Criteria for choosing a valuation approach

Criteria for choosing a valuation approach

Published September 28, 2026

Criteria for choosing a valuation approach

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Explain broad criteria for choosing an appropriate approach for valuing a given company.

On the exam: The case gives you company evidence, a forecast, financing facts, and possible peer or asset anchors. Your job is to choose and justify an approach. You may then need to interpret base, bull, and bear valuation evidence in an item set or standalone question.

First ask how the business creates value and how much confidence you can place in the evidence. A mature utility with predictable FCFF can support a cash-flow model. An asset-rich distressed company may call for asset or liquidation evidence.

Company evidenceApproach favored
Mature, predictable FCFFFCFF DCF
Growth or transitionMulti-stage or relative
Unstable or negative cash flowRelative or scenario
Asset-rich or distressedAsset or liquidation
Stable financing and debt dataFCFF DCF
Credible peers and market anchorsRelative valuation
Weak forecasts and peersBase, bull, and bear scenarios

Next ask whether the evidence supports intrinsic value or a market comparison. Absolute valuation builds intrinsic value from operating drivers, while relative valuation uses credible comparable companies and market anchors. Give asset or liquidation evidence more weight when the balance sheet says more about value than going-concern cash flows.

Read the evidence-fit column as a credibility test, not a checklist to satisfy mechanically. A forecast may look detailed yet remain weak if financing assumptions are unstable; a peer set may be large yet misleading if its companies support different claim levels. Choose the approach whose value anchor is supported by the strongest case evidence, then explain why alternatives deserve less weight.

ApproachValue anchorEvidence fit
Absolute valuationOperating drivers and forecast cash flowsForecast and financing facts are credible
Relative valuationComparable-company market anchorsPeers are credible and claim levels match
Asset or liquidationBalance-sheet or sale evidenceAssets outweigh weak going-concern cash flows

If the company generates cash for both lenders and shareholders, FCFF is the relevant cash-flow source. The cash flow in annual period $t$ is $FCFF_t$. The discount rate, $w$, is WACC. The stable-growth rate, $g$, applies after the last explicit period, $n$.

The first term discounts each forecast FCFF back to today. The second term values the cash flows after period $n$ and discounts that continuing value back to today. Use this DCF and bridge only when the forecast and financing evidence can support them.

$$ \begin{aligned} EV&=\sum_{t=1}^{n}\frac{FCFF_t}{(1+w)^t}+\frac{FCFF_n(1+g)}{(w-g)(1+w)^n}\ E&=EV-D+C,\qquad V_0=\frac{E}{S} \end{aligned} $$

More forecast FCFF raises $EV$. A higher $w$ lowers present value, while a higher $g$ raises continuing value and narrows $w-g$, which is why the continuing-value term needs $w>g$. Debt lowers $E$, cash raises it, and more shares lower $V_0$ for a fixed aggregate equity value.

For relative valuation, label the denominator before you compare multiples. The label tells you which operating period or earnings concept supports the comparison.

Input labelEvidence basis
TrailingLatest completed period
ForwardForecast period
ReportedPublished result
NormalizedRecurring result

Choose trailing data when the latest period represents normal operations. Choose forward data when the forecast is more credible. Reported figures preserve published results, while normalized figures remove unusual effects only when the adjustments are defensible.

These labels answer what the denominator measures and when it was measured. Keep the timing and earnings basis consistent across companies; otherwise an apparent valuation gap may come from mixing a forecast with a completed period or recurring earnings with an unadjusted reported result. Make each adjustment only when the case gives you evidence to defend it.

NumeratorMatching denominatorOutput
Enterprise valueFirm-level operating measureEnterprise-value multiple
Equity valueEquity-level measureEquity-value multiple
Aggregate equity valueShares outstandingPer-share value

Before using a multiple, check that its numerator and denominator refer to the same claim level. Enterprise value covers lenders and shareholders, so pair it with a firm-level operating measure. Equity value belongs to shareholders, so pair it with an equity-level measure. To move from aggregate equity value to a per-share figure, divide by shares outstanding. A matching label keeps the comparison interpretable.

