This module matters because the exam can turn price, forecast, peer, and capital-structure data into a valuation call. You will calculate a multiple, choose its denominator, bridge enterprise value, EV, to equity value, and decide whether the stock is overvalued, fairly valued, or undervalued. The discipline is matching an enterprise claim with enterprise earnings and keeping a reported denominator with a forecast numerator.
Loading diagram…
Comparables provide the market comparison, while forecasted fundamentals show whether growth, payout, risk, and profitability support it. Normalization, claim matching, regression, terminal multiples, cross-border checks, momentum, and central-tendency choices help you turn that comparison into a defensible conclusion.
The forward EPS path below shows the denominator effect in a forward $\mathrm{P/E}$ comparison. When EPS rises while price stays fixed, the same price is divided by a larger EPS, so forward $\mathrm{P/E}$ falls. Read the chart as a sequence of forecast inputs rather than as a price forecast: it holds price fixed and changes only EPS. The table records those same yearly values explicitly, making it easier to select the intended forward denominator when a question names a forecast period. A rising denominator lowers the ratio even when nothing happens to the share price.
Loading diagram…
The chart makes the direction of the denominator change visible, while the listed values let you calculate the ratio for any named forecast year. If price is unchanged, later EPS forecasts produce progressively smaller forward P/E values. When a vignette offers reported, trailing, and forward figures together, use the timing specified in the question rather than selecting whichever EPS is easiest to find.
| Forecast period | EPS (USD/share) |
|---|---|
| Forward year one | 3.00 |
| Forward year two | 3.30 |
| Forward year three | 3.63 |
| Forward year four | 3.99 |
Method of comparables vs method of forecasted fundamentals Rule: comparables infer value from similar companies’ market multiples; fundamentals derive a multiple from growth, payout, risk, and profitability. The exam asks which lens fits the evidence or why estimates differ. The trap is treating a peer multiple as objective when the peer’s underlying economics do not match the subject company.
Justified price multiples Rule: justified $\mathrm{P/E}=\frac{b}{k-g}$, with payout $b$, required return $k$, and decimal growth $g$. The exam supplies fundamentals and asks for a benchmark to compare with observed price multiples. The trap is inserting percentage-point growth as though it were decimal growth, or allowing $k-g$ to become nonpositive.
Rationales and drawbacks of alternative price multiples Rule: choose P/B, P/S, P/CF, or dividend yield when its denominator captures a useful business feature. The exam asks which ratio suits a firm and what it omits. The trap is choosing a denominator merely because it is positive: sales omit margins, book value can miss intangibles, and yield omits retained earnings and buybacks.
Enterprise value multiples: EV/EBITDA, EV/Sales Rule: divide enterprise value by an enterprise measure such as EBITDA or sales; EV/EBITDA reduces financing-structure effects. The exam may ask you to select or interpret an EV multiple. The trap is pairing EV with per-share data or assuming EBITDA captures capital spending, working capital, taxes, and asset intensity.
| Measure | Fits and drivers | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|
| $\mathrm{P/B}$ | Asset firms, ROE, growth, required return | Intangibles and accounting differences |
| $\mathrm{P/S}$ | Positive sales, margin, growth, required return | Margins disappear |
| $\mathrm{P/CF}$ | Accrual noise, cash conversion | Cash-flow definition varies |
| Dividend yield | Payout, growth, required return | Retention and buybacks omitted |
| CFO | Operating cash after working capital | Before capital spending |
| FCFE | Equity claim cash flow | Debt and reinvestment assumptions |
| FCFF | Enterprise claim cash flow | Financing consistency required |
| EBITDA | Operating comparison, financing structure | Ignores capex, working capital, taxes |
Alternative price multiples and dividend yield Rule: $\mathrm{P/B}=\frac{P_0}{B_0}$, $\mathrm{P/S}=\frac{P_0}{S_0}$, and dividend yield $=\frac{D_1}{P_0}$. The exam asks you to interpret price paid per unit of book value or sales, or dividends per price unit. The trap is confusing dividend yield with earnings yield or ignoring margins when using P/S.
Underlying earnings and normalized EPS Rule: normalized EPS equals reported EPS plus after-tax charges minus after-tax gains. The exam gives unusual items and asks for recurring earning power. The trap is adjusting pretax amounts or removing a cost that recurs; preserve the tax basis and distinguish a one-time distortion from ordinary operations.
Earnings yield (E/P) Rule: $\mathrm{E/P}=\frac{E}{P_0}=\frac{1}{\mathrm{P/E}}$. The exam may ask you to reverse a P/E or compare the earnings rate with a required return. The trap is calling E/P dividend yield: earnings include amounts retained in the business, while dividends measure distributions.
