluded. Wealth adviser Dana Brooks has an agreement with an accounting firm under which the firm introduces prospective clients to her. For every prospect who signs an advisory agreement, Brooks gives the accounting firm research services with an estimated value of USD 1,500. The arrangement does not increase the fee charged to the client. Brooks tells prospects that the accounting firm introduced them but does not disclose the research-services payment or its estimated value.
4. An adviser receives USD 500 from an external manager for each client referral. Before making referrals, the adviser should most appropriately:
Answer: C. Disclose the fee to her employer and referred clients
> Key point: Disclose referral compensation to both the employer and the affected clients before making referrals. Why disclosure to her employer and referred clients is correct - The adviser receives a fee for each referral, creating a financial incentive that could affect her recommendations. - Disclosure to both the employer and referred clients allows each to assess that incentive before referrals are made. Why the other options are wrong - Disclose the fee only to her employer: the referred clients would not learn about the adviser’s financial incentive. - Disclose the fee only to referred clients: the employer would not be informed of the referral arrangement.
5. After taking a CFA examination, a candidate posts online. Which statement is most appropriate under the CFA Institute Standards?
Answer: C. State only that the examination was challenging
> Key point: Candidates may share a general impression of an exam, but not details about what it tested. Why State only that the examination was challenging is correct - This shares a personal impression without disclosing examination content. Why the other options are wrong - Describe the specific industry tested without identifying questions: Naming tested content discloses exam information even without question wording. - List the formulas tested but omit the wording of the questions: The formulas reveal specific exam content; omitting the questions does not make disclosure appropriate.
6. Jordan Lee earned the CFA charter last year. Which use of the credential in Lee's email signature is most appropriate?
Answer: A. Jordan Lee, CFA
> Key point: A charterholder may use the designation CFA after their name, without periods or a candidate-level label. Why Jordan Lee, CFA is correct - Lee earned the charter, so CFA may follow the name in the email signature. - The designation is written without periods and needs no program-level label. How they compare | Signature | Assessment | |---|---| | Jordan Lee, CFA | Correct designation and format | | Jordan Lee, C.F.A. | Adds periods not used in the designation | | Jordan Lee, CFA Charterholder, Level III | Adds a candidate-level reference that does not apply to Lee’s charterholder status | Why the other options are wrong - Jordan Lee, C.F.A.: The designation is CFA, not “C.F.A.” - Jordan Lee, CFA Charterholder, Level III: Level III is a program stage, not an additional designation for someone who has earned the charter.
1. In Ethical and Professional Standards, what are the steps in the ethical decision-making framework?
1\. Identify (facts, stakeholders, duties, conflicts). 2. Consider (situational influences, additional guidance, alternatives). 3. Decide and Act. 4. Reflect (evaluate the outcome).
2. In Ethical and Professional Standards (Ethics Application), what is the appropriate action if a member discovers their firm is overcharging clients for reimbursable expenses?
The member must disassociate from the activity and not work with any clients who are still being overcharged (Standard I-A).
Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.
Scan to download app
Enter your email to get your 75% OFF code and unlock the full CFA question bank on the app.