Swap price vs swap value

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Contrast the value and price of swaps.

On the exam: You receive the fixed and floating legs, payment and discount conventions, and a party perspective. You choose the negotiated fixed rate, a later present value, or the correct sign in an MCQ, fill-in-the-blank, or matrix.

A swap joins a fixed payment stream to a floating payment stream. At inception, the fixed rate is negotiated so the present values of the two legs match. Later, market rates change the value of those promised cash flows. Keep the rate agreed at the start separate from the dollar value measured later.

FeatureSwap priceSwap value
Quoted itemNegotiated fixed rateDollar present value
TimingInceptionLater valuation date
Zero conditionSets initial value to zeroCan be positive or negative
PerspectiveSame rate for both partiesSign depends on party

The word price is misleading here. It is a rate, not the amount you would receive on closing the swap. Value is the amount the remaining cash flows are worth today from one party's perspective.

The fixed rate agreed for a new swap is $K_{\mathrm{swap}}$. The current dollar value for a party that receives floating and pays fixed is $V_{\mathrm{RF/PF}}$. The fixed-rate annuity is the present value of fixed payments generated by a unit of fixed rate across the notional and payment dates.

$$ \begin{aligned} K_{\mathrm{swap}} &= \frac{\mathrm{PV}(\text{floating receipts})}{\text{fixed-rate annuity}},\ V_{\mathrm{RF/PF}} &= \mathrm{PV}(\text{floating receipts})-\mathrm{PV}(\text{fixed payments}) \end{aligned} $$

The first line chooses the negotiated rate by matching the floating-leg present value with the fixed-leg present value. The numerator is the floating receipts, while the denominator is what one unit of fixed rate would cost across the payment dates. The second line values an existing contract, so more floating receipts raise the answer and more fixed payments lower it. Reverse the subtraction for a party that receives fixed and pays floating.

The sign follows the payment direction.

Loading diagram…

In this comparison, hold the floating-leg present value and schedule constant. Higher market fixed rates raise the fixed-payment benchmark and reduce the value of a receive-floating/pay-fixed swap.

Follow each arrow from the party to the cash flow, then from each leg to its present value. The receiving party adds floating receipts to its position, while fixed payments reduce that position. Subtracting the fixed-leg present value from the floating-leg present value gives the sign for this perspective. If the party directions reverse, reverse the subtraction as well.

Worked example

You are handed a receive-floating/pay-fixed swap with contract fixed rate 0.04 per year. You need the negotiated swap price from the current forward rates and the later value of this existing contract. Annual net settlement occurs at each period end, and the notional is not exchanged.

The diagram shows the payment directions that determine the sign; the worked example now supplies the rates and dates needed to quantify each leg. Keep the notional and annual payment interval in view when converting rates to cash flows. Discount those cash flows back to the valuation date before comparing the two present values.

InputValue
PerspectiveReceive floating, pay fixed
NotionalUSD 100 million
Maturity2 years
Payment interval1 year
Contract fixed rate0.04 per year
Forward rate, period 10.05 per year
Forward rate, period 20.06 per year
Discount rate, period 10.05 per year
Discount rate, period 20.06 per year
SettlementAnnual net, period end
DiscountingAnnual compounding

The line shows the receive-floating/pay-fixed value when the fixed rate changes while the base floating-leg present value stays fixed. The line falls as the fixed-rate quote rises.

Read the horizontal labels as alternative fixed-rate quotes and the vertical values as the resulting dollar values in USD millions. At 0.0400, the existing contract is worth USD 2.73 million to the receiving-floating party. At 0.0600, value turns negative at USD 0.95 million. The zero crossing lies between those quotes.

Loading diagram…

Use the plotted points to compare the same receive-floating/pay-fixed contract under different fixed rates. As the quote rises, fixed payments become more costly relative to the unchanged floating-leg present value, so the contract value declines. The values shown are in USD millions; a negative result means the fixed payments exceed the floating receipts from this party’s perspective.