Fundamental drivers of price multiples and dividend yield Rule: growth and profitability can raise supported multiples, while risk or required return can lower them; payout affects yield. The exam asks you to explain a premium or discount from fundamentals. The trap is crediting growth alone when profitability, accounting, or capital intensity differs.
| Method | Reflects | Weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Arithmetic mean | Equal observation weights | Outlier sensitive |
| Harmonic mean | Reciprocal weighting | Less intuitive |
| Weighted harmonic mean | Explicit weights and reciprocals | Weights require justification |
| Median | Middle peer observation | Uses less distribution detail |
Predicted P/E from cross-sectional regression Rule: $\hat{\mathrm{P/E}}=\alpha+\beta_g\times G-\beta_r\times r$, where $G$ is percentage-point growth. The exam tests coefficient signs, units, and comparison with observed P/E. The trap is treating a peer-based estimate as intrinsic value; peer selection, omitted variables, and regression error remain.
Justified P/E, P/B and P/S from fundamentals Rule: justified $\mathrm{P/E}=\frac{b}{k-g}$, $\mathrm{P/B}=\frac{\mathrm{ROE}-g}{k-g}$, and $\mathrm{P/S}=\frac{m\times b}{k-g}$. The exam supplies forecast payout, return, growth, ROE, or margin and asks for a supported multiple. The trap is mixing reported and forecast inputs or mismatching growth units.
P/E-to-growth (PEG) ratio Rule: $\mathrm{PEG}=\frac{\mathrm{P/E}}{G}$, where $G$ is growth in percentage points. The exam asks you to compare P/E in light of growth, with risk and growth comparability in view. The trap is dividing by decimal growth or treating PEG as an intrinsic value estimate.
Price multiples in terminal value estimation Rule: $\mathrm{TV}_T=M_T\times X_T$. The exam asks you to convert a terminal metric into value and may require an equity or enterprise claim. The trap is applying an equity multiple such as P/E to an enterprise metric such as EBITDA; match both the claim and metric.
Relative valuation using comparisons of multiples Rule: compare observed multiples with justified or predicted benchmarks and peers on a like-for-like basis. The exam asks for an overvalued, fairly valued, or undervalued conclusion with assumptions. The trap is deciding from one raw peer ratio when growth, risk, or accounting differences explain the gap.
The claim bridge is where many otherwise correct calculations fail. The bars show aggregate EV moving through debt and cash to aggregate equity value. Read the bars from left to right: start at zero, establish enterprise value, subtract debt, add cash, and arrive at equity value. This order keeps operating value separate from the financing claims attached to the business. The amounts here are in USD millions, so do not confuse aggregate equity with the per-share result; shares still have to be applied afterward.
Loading diagram…
Follow each bridge adjustment in order and keep its sign: debt is subtracted from enterprise value, while cash is added back for equity holders. The table below carries those amounts through to equity value and then per-share value. This distinction matters because a correct EV calculation is only an intermediate result when the question asks what each share is worth.
| Bridge item | Amount | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Start | 0.00 | USD millions |
| Enterprise value | 960.00 | USD millions |
| Debt | -300.00 | USD millions |
| Cash | 60.00 | USD millions |
| Equity value | 720.00 | USD millions |
| Shares outstanding | 30 | Million shares |
| Equity value per share | 24.00 | USD/share |
The table makes the bridge auditable: debt reduces the enterprise claim and cash increases the residual for equity holders. After those adjustments, divide aggregate equity value by shares outstanding to get equity value per share. Keep the units visible at each step; millions of dollars divided by million shares produces dollars per share. This dimensional check catches answers that stop at enterprise value or aggregate equity instead of completing the requested valuation.
.
Method of comparables and the role of fundamentals Rule: use peers whose growth, risk, profitability, accounting, and timing are sufficiently comparable. The exam asks you to select a peer multiple or judge value from a peer set. The trap is copying the highest or average multiple without checking whether the peer’s premium has a different fundamental cause.
Cash flow definitions in price and EV multiples Rule: FCFE serves equity value, FCFF serves enterprise value, CFO is operating cash after working-capital effects, and EBITDA removes financing and tax effects. The exam asks which cash flow fits a multiple and its limitation. The trap is pairing EV with FCFE or assuming CFO includes capital spending.