Use this map as a first screen. Let the case evidence decide whether the initial approach still fits. A company can sit between categories: forecastable cash flow favors a DCF, while a substantial asset base may strengthen an asset check. Treat the plotted labels as starting points, then weigh forecast reliability, financing stability, and market evidence together before settling on a primary approach.

Loading diagram…

Worked example

You are handed a mature utility with predictable FCFF and stable financing. Peer companies provide a credible enterprise-value anchor, so you choose an FCFF DCF as the primary approach and an enterprise-value multiple as a cross-check. You need the base-case operating value, equity value, and value per share.

The inputs are WACC $w=0.1$ decimal per year, terminal growth $g=0.03$, debt $D=$ USD 20 million, cash $C=$ USD 5 million, and $S=$ 10 million shares. The current price is USD 7 per share. Valuation is at time zero, with annual period ends.

PeriodFCFFInvestor perspective
1USD 12 millionCash received at period end
2USD 15 millionCash received at period end
3USD 18 millionCash received at period end

The rising forecast supports using a DCF as the primary model. Read each amount as cash received at that period end, so discount period 1 once, period 2 twice, and period 3 three times. The sequence gives the explicit forecast used in the worked calculation; the terminal value begins after period 3. This timing is why the final forecast is grown before the continuing-value formula is applied.

Loading diagram…
  1. Grow the last forecast FCFF because continuing value starts after the explicit forecast. The terminal FCFF is $18(1+0.03)=18.54$ USD million.

  2. Apply the stable-growth formula because it converts the terminal FCFF into value at the end of the explicit forecast. The terminal value is $\frac{18.54}{0.1-0.03}=264.86$ USD million.

  3. Discount every cash flow to time zero. The three explicit present values are $\frac{12}{1.1000}=10.91$, $\frac{15}{1.2100}=12.40$, and $\frac{18}{1.3310}=13.52$ USD million. The explicit present value is $36.83$, the terminal present value is $198.99$, and operating value is $EV=235.82$ USD million.

  4. Bridge from the firm claim to the equity claim because FCFF belongs to lenders and shareholders. Debt reduces value and cash increases it, giving $E=235.82-20+5=220.82$ USD million. Dividing by shares gives $V_0=\frac{220.82}{10}=22.08$ USD per share.

The bars are, from left to right, explicit FCFF value, terminal value, debt adjustment, cash, and aggregate equity value.

Loading diagram…

The base estimate is USD 22.08 per share versus USD 7 per share. The model supports a positive valuation signal, but terminal value dominates, so you should seek the peer multiple cross-check and report a range rather than treat USD 22.08 as certainty.

Changed condition

Now terminal growth falls while every other input stays unchanged. Before calculating, predict a lower terminal value, operating value, and per-share value.

MeasureBase caseBear case
Terminal growth0.030.02
Operating value, $EV$USD 235.82 millionUSD 209.26 million
Value per share, $V_0$USD 22.08USD 19.43

The lower bear-case growth rate should have predicted a lower result before you calculated it. It reduces terminal FCFF from USD 18.54 million to USD 18.36 million and terminal value from USD 264.86 million to USD 229.50 million, while explicit present value stays USD 36.83 million. Before reading on, write one sentence explaining why a lower $g$ lowers value.

Common error

You calculate enterprise value and compare it with a price-to-earnings multiple because both numbers look like company values. That feels right when the peer table is full of market statistics. The mismatch appears because the numerator is a firm claim and the denominator is an equity claim, so rebuild the comparison at one claim level.

Calculator

Use percentage mode for WACC, and keep the three FCFF inputs in period order.

KeysDisplay
12 CFj12.00
15 CFj15.00
18 CFj18.00
10 I/Y10.00
CPT NPV36.83

Check yourself

Practice

A mature utility has predictable FCFF, stable financing, a base case, and a lower-growth bear case.

Question 1

Which value is the base-case value per share?

Question 2

Which approach is best supported as primary?

Question 3

Which base-to-bear change is consistent with the case?

Question 4

Which comparison keeps claim levels aligned?

Choose the better primary approach for each case.