Fixed rateSwap value
0.0300USD 4.57 million
0.0400USD 2.73 million
0.0500USD 0.89 million
0.0600USD -0.95 million
0.0700USD -2.79 million
  1. Turn each forward rate into a floating cash flow. The amounts are in USD million. Period 1 gives $100 \times 0.05 \times 1 = 5.00$. Period 2 gives $100 \times 0.06 \times 1 = 6.00$.

  2. Discount each leg so future amounts become current values. The fixed cash flow is USD 4.00 million at each period, and the discount factors are 0.9524 and 0.8900. The floating-leg PVs are USD 4.76 million and USD 5.34 million. The fixed-leg PVs are USD 3.81 million and USD 3.56 million.

  3. Add the period PVs within each leg. This gives $\mathrm{PV}(\text{floating receipts}) = 10.10$ and $\mathrm{PV}(\text{fixed payments}) = 7.37$, both in USD million.

  4. Find the fixed rate that makes inception value zero. The fixed-rate annuity is $100 \times 1 \times 0.9524 + 100 \times 1 \times 0.8900 = 184.24$ USD million. Dividing the floating-leg PV by this annuity gives $K_{\mathrm{swap}} = 0.054831$ per year.

  5. Value the existing contract at its stated fixed rate. Since your perspective receives floating and pays fixed, $V_{\mathrm{RF/PF}} = 10.10 - 7.37 = 2.73$ USD million.

The swap price is 0.054831 per year, while the existing contract is worth USD 2.73 million to the stated party, so the existing contract is favorable from that perspective and a new contract at the swap price would start at USD 0.00 million.

Changed condition

Now change only the period 2 forward rate. The same perspective, contract fixed rate, discounting, settlement, and maturity remain in place.

ItemBaseChanged
Forward rate, period 20.06 per year0.07 per year
Floating PV totalUSD 10.10 millionUSD 10.99 million
Fixed-rate annuityUSD 184.24 millionUSD 184.24 million
Swap price0.054831 per year0.059661 per year
Contract valueUSD 2.73 millionUSD 3.62 million

Before you calculate, predict the direction. Raising the period 2 floating rate increases floating receipts while the fixed leg stays unchanged. The floating-leg PV rises, so the zero-value fixed rate and the existing receive-floating/pay-fixed value both rise. Before reading on, calculate the changed floating cash flow for period 2 yourself.

Common error

A candidate sees the word price and writes USD 2.73 million because it is the dollar amount already calculated. It feels right because a swap sounds like something with a cash price, and the candidate may also reverse the sign by thinking like the fixed payer. The wording gives it away: inception and negotiated fixed rate ask for swap price, while a later receive-floating/pay-fixed valuation asks for floating PV minus fixed PV.

Check yourself

Practice

A receive-floating/pay-fixed swap has floating-leg present value of USD 10.10 million and fixed-leg present value of USD 7.37 million. What is the current swap value?

Which choice correctly contrasts swap price and swap value?

Revision snapshot

Swap price is the negotiated fixed rate that sets the initial swap value to zero. For a receive-floating/pay-fixed party, swap value equals the present value of floating receipts minus the present value of fixed payments. Higher market fixed rates reduce the value of a receive-floating/pay-fixed swap. Read timing first. Inception asks for the rate. A later valuation asks for a dollar PV and its sign.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Swap price vs swap value