Cross-border valuation comparison differences Rule: adjust comparisons for accounting, currency, inflation, tax, interest rates, market risk, liquidity, and industry mix. The exam asks why similar-looking ratios across countries may not be comparable. The trap is converting only currency; the underlying definitions, risk, and growth can still differ.
| Indicator | Signal |
|---|---|
| Price momentum | Sentiment and demand pressure |
| Relative performance | Peer positioning |
| Earnings revisions | Updated growth expectations |
| Earnings surprise | Estimate credibility |
Momentum indicators in valuation Rule: price momentum, relative performance, earnings revisions, and earnings surprises provide context for a multiple. The exam asks what signal an indicator offers or how it affects interpretation. The trap is treating recent price strength as forecast growth and letting sentiment replace fundamental analysis.
Arithmetic, harmonic and weighted harmonic mean multiples Rule: arithmetic averages observations equally, harmonic averages reciprocals, and weighted harmonic applies explicit weights; the median resists extremes. The exam asks which central tendency best represents a peer set. The trap is defaulting to the arithmetic mean when the distribution is skewed or denominators differ.
| Question shape | Given and asked | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| Price multiple | Share price, EPS. Calculate and interpret $\mathrm{P/E}$. | Reported versus forward EPS |
| Justified or regression | Fundamentals or coefficients. Calculate benchmark. | Decimal versus percentage points |
| EV bridge | EBITDA, multiple, debt, cash, shares. Value equity. | Enterprise/equity mismatch |
| Normalized earnings | Reported EPS, after-tax item. Normalize EPS. | Pretax adjustment |
| Comparables | Peer multiples, fundamentals. Judge value. | Raw peer multiple |
| Central tendency or momentum | Peer distribution or indicators. Explain signal. | Mean or momentum overreach |
Start by naming the claim the exam wants you to value. When the question gives you a share price and a per-share denominator, you are working with an equity multiple. When it gives you EBITDA, EV, debt, cash, and shares, you are building a bridge from enterprise value to equity value. Keep the company-wide amounts separate from the per-share amounts.
Words such as forward, reported, trailing, and normalized tell you which denominator timing the exam wants. A regression model supplies coefficients and fundamentals, while a PEG calculation applies a growth convention. When an after-tax item appears, the company’s reported earnings need normalization.
Treat a peer set as an invitation to make a comparables judgment, not as permission to accept its central multiple automatically. The exam may ask you to calculate first and then decide whether the security is overvalued, fairly valued, or undervalued. If the question gives you EV, identify the cash-flow claim before you calculate.
Practice
An analyst has a current share price of USD 48, forward EPS of USD 3, book value per share of USD 24, sales per share of USD 40, payout ratio of 0.4, required return of 0.1, growth of 0.04, regression inputs of 5, 0.2, 10, 1, and 0.5, and EBITDA of USD 120 million. Debt is USD 300 million, cash is USD 60 million, shares outstanding are 30 million. Reported EPS is USD 3.2 and the after-tax one-time charge is USD 0.4.
Question 1
Using the forward EPS, what is the forward P/E?
Question 2
Which justified P/E follows from the forecast fundamentals?
Question 3
An EV/EBITDA multiple of 8 is applied to EBITDA of USD 120 million. Debt is USD 300 million, cash is USD 60 million, and shares outstanding are 30 million. What equity value per share follows?
Question 4
Reported EPS is USD 3.2 and the after-tax one-time charge is USD 0.4. What normalized EPS follows?
Question 5
Using the stated regression, which result and interpretation is correct?
For a quick calculator check, key the share price and forecast EPS before dividing.
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 2ND CLR WORK | 0.00 |
| 48 | 48.00 |
| / | 48.00 |
| 3 | 3.00 |
| = | 16.00 |
The calculator sequence divides the share price by forecast EPS, giving the forward P/E. Notice that the setup preserves the price and EPS as separate entries before division; entering the reciprocal would instead produce earnings yield. On exam questions, first identify whether the requested output is a price multiple or its inverse, then enter the matching numerator and denominator. That simple check prevents a correct calculation from answering the wrong question.