FCFF DCFRelative or scenarioAsset or liquidation
Mature predictable utility
Unstable negative cash flow
Asset-rich distressed company

Revision snapshot

The bridge is:

$$ E=EV-D+C,\qquad V_0=\frac{E}{S} $$

Match the valuation approach to the company's life cycle, cash-flow source, asset base, financing, and evidence quality. Use absolute valuation when intrinsic operating drivers are forecastable. Use relative valuation when comparable companies and market anchors are credible. A mature company with predictable FCFF and stable financing can support an FCFF DCF, cross-checked with enterprise-value multiples. Unstable or negative cash flow makes a cash-flow model fragile, so consider a credible relative or scenario approach and label uncertainty. Asset-rich or distressed companies may need more weight on asset or liquidation evidence than on going-concern cash flows. Keep enterprise value, equity value, aggregate value, and per-share value at the same claim level. State base, bull, and bear assumptions. A point estimate is not certainty. The trap is an enterprise-value numerator with an equity-value multiple. On the exam, justify the model from company evidence and interpret the scenarios.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Criteria for choosing a valuation approach

  1. 1. Elena Park is valuing Meridian Systems, a publicly traded provider of industrial automation equipment. Meridian reports under US GAAP and has recently completed several acquisitions. Management expects revenue growth to moderate as the industry matures, but it anticipates maintaining its operating margin through greater use of standardized components. Park prepares the operating forecast in Exhibit 1. She assumes depreciation is tax deductible, all operating income is taxable at the stated effective tax rate, and there are no other noncash operating charges. Meridian currently uses both debt and equity financing. Management expects the debt-to-capital ratio to change materially during the next three years as acquisition debt is repaid. The company's dividend is set by the board using a stable nominal amount and is not expected to reflect its capacity to distribute cash. Park also identifies material share-based compensation and recurring transactions recorded directly in shareholders' equity rather than comprehensive income. She therefore considers whether a dividend discount, residual income, or free cash flow model should serve as her primary valuation method. For a separate equity valuation using FCFE, Park develops the assumptions in Exhibit 2. The Year 1 FCFE is expected one year from the valuation date. The forecast assumes that FCFE grows by 12% in both Year 2 and Year 3. Beginning in Year 4, Meridian is expected to enter a stable-growth phase. All cash flows occur at year-end, the cost of equity remains constant, and no separate non-operating assets or liabilities need to be added or deducted. A colleague recommends using a 6.5% perpetual growth rate because Meridian recently achieved revenue growth above 10%. Park notes that the industry is becoming more competitive, Meridian's return on invested capital is expected to converge toward its cost of capital, and long-run nominal economic growth is forecast at 4.5%. She evaluates whether the colleague's terminal assumption is consistent with a mature company's sustainable long-run growth.

    • 2. Northstar Holdings is a publicly traded industrial group followed by Elise Martin, an equity analyst. Martin values the consolidated company using a constant-growth FCFF model because management has completed a major restructuring, capital expenditure is expected to track depreciation, and operating margins and reinvestment rates have stabilized. All forecasts are nominal, after-tax estimates stated as of the valuation date. Exhibit 1 presents the inputs Martin considers sustainable. Martin notes that Northstar's interest-bearing debt is required for operations, whereas the cash balance in Exhibit 1 exceeds the amount needed for normal working-capital purposes. She therefore plans to convert the enterprise value obtained from the FCFF model into common equity value before calculating value per share. As a cross-check, Martin applies a residual income framework. She assumes that the forecast return on equity, required return, and long-run growth rate in Exhibit 1 remain constant. Northstar's reported book value of common equity is positive, and its accounting policies are broadly comparable with those of its peers. Martin separately reviews Solara, a rapidly growing Northstar subsidiary. Solara pays no dividends and is not expected to initiate dividends during the explicit forecast horizon. Its leverage is expected to remain stable, and Martin can forecast positive free cash flow to equity with reasonable reliability. Solara has completed several acquisitions, however, and the resulting purchase accounting and recurring impairment charges make reported book value and residual income difficult to interpret. Finally, Martin values Northstar's services division using the median forward EV/EBITDA multiple of comparable listed companies. The comparable companies and the division use similar accounting policies for depreciation and have similar expected growth and operating risk. Exhibit 2 provides the multiple and division-specific data. The division debt is interest-bearing, and its reported cash balance is not required for operations. No control premium or marketability adjustment is appropriate because the valuation is for a publicly traded minority interest.

