Learning Outcome Statement
Estimate the cost of debt or required return on equity for a public company and a private company.
On the exam: You receive public-market inputs, comparable-company evidence, private-company adjustments, and tax conventions. Then you calculate a pre-tax or after-tax cost of debt or required return on equity, or interpret those inputs in a short item-set question.
A lender focuses on the firm's promise to repay, while an equity investor faces uncertain ownership cash flows. A public company gives you observable market evidence directly. For a private company, you start with a comparable public company and make supported adjustments for size, liquidity, and credit risk. The risk-free rate, $r_f$, is the starting return for both estimates. A debt credit spread, $s$, is the extra return a lender demands from the issuer. For equity, beta, $\beta$, scales the equity risk premium, $ERP$. A private estimate adds supported premiums rather than copying the public result.
| Company | Debt evidence | Equity evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Public | Risk-free rate plus public spread | Beta and equity risk premium |
| Private | Risk-free rate plus private spread | Comparable beta plus justified premiums |
For public debt, $k_{d,\mathrm{public}}$ is the pre-tax cost a lender requires, built from $r_f$ and $s_{\mathrm{public}}$. For private debt, $k_{d,\mathrm{private}}$ uses the same starting rate and the private spread, $s_{\mathrm{private}}$. For equity, $k_{e,\mathrm{public}}$ is the public required return, and $k_{e,\mathrm{private}}$ starts there before adding a supported size premium, $SP$, and liquidity premium, $LP$. When taxes matter, use tax rate $t$ to turn the relevant debt cost, $k_d$, into the after-tax cost, $k_{d,\mathrm{posttax}}$.
Now place each input where the actor would use it. The debt lines add the lender's spread to the risk-free starting point. The equity lines scale the premium with beta and add private adjustments. The final line applies the tax shield to debt.
$$ \begin{aligned} k_{d,\mathrm{public}} &= r_f+s_{\mathrm{public}} \ k_{d,\mathrm{private}} &= r_f+s_{\mathrm{private}} \ k_{e,\mathrm{public}} &= r_f+\beta \times ERP \ k_{e,\mathrm{private}} &= k_{e,\mathrm{public}}+SP+LP \ k_{d,\mathrm{posttax}} &= k_d \times (1-t) \end{aligned} $$
A higher private spread raises the lender's required return, a higher beta raises public equity return because beta scales $ERP$, and supported $SP$ or $LP$ raises private equity return. You may multiply equity by $(1-t)$ because the tax adjustment appears beside debt. That feels reasonable when the case presents a tax rate with the financing data. The actor gives it away because the tax shield lowers debt cost for the lender and never multiplies an equity return.
When a case moves from public evidence to private evidence, you still follow the same path. Identify the company type, choose the matching debt or equity evidence, and apply the tax convention only if the requested result is debt. For private equity, add size and liquidity premiums only when the case supports them.
Loading diagram…
Read the flow from the company type toward the return you need. Public evidence supplies the market inputs directly; private evidence begins with a comparable and needs support for each adjustment. Keep debt and equity separate as you move through the choices: the spread belongs to debt, while beta and any justified private premiums shape equity. At the end, apply the tax convention only when the selected result is debt. The figure shows where each decision enters, so use it to trace the inputs rather than memorize isolated labels.
Worked example
You are pricing a public industrial company and a private comparable at the same date. The public company supplies market evidence, while the private comparable supplies financing facts. The case asks you to find pre-tax and after-tax debt costs and the required return on equity for each company. All market rates are annual decimals, the tax rate is a decimal, and beta is unitless.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Risk-free rate | 0.04 |
| Equity risk premium | 0.055 |
| Comparable beta | 1.1 |
| Public debt spread | 0.018 |
| Private debt spread | 0.032 |
| Private size premium | 0.02 |
| Private liquidity premium | 0.015 |
| Tax rate | 0.25 |
Use the bars to compare the public and private estimates across debt and equity. For debt, each pre-tax bar uses its company's spread, and its post-tax bar reflects the interest tax shield. The two equity bars use the comparable beta and equity risk premium, with the private estimate also including its size and liquidity premiums. Notice that the after-tax adjustment belongs only to debt. As you read the chart, match each bar to the inputs above it and check that the direction of each difference follows from the stated evidence.
Loading diagram…
- The public lender starts with the risk-free rate and adds the public debt spread to price the issuer's credit. This gives the public pre-tax debt cost: $0.04+0.018=0.0580$.