| Area | Formula or rule | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Equity value | $\text{equity value}=P_0\times S$ | Per-share price times shares outstanding |
| Enterprise value | $\mathrm{EV}=\text{equity value}+\text{debt}+\text{preferred stock}+\text{noncontrolling interest}-\text{cash}$ | Bridge to total capital claims |
| Forward $\mathrm{P/E}$ | $\mathrm{P/E}=\frac{P_0}{E_1}$ | $E_1$ is forecast EPS |
| Alternative price ratios | $\mathrm{P/B}=\frac{P_0}{B_0}$, $\mathrm{P/S}=\frac{P_0}{S_0}$ | Match per-share denominators |
| Dividend yield | $\frac{D_1}{P_0}$ | Next-period dividend divided by price |
| Justified $\mathrm{P/E}$ | $\frac{b}{k-g}$ | Payout, required return, growth |
| Justified $\mathrm{P/B}$ | $\frac{\mathrm{ROE}-g}{k-g}$ | Link to ROE |
| Justified $\mathrm{P/S}$ | $\frac{m\times b}{k-g}$ | Link to net profit margin |
| Normalize EPS | Reported EPS plus after-tax charges minus gains | Remove nonrecurring distortions |
| Earnings yield | $\mathrm{E/P}=\frac{1}{\mathrm{P/E}}$ | Compare earnings rate with required return |
| Predicted $\mathrm{P/E}$ | $\hat{\mathrm{P/E}}=\alpha+\beta_g\times G-\beta_r\times r$ | Growth uses percentage points |
| PEG | $\mathrm{PEG}=\frac{\mathrm{P/E}}{G}$ | $G$ is percentage-point growth |
| Terminal value | $\mathrm{TV}_T=M_T\times X_T$ | Match claim and metric |
| Cash-flow fit | Price with FCFE, EV with FCFF or EBITDA | Match numerator to claim |
| $\mathrm{EV}/\mathrm{EBITDA}$ | Financing-structure effects reduced | Ignores capex, working capital, taxes, asset intensity |
| Comparable multiples | Match growth, risk, profitability, accounting, cross-border | Peer multiples are not automatically fair |
| Timing | Separate forward, trailing, reported, normalized | Align numerator and denominator |
| Central tendency | Arithmetic, harmonic, weighted harmonic, median | Choose for outliers and weights |
Read each multiple by claim, timing, and denominator. Then test the fundamentals behind the comparison. A multiple is a signal, not certainty.
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more
1. A portfolio manager buys sponsored depositary receipts representing a foreign issuer's common shares. The manager's position is best described as:
Answer: A. Hold economic interests while voting through the depositary
Hold economic interests while voting through the depositary - Sponsored depositary receipts give the manager economic exposure to the foreign issuer’s common shares deposited with a custodian. - The depositary holds the underlying shares and typically handles voting according to receipt holders’ instructions. Hold issuer shares directly in the domestic market - The manager buys depositary receipts, not the issuer’s common shares directly. - The underlying shares are held through the depositary arrangement rather than as the manager’s direct position in the issuer’s domestic market. Hold creditor claims secured by the deposited shares - Depositary receipts represent an equity interest in the underlying shares, not a debt claim against the issuer. - The deposited shares back the receipts but do not serve as collateral for a secured creditor claim.
2. A US investor buys a USD-denominated negotiable certificate issued by a depositary bank that represents shares of a foreign company. The instrument is most likely:
Answer: A. A depositary receipt
A depositary receipt - A depositary receipt is a negotiable certificate issued by a depositary bank that represents shares of a foreign company. - Its USD denomination and purchase by a US investor are consistent with this structure. A convertible preference share - A convertible preference share can be converted into common shares under specified terms. - It is not a depositary-bank certificate representing shares of a foreign company. A participating preference share - A participating preference share entitles its holder to share in additional distributions under specified terms. - Participation in distributions does not make it a depositary-bank certificate representing foreign shares.
3. A stock's next dividend is USD 2.10, its required return is 9%, and dividends will grow perpetually at 4%. The calculated value of the stock is closest to:
Answer: C. USD 42.00
USD 42.00 - The Gordon growth model uses the next dividend: \(V0=D1/(r-g)\). - Substituting the given figures gives USD 2.10/(0.09 − 0.04) = USD 42.00. USD 38.18 - Using 9.5% instead of the stated 9% makes the denominator 0.055 and gives USD 2.10/0.055 = USD 38.18 when rounded. - The required return in the question is 9%, so that larger denominator understates the value. USD 40.00 - Prematurely rounding the next dividend from USD 2.10 to USD 2.00 gives USD 2.00/0.05 = USD 40.00. - The stated USD 2.10 is already the next dividend and must be used without rounding or adjusting it for growth.
4. A broker holds shares in street name for a client. Before voting on a contested director election, the broker must most likely obtain:
Answer: B. Authorization from the beneficial owner
Authorization from the beneficial owner - Shares held in street name are registered in the broker’s name, but the client is the beneficial owner. - A contested director election is not a matter on which the broker may vote without the beneficial owner’s authorization. Approval from a majority of outstanding shares - A majority-of-shares requirement would concern an election’s outcome, not the broker’s authority to vote the client’s shares. - The broker needs instructions from the beneficial owner, not approval from other shareholders. Direction from the company's board - The company’s board cannot authorize the broker to exercise voting rights belonging to the client. - For this contested election, voting authority must come from the beneficial owner.