      • 3. Sofia Marchetti, an equity analyst, is valuing Northstar Consumer Products, a publicly traded manufacturer of household products. Northstar reports under US GAAP and has historically generated positive operating cash flow, maintained moderate leverage, and paid regular dividends. Marchetti's objective is to estimate intrinsic common equity value using methods consistent with the company's operating and financing characteristics. Before building her valuation models, Marchetti conducts a brief ratio-analysis review of Northstar's profitability, examining net profit margin and its relationship to the forecast ROE, to confirm that the DuPont components are internally consistent with the operating assumptions in Exhibit 1. Marchetti prepares the forecasts in Exhibit 1. The revenue forecast incorporates expected unit growth and announced price increases. The EBIT margin reflects normalized input costs and excludes a non-recurring restructuring charge recognized in the prior year. The cash tax rate is expected to equal the statutory rate because Northstar has no material tax-loss carryforwards or unusual permanent differences. Capital expenditures include both maintenance spending and planned capacity expansion. The forecast increase in net working capital reflects expected growth in receivables and inventory, net of spontaneous supplier financing. Northstar's target debt-to-capital ratio has remained stable. The company expects to issue enough debt in 2025 to support that target while funding its investment program. Marchetti notes that borrowing is a financing cash flow and should affect cash flow available to equity holders but not cash flow available to all capital providers. She also observes that Northstar has no preferred shares, material pension deficit, or unconsolidated subsidiary requiring a separate valuation adjustment. Marchetti is considering dividend discount, free cash flow, and residual income approaches. She expects the company's accounting policies to remain stable and considers reported book value reliable. Nevertheless, Northstar's established dividend policy and its explicit transition from near-term above-trend growth to stable growth may provide a more direct basis for one of the models. Marchetti will use the required return on equity for dividends, FCFE, and residual income. If she values FCFF, she will instead discount the cash flows at WACC and then subtract debt and add excess cash to obtain common equity value. All amounts in Exhibit 1 are forecasts for the year ending 31 December 2025. Cash flows occur at year-end, beginning equity is measured at 31 December 2024, and no adjustment for midyear discounting is appropriate.

        • 4. Nordlake Systems develops logistics software for commercial customers. An equity analyst is preparing a valuation as of 31 December 2024. The company has recently completed a major product-development cycle, and management expects operating performance to stabilize after 2025. Management's forecasts are considered sufficiently reliable for estimating operating cash flows, and the analyst assumes that the long-term growth rate will begin after the 2025 forecast year. Nordlake reports under US GAAP. The analyst treats depreciation and amortization as non-cash operating charges, capital expenditures as reinvestment, and increases in working capital as uses of cash. The analyst also assumes that the cash balance shown in Exhibit 1 is non-operating and that all reported debt is interest-bearing. Enterprise value is therefore converted to equity value by adding non-operating cash and subtracting debt. All forecast cash flows occur at year-end. Nordlake has paid dividends for several years, but its board adjusts the payout ratio in response to acquisition opportunities and financing needs. Management currently anticipates rapid dividend growth for two years, followed by a stable long-term rate. The analyst considers a two-stage dividend discount model as a secondary valuation approach and will value the stock immediately after the dividend identified as D0 has been paid. For a relative valuation cross-check, the analyst identifies publicly traded software companies with similar business models. The peer companies differ materially in leverage, depreciation policies, and operating margins. One associate proposes using P/E because it is familiar to clients. A second proposes EV/EBITDA to reduce the effect of financing differences. A third proposes P/S, claiming that sales multiples automatically adjust for differences in operating profitability. The analyst must maintain consistency between the definition of cash flow, the discount rate, and the resulting measure of value. The FCFF approach uses WACC and initially produces enterprise value. The dividend approach values equity directly using the required return on equity.