- The private lender uses the private debt spread because the private issuer has different credit evidence. This gives the private pre-tax debt cost: $0.04+0.032=0.0720$.
- The company receives a tax shield on interest, so its after-tax debt cost is the pre-tax cost multiplied by the after-tax factor. For public debt, this gives $0.0580 \times 0.7500=0.0435$.
- Apply the same tax convention to the private debt cost because the private company also receives the interest tax shield. This gives $0.0720 \times 0.7500=0.0540$.
- The equity investor requires the risk-free rate plus compensation for market exposure. Multiply beta by the equity risk premium, then add the risk-free rate: $0.04+1.1 \times 0.055=0.1005$.
- The private equity investor faces size and liquidity risks beyond the public-equivalent return. Add both premiums to the public-equivalent equity return: $0.1005+0.02+0.015=0.1355$.
| Measure | Public | Private |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-tax debt | 0.0580 | 0.0720 |
| After-tax debt | 0.0435 | 0.0540 |
| Required return on equity | 0.1005 | 0.1355 |
Suppose a credit committee is deciding whether to approve financing for the private comparable, while an investment committee is reviewing its equity return. The credit committee should carry 0.0720 before tax or 0.0540 after tax into its decision, and the equity committee should require 0.1355. The higher private figures mean you should not substitute the public company's rates when judging the private issuer.
Changed condition
Keep the same case, but raise only the private size premium. The question asks how the private equity estimate responds.
| Measure | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Private size premium | 0.02 | 0.03 |
| Private required return on equity | 0.1355 | 0.1455 |
Before you calculate, predict that only the private equity return rises. The added premium enters directly, while the debt estimates and public equity estimate stay put. The tax convention is unchanged because equity is not tax-adjusted. Recalculate the changed private required return on equity before reading on.
Common error
You may carry the public company's beta or credit spread into the private-company answer, or tax-adjust the required return on equity. This feels right because the firms share an industry, and the tax adjustment is familiar from debt financing. The private-company question supplies size, liquidity, or different credit-risk evidence and asks for pre-tax versus after-tax treatment. Change the inputs or the tax rule to match what the question tells you about the private company.
Calculator
Use the first sequence for the base case and the second after the size change. In each calculation, start from the public-equivalent equity return, then add the private premiums that the case supports. The second sequence changes only the size premium; the liquidity premium and comparable return remain as shown. Read each display before moving to the next key, and check that the final value agrees with the corresponding return in the lesson. This keeps the adjustment visible and makes it easier to catch a copied or omitted premium.
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 0.04 + 1.1 × 0.055 = | 0.1005 |
| 0.1005 + 0.02 + 0.015 = | 0.1355 |
| CPT | 0.1355 |
Now compare that result with the changed case. The first sequence includes the original private size premium, while the next sequence substitutes the higher amount given in the changed condition. The risk-free rate, beta, equity risk premium, and liquidity premium are unchanged, so only the private equity result should move. This is a useful calculator check: if a debt figure or the public equity return changes, an input from the case has been carried into the wrong calculation.
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 0.04 + 1.1 × 0.055 = | 0.1005 |
| 0.1005 + 0.03 + 0.015 = | 0.1455 |
| CPT | 0.1455 |
Check yourself
Practice
A public industrial company and a private comparable operate in the same business and are valued at the same date. Market evidence gives a risk-free rate of 0.04, an equity risk premium of 0.055, a comparable beta of 1.1, a public debt spread of 0.018, and a private debt spread of 0.032. The private company has a size premium of 0.02, a liquidity premium of 0.015, and a tax rate of 0.25.
Question 1
What is the private company's pre-tax cost of debt?
Question 2
What is the private required return on equity?
Question 3
Which figure is the private company's after-tax cost of debt?
Question 4
Which treatment follows for the private required return on equity?
A private company's size premium rises from 0.02 to 0.03 while all other stated inputs stay unchanged. What is its required return on equity?
Revision snapshot
Public cost of debt equals $r_f+s$ and is reported pre-tax unless a post-tax financing measure is required. Public required return on equity equals $r_f+\beta \times ERP$. Private-company estimates begin with comparable public-company risk and add justified size and liquidity premiums. Tax-adjust debt costs when appropriate for a post-tax financing measure. Do not tax-adjust the required return on equity. The exam supplies public-market inputs, comparable-company evidence, private adjustments, and tax conventions, then asks for a pre-tax or after-tax debt cost or an equity required return. The trap is copying a public beta or credit spread into a private estimate.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more