  1. 1. Northbridge Manufacturing is reviewing several derivative transactions with its treasury adviser. The company uses derivatives only for identifiable financing or operating exposures and measures all derivative values from Northbridge's position. Transaction costs and taxes are ignored, and all counterparties are assumed able to perform. The first transaction is a six-month equity forward considered by the corporate pension plan. The plan would take the long position and receive one share at maturity in exchange for the delivery price. The underlying share pays no dividends or other income during the contract term. At initiation, the share price and annual effective risk-free rate are those reported in Exhibit 1. The dealer quoted a delivery price of USD 126.00, although the pension analyst wants to calculate the no-arbitrage price independently. Three months after initiation, the share price has risen, and the risk-free rate is unchanged. The contract has not been reset, so its delivery price remains USD 126.00. The analyst must distinguish the forward price of a new contract from the value of the existing contract. The treasury adviser also proposes using exchange-traded futures instead of new OTC forwards for some shorter-term exposures. A treasury associate states: 'Because a futures contract is marked to market, Northbridge does not need to provide funds until the contract expires.' The adviser responds that an initial margin deposit and subsequent variation margin may be required. The adviser further explains that the daily settlement of gains and losses affects both counterparty exposure and the timing of cash flows. When interest rates are uncertain, the ability to reinvest interim gains or finance interim losses may cause a futures price to differ from the price of an otherwise comparable forward. Finally, Northbridge has USD 80 million of floating-rate debt. Interest is paid quarterly at the three-month reference rate plus 120 basis points, where 1 basis point equals 0.0001 in decimal rate terms. Management expects reference rates to rise and wants to stabilize interest expense for the next three years without refinancing the debt. The available swap has quarterly settlements, a USD 80 million notional principal, and a fixed rate of 4.60%. The floating leg is based on the same three-month reference rate as the debt. No principal is exchanged under the swap.

    • 2. Meridian Capital manages a diversified multi-asset fund and uses derivatives both to obtain market exposure and to alter the fund's interest-rate profile. The derivatives committee requires all positions to be priced using no-arbitrage relationships and values to be reported from the fund's perspective. Unless stated otherwise, quoted rates are annual rates, and there are no transaction costs, taxes, or restrictions on short selling. An analyst first considers establishing a six-month long forward on a broad equity index. The index pays dividends continuously, so the analyst treats the dividend yield as an economic benefit forgone by holding the forward instead of the underlying index portfolio. The analyst notes that a forward's delivery price is set so that the contract has zero value at initiation, but its value can subsequently become positive or negative as market conditions change. The fund already holds a long equity index forward with a delivery price of 2,480 and three months remaining. To value this contract, the analyst obtains current spot, financing-rate, and dividend-yield data. The counterparty has posted collateral, but the contract is not settled daily. The analyst is instructed to calculate the current value rather than the current forward price or the expiration payoff. Meridian also holds a receive-fixed, pay-floating interest rate swap with a semiannual settlement convention. The floating payment for each period is determined using six-month SOFR observed at the beginning of that period and is paid at the end. The fixed and floating amounts are netted at settlement. The most recent SOFR reset has already occurred, making the next floating payment known even though later payments remain uncertain. Finally, the committee is comparing OTC forwards with exchange-traded futures. One member states that identical forward and futures prices are not guaranteed when interest rates are stochastic because futures gains and losses are realised daily and can be reinvested or financed at prevailing rates. For the operational comparison, the committee focuses on the daily settlement mechanism rather than on potential price differences arising from the correlation between interest rates and the underlying asset.

      • 3. A copper producer locks in a customized future selling price through a privately negotiated contract requiring both parties to transact at maturity. The contract is best described as:

        • A. An OTC forward commitment with counterparty risk
        • B. An exchange-traded contingent claim with basis risk
        • C. An OTC contingent claim with daily settlement
        Show answer

        Answer: A. An OTC forward commitment with counterparty risk

        An OTC forward commitment with counterparty risk - The producer’s customized selling price and privately negotiated terms identify an OTC forward. - Because both parties must transact at maturity, the contract is a forward commitment with counterparty risk rather than a right that one party may choose to exercise. An exchange-traded contingent claim with basis risk - A contingent claim gives its holder a right rather than requiring both parties to transact at maturity. - The privately negotiated, customized contract is OTC, not exchange-traded; basis risk does not change that classification. An OTC contingent claim with daily settlement - Although the contract is OTC, its mutual obligation makes it a forward commitment, not a contingent claim. - Daily settlement is characteristic of futures, whereas a conventional forward settles at maturity.