          • 5. Elias Morgan, an equity analyst, is valuing Galena Systems, a listed producer of industrial automation equipment. Demand is supported by multiyear factory-modernization programs, but the company operates in a cyclical industry and its margins have varied with production volume. Morgan decides to prepare an explicit three-year forecast followed by a continuing-value estimate. All forecast cash flows occur at year-end, and all amounts are stated in USD. Galena currently generates revenue of USD 600 million. Morgan expects year 1 revenue to grow by 8% as an existing plant uses more of its available capacity. He forecasts the operating assumptions shown in Exhibit 1. Net working capital is defined as non-cash operating current assets minus non-interest-bearing operating current liabilities. Galena's year-end net working capital is currently 10% of current-year revenue, so changes in that balance represent operating cash-flow investments or releases. Galena does not pay dividends. It has occasionally repurchased shares, but the amounts have depended on acquisition opportunities rather than a stated payout target. Management plans to issue debt to finance an acquisition during forecast year 2 and then reduce leverage over the following four years. Morgan believes the timing and amount of future net borrowing cannot be forecast with sufficient reliability. He nevertheless expects Galena's long-term operating asset mix and business risk to remain broadly stable. Morgan uses FCFF and WACC for his principal valuation. He forecasts year 3 FCFF of USD 64 million and year 4 FCFF of USD 70 million. From year 4 onward, he expects FCFF to grow at a constant 3% annually. He estimates a 9% WACC and confirms that the perpetual growth rate is below both the discount rate and his estimate of long-run nominal economic growth. The relevant continuing-value assumptions and balance-sheet adjustments are presented in Exhibit 2. After discounting the explicit-period FCFF and terminal value, Morgan obtains an enterprise value of USD 800 million. He notes that Galena holds excess cash and short-term investments that are not required in operations. The company also has interest-bearing debt and a consolidated subsidiary in which outside investors own a minority interest. Morgan intends to calculate the value attributable solely to Galena's common shareholders by making the necessary non-operating and financing adjustments to enterprise value.

            • 6. Priya Shah, an equity analyst, is valuing Ardent Systems, a manufacturer of industrial automation equipment. Demand from existing customers is stable, and recently introduced products are expected to increase revenue during 2025. Shah believes the company can raise its EBIT margin through higher plant utilization, but she does not forecast any material change in its cash tax rate. She prepares the operating forecast shown in Exhibit 1. Ardent's depreciation and amortization expense is treated as a non-cash operating charge. Capital expenditures include both maintenance and growth investment. Shah forecasts net working capital as a constant percentage of annual revenue and defines the annual working-capital investment as the change from the preceding year. All cash flows occur at year-end, and no acquisition-related or restructuring cash flows are expected during the forecast period. Ardent currently pays a regular dividend, but management has historically retained substantial cash even when profitable investment opportunities were limited. The dividend payout ratio has varied widely and does not reflect the company's capacity to distribute cash. Management has also announced a three-year financing plan under which the proportion of debt in the capital structure is expected to change materially as existing borrowings mature and new production assets are financed. Shah therefore considers several possible equity valuation models. Her explicit forecast period ends on 31 December 2026. For the continuing-value calculation at that date, Shah has separately estimated the FCFF expected during 2027, the first year after the explicit forecast period. She believes the company's long-term growth rate will be below the nominal growth rate of the overall economy and assumes that WACC will remain constant after 2026. The relevant continuing-value assumptions are included in Exhibit 2. Shah's independently prepared discounted cash flow model produces the enterprise value reported in Exhibit 2. Ardent's debt is interest-bearing and ranks ahead of common equity. Cash and marketable securities are non-operating assets that are not reflected in the forecast FCFF. Ardent has no preferred shares, non-controlling interests, unfunded pension deficits, or outstanding employee options. The share count in Exhibit 2 is fully diluted. Shah must convert the enterprise value into a common-equity value and then determine the implied value per share.