5. An investor wants to preserve a 2% ownership interest after a fully subscribed rights offering. Assuming sufficient funds, the investor should most likely:
Answer: A. Exercise all subscription rights
Exercise all subscription rights - Exercising all subscription rights lets the investor buy a proportionate share of the new shares. - Because the offering is fully subscribed, buying that proportionate share preserves the investor’s 2% ownership interest. Sell the rights and buy bonds - Selling the rights may recover their value, but it does not give the investor any new shares. - Buying bonds does not offset the ownership dilution caused by the increase in shares outstanding. Allow the rights to expire - Letting the rights expire means the investor acquires none of the new shares. - The investor’s share count stays the same while total shares outstanding increase, so the ownership interest falls below 2%.
6. An issuer omits a non-cumulative preferred dividend after reporting a loss. The preferred shareholders are most likely entitled to:
Answer: B. Receive dividends before common shareholders
Receive dividends before common shareholders - Preferred shareholders have dividend priority over common shareholders when the issuer declares a dividend. - The reported loss does not eliminate that priority, although the issuer may omit a non-cumulative preferred dividend. Receive a contractually guaranteed dividend - A preferred dividend is not contractually guaranteed like bond interest, so the issuer may omit it after reporting a loss. - Because the shares are non-cumulative, the omitted dividend does not become payable in a later period. Exercise voting rights equal to common shareholders - Preferred shareholders generally have limited or contingent voting rights, not voting rights equal to common shareholders. - Their relevant entitlement here is priority in declared dividends, not equal participation in shareholder votes.
7. An issuer omits a scheduled dividend on non-convertible cumulative preference shares. The consequence is most likely that:
Answer: C. The omitted dividend accumulates before common distributions
The omitted dividend accumulates before common distributions - Cumulative preference shares retain unpaid scheduled dividends as arrears. - The issuer generally must pay those arrears before distributing dividends to common shareholders. The omitted dividend becomes corporate debt - An omitted preference dividend does not ordinarily become corporate debt merely because it accumulates. - Unlike missed bond interest, the omission generally does not give preference shareholders a creditor claim. Common dividends may continue without restriction - Unpaid cumulative preference dividends place a restriction on distributions to common shareholders. - Common dividends generally cannot be paid until the preference dividend arrears are satisfied.
1. Comparables calculated as benchmark price multiple & estimate of the fundamental value. Terminal value in year n =
- terminal value in year n = (benchmark leading P/E ratio)(forecasted earnings in year n+1) - terminal value in year n = (benchmark trailing P/E ratio)(forecasted earnings in year n)
2. Method of comparables in mkt based valuation
- values a stock based on the avg. price multiple of the stock of similar companies - based on Law of One Price
3. How is the market conversion ratio affected by stock split?
doubles
4. What are the advantages of price multiples (NAVPS, FFO & AFFO)?
- P/FFO and P/AFFO are globally accepted - multiples allow comparisons with other investment alternatives - FFO estimates are widely available from reputed data providers - multiples are evaluated in conjuction with other factors such as growth rates to allow for reconciliation of differences in multiples between different REITs - leverage needs to be adjusted for since it isn't explicity accounted for in FFO & AFFO
5. GAV =
\= operating RE + cash + land for dev. + AR + prepaid/other assets
6. Three methods for market approach
- Guideline public company: use public EV mutliples with adjustments - Guideline transactions: prior acquisition value for entire companies - Prior transactions
7. Rationale and shortcomings of using a P/B ratio
Rationale - BV almost always > 0 - BV more stable than EPS - appropriate measure of NAV for firms that primarily hold liquid assets - P/B helps explain differences in long-run average stock returns Shortcomings - size differences cause misleading comparisons - influenced by accouting choices - BV does not equal Market value due to inflation/technology
8. What is the Fed model?
considers the overall market to be overvalued (undervalued) when the earnings yield (E/P ratio) on the S&P500 index is lower (higher) than the yield on the 10-yr T-bonds
9. Rationale and shortcomings of P/S ratios for multiple valuation
Rationale - meaningful even for distressed firms - sales revenue not easily maniputated - not as volatile as P/E ratios - useful for mature, cyclical and start up firms Shortcomings - high sales does not necessarily indicate high operating profits - does not capture cost structure differences - revenue recognition practices can distort sales forecasts
Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.
Scan to download app
Enter your email to get your 75% OFF code and unlock the full CFA question bank on the app.