      • 4. A portfolio manager trades an exchange-listed contract that requires both parties to transact at maturity and is marked to market daily. The contract is best described as:

        • A. A forward commitment with standardized terms
        • B. A contingent claim with bilateral settlement
        • C. A forward commitment with daily settlement
        Show answer

        Answer: C. A forward commitment with daily settlement

        A forward commitment with daily settlement - Both parties must transact at maturity, making the contract a forward commitment rather than an option. - Its daily marking to market identifies the daily settlement characteristic of an exchange-listed futures contract. A forward commitment with standardized terms - Exchange-listed futures do have standardized terms, so this describes a real feature of the contract. - It is less precise here because it omits the daily settlement expressly stated in the question. A contingent claim with bilateral settlement - A contingent claim, such as an option, gives one party a choice whether to exercise; this contract obligates both parties. - Bilateral settlement also misses the daily marking to market of an exchange-listed futures contract.

      • 5. Meridian Capital operates a derivatives desk that supports several institutional portfolios. The desk is reviewing positions whose values and hedge requirements have changed following a rise in interest rates. Unless otherwise stated, contracts have no counterparty default risk, transaction costs are zero, and markets permit borrowing and lending at the stated risk-free rates. The first position is a long forward on a broad equity index. The index pays dividends continuously, and the forward is not settled daily. The desk must distinguish the contract's original delivery price from both the current forward price and the contract's current value. The current value is measured from the perspective of the long party and should reflect the present value of the difference between the current forward price and the contractual delivery price. The desk is also quoting a one-year forward on an industrial commodity. The commodity provides a nonmonetary convenience benefit to firms holding physical inventory. Storage costs are known and payable at the end of the year. The convenience yield applies proportionally to the spot commodity, and the quoted effective annual rates should be used consistently. The forward will be cash settled at maturity. A fixed-income client separately wants to eliminate the interest-rate exposure of a bond portfolio using bond futures. The portfolio manager plans to sell futures because the portfolio is long bonds. The contract price represents the quoted futures contract value. The cheapest-to-deliver bond's modified duration and conversion factor must be incorporated when estimating the effective duration exposure represented by each futures contract. The manager assumes parallel yield-curve shifts and no change in the cheapest-to-deliver bond. Finally, Meridian holds a receive-fixed, pay-floating interest rate swap. Immediately after the most recent floating payment, market swap rates increased. The swap is valued as the difference between an otherwise equivalent fixed-rate bond paying the contractual rate and a floating-rate bond that resets to par on a payment date. For the remaining one-year term, the change from the contractual fixed rate to the current par swap rate provides an equivalent annuity-based valuation. Exhibit 1 presents the forward and futures data, and Exhibit 2 presents the swap terms and discount factors.

        • 6. A portfolio manager buys a listed contract that grants the right, but not the obligation, to buy an equity index at a fixed price. The contract is best described as:

          • A. An exchange-traded forward commitment
          • B. An OTC forward commitment
          • C. An exchange-traded contingent claim
          Show answer

          Answer: C. An exchange-traded contingent claim

          An exchange-traded contingent claim - The right, but not the obligation, to buy the equity index at a fixed price describes a call option. - Because the contract is listed and the holder chooses whether to exercise, it is an exchange-traded contingent claim. An exchange-traded forward commitment - Exchange-traded fits a listed contract, but a forward commitment obligates the parties rather than giving the buyer an exercise choice. - The manager’s right to buy without an obligation makes this a contingent claim, not a commitment. An OTC forward commitment - OTC does not fit the stated listed contract, which trades on an exchange. - A forward commitment also imposes obligations on both parties, unlike the manager’s right to buy only if the manager chooses.