              • 7. Elena Ruiz, an equity analyst, is preparing an initiation report on Northstar Consumer Products, a mature producer of household products. Northstar pays regular dividends, and management has maintained a stated payout policy for several years. Ruiz expects above-normal dividend growth for two years as recently introduced products gain distribution. Beginning in Year 3, she expects Northstar's growth to converge to a sustainable long-term rate below the required return on equity. Ruiz uses the capital asset pricing model to estimate the cost of equity and assumes all dividends are paid at year-end. She intends to value the shares as of today using a two-stage dividend discount model. No additional interim dividend is expected, and the current dividend shown in Exhibit 1 has already been paid. Northstar has no non-voting equity classes or preferred shares that would require separate per-share adjustments. For the revenue forecast, Ruiz follows a top-down process. She first projects total industry revenue and then applies Northstar's expected market share. Management expects the company's new distribution agreements to increase market share, while industry demand continues to expand. Ruiz will forecast operating profit separately by applying the expected operating margin to forecast revenue; therefore, operating margin is not needed to determine revenue itself. As a reasonableness check, Ruiz calculates a justified forward P/E using the stable-growth assumptions expected to apply after the initial high-growth period. She uses the prospective payout ratio, the CAPM-derived cost of equity, and the perpetual growth rate. She does not use the current dividend yield or the historical average P/E in this calculation. Ruiz's supervisor also reviews the draft report for completeness. The firm requires reports to communicate the recommendation, target price and time horizon, valuation method and material assumptions, key risks to the investment thesis, and relevant conflicts. A report may use one valuation method when that method is appropriate and its limitations are understood. Exhibit 3 summarizes the contents of Ruiz's current draft.

                • 8. An equity analyst is valuing Marlow Industries, a mature manufacturer reporting under US GAAP. Marlow has historically paid stable dividends, but management has announced that dividends will be suspended after the coming year to fund a multiyear expansion. Management expects free cash flow to equity to remain positive during the expansion and has provided sufficiently detailed operating and financing forecasts for the analyst to estimate that cash flow directly. The analyst first prepares the Year 1 operating forecast in Exhibit 1. Revenue is expected to be USD 500 million, and the forecast EBIT margin is based on normalized operations. Depreciation, capital expenditures, and working capital investment occur throughout the year but are treated as year-end cash flows for valuation purposes. Interest expense is deductible for tax purposes, and the stated tax rate applies to both operating income and pretax income. Net borrowing represents debt issued minus principal repayments during Year 1. The company has no preferred shares or noncontrolling interests. The analyst also prepares a per-share valuation using the assumptions in Exhibit 2. The current dividend has just been paid. Dividends are expected to grow at 8% annually for the next three years, after which growth is expected to decline immediately to a sustainable 4%. The terminal value is therefore measured at the end of Year 3. All dividends are assumed to be paid at year-end, and the required return remains constant. As an alternative, the analyst considers a residual income model. Marlow applies clean-surplus accounting, has no expected share issuances or repurchases, and is not expected to record transactions directly in equity other than dividends. Year 1 ending book value per share can therefore be forecast from beginning book value, earnings, and dividends. Beginning in Year 2, residual income is expected to grow at 3% indefinitely. The continuing value of residual income is measured at the end of Year 1. A colleague recommends retaining the dividend discount model as the primary valuation method even after dividends are suspended, arguing that Marlow has a long dividend history. The analyst instead notes that the company's expected FCFE is positive, management's capital spending and financing plans are available, and the future dividend policy will not reflect the company's capacity to distribute cash. The analyst will use relative valuation only as a secondary reasonableness check because peer operating margins vary materially.

                  Flashcards: Criteria for choosing a valuation approach

                  1. 1. What are the two methods to estimate the terminal value in stock valuation?

                    Show answer

                    - constant (Gordon) growth model - price multiple method

                  2. 2. Country risk premium: CRP =

                    Show answer

                    \= sovereign yield spread \ (σequity / σbond)

                  3. 3. When using standardized unexpected earnings, when is a given forecast error more meaningful?

                    Show answer

                    the lower the size of historical forecast errors

                  4. 4. What is equation for standardized unexpected earnings?

                    Show answer

                    \= earnings surprise / stdev(earnings surprise)

                  5. 5. What is the economic rationale for examining earning surprises?

                    Show answer

                    positive surprises may lead to persistent positive abnormal returns

                  6. 6. What is analyst sentiment backtesting based on?

                    Show answer

                    - EPS changes over the past 3 months - stocks with positive earnings revisions are preferred

                  7. 7. What does the value of an asset depend on?

                    Show answer

                    - expected future cash flows - the discount rate used to value its cash flows

                  8. 8. What is a hard catalyst event-drive approach?

                    Show answer

                    investment made after an event has been announced

                  Everything you need for CFA prep

                  Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

                  GET STARTED FOR FREE
                  75% OFFLimited time offer
                  GET 75% OFF