        • 7. Meridian Derivatives Fund uses forwards, futures, and swaps to obtain market exposure and manage financing risk. A portfolio manager entered a nine-month long forward on a non-tradable equity index. The contract requires cash settlement at maturity, and the index's dividends are represented by a continuous dividend yield. Relevant initiation and current data are presented in Exhibit 1. The counterparty has not defaulted, no collateral has been transferred, and the current value is measured from Meridian's perspective. The manager is also comparing the index forward with an otherwise equivalent exchange-traded futures contract. The two contracts have the same underlying index and maturity. The futures contract is marked to market daily through a central clearinghouse, whereas the forward settles only at maturity. The manager expects index values and short-term interest rates to be positively correlated during the remaining contract period. Transaction costs, taxes, and initial margin financing costs are ignored for the pricing comparison. Meridian is evaluating a newly initiated three-year interest rate swap with annual settlements. Under the proposed swap, Meridian would pay a fixed rate and receive a one-year floating reference rate. The first floating payment is set at initiation, subsequent floating payments reset annually, and the notional principal is not exchanged. Exhibit 2 reports the discount factors applicable to the three annual payment dates. The fixed rate must make the swap's initial value equal to zero. Finally, the fund is considering a six-month forward purchase of an investment commodity. The commodity's spot price is USD 50.00 per unit. The continuously compounded annual risk-free rate is 4%, proportional storage costs are 2% annually, and the commodity provides a 1% annual convenience yield. All rates remain constant through maturity. Storage costs and convenience yield are incorporated into the continuous cost-of-carry relationship, and there are no other benefits, financing costs, or restrictions on short selling.

          • 8. Meridian Capital manages a diversified portfolio and uses derivatives for both efficient exposure management and risk control. Priya Shah, a derivatives analyst, reviews several contracts after market interest rates and equity prices have changed. All rates in the analysis use annual compounding, and there are no transaction costs, taxes, bid–ask spreads, or default losses. Shah first considers entering a new one-year forward on a non-index equity. The equity will pay a single known cash dividend in six months. Because the dividend is received by an equity owner but not by the holder of the forward, Shah recognizes that the dividend must be removed from the spot-based replication before calculating the forward price. The portfolio also holds an existing long equity forward with three months remaining. Shah notes that the contract's delivery price was fixed at initiation and must not be replaced with the current forward price. To measure the contract's current value, she intends to compare the current forward price for the remaining maturity with the contractual delivery price and discount the difference to the valuation date. She also reminds a colleague that the counterparty on the other side of this contract, holding the short position, has a claim of equal magnitude but opposite sign. A junior analyst asserts that the portfolio's exchange-traded futures contract behaves like an otherwise comparable forward because both contracts create obligations for the buyer and seller. Shah responds that the payoff commitments are similar, but the timing of cash flows differs because the futures contract is marked to market through a central clearinghouse. Shah also considers what would happen if the new equity forward under review were mispriced relative to its no-arbitrage value, and she outlines the trades needed to exploit such a mispricing and the resulting riskless profit. Finally, Shah values a receive-fixed, pay-floating interest rate swap immediately after a settlement date. The next floating payment has therefore just been reset. She uses the bond-equivalence approach, under which the receive-fixed swap is valued as a long position in a fixed-rate bond and a short position in a floating-rate bond. The relevant contract and market information is presented in Exhibit 1.

            Flashcards: Swap price vs swap value

            1. 1. In Derivatives (Pricing of Swaps), what is the typical value of a fixed-for-floating interest-rate swap at initiation?

              Show answer

              Zero. The swap is priced so that neither party pays the other to enter the contract.

            2. 2. In Derivatives (Pricing of Swaps), how is the value of the fixed-rate payer position calculated at any point during the life of the swap?

              Show answer

              It is the present value of the expected future floating-rate payments minus the present value of the future fixed-rate payments.

            3. 3. In Derivatives (Pricing of Swaps), how can an interest-rate swap be conceptually replicated using other derivatives?

              Show answer

              A swap is equivalent to a series of forward rate agreements (FRAs), each with a forward contract rate equal to the swap fixed rate.

            4. 4. Why is an interest rate swap mathematically equivalent to a series of forward rate agreements (FRAs)?

              Show answer

              Because at each settlement date, the exchange of a fixed rate for a floating rate acts exactly like the settlement of an individual forward contract expiring on that date.

            5. 5. In Derivatives (Pricing of Swaps), how does an increase in expected future interest rates affect the value of the fixed-rate payer position?

              Show answer

              An increase in expected future rates will produce an increase in the value of the fixed-rate payer position.

            Everything you need for CFA prep

            Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

            GET STARTED FOR FREE
            75% OFFLimited time offer
            GET 75% OFF