Learning Outcome Statement
Contrast roll return in markets in contango and markets in backwardation.
On the exam: You are given near and deferred futures prices, the position direction, and the roll convention. You calculate or classify the gross roll-return sign for a long position, then contrast contango with backwardation in an item set or matrix grid.
At the roll date, a long investor closes the expiring futures by selling it and opens the next contract by buying it. If the replacement is more expensive, the investor spends more on the new contract than the sale price of the old contract. That price difference drives the roll return, even before any other return component is considered. Call the expiring contract's futures price the near futures price, $F_{\mathrm{near}}$, and call the next contract's price the deferred futures price, $F_{\mathrm{deferred}}$.
| Market | Price relationship | Long roll return |
|---|---|---|
| Contango | $F_{\mathrm{deferred}} > F_{\mathrm{near}}$ | Negative |
| Backwardation | $F_{\mathrm{deferred}} < F_{\mathrm{near}}$ | Positive |
Read the relationship from the long investor's trade. Contango makes the replacement purchase more expensive, while backwardation makes it cheaper.
For a long futures position, the gross roll return is approximately:
$$ \text{Gross roll return} \approx \frac{F_{\mathrm{near}} - F_{\mathrm{deferred}}}{F_{\mathrm{near}}} $$
The numerator compares the sale price of the expiring futures with the purchase price of the deferred futures. A higher deferred price makes that difference negative, while a lower deferred price makes it positive. Dividing by the near price turns the price gap into a return. This is a gross, unlevered measure, not the complete net or levered investor return, so exclude collateral return, fees, financing, and transaction costs unless stated.
Worked example
You are handed a long futures position that rolls the expiring futures into the next futures contract at the roll date. The near futures price is USD 100 per commodity unit, the contango deferred price is USD 104, the backwardation deferred price is USD 96, and the notional exposure is USD 100,000. The exam asks you to calculate the gross roll return in each market and compare the dollar effect at that exposure.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Near futures price | USD 100 per commodity unit |
| Contango deferred price | USD 104 per commodity unit |
| Backwardation deferred price | USD 96 per commodity unit |
| Notional exposure | USD 100,000 |
| Position | Long |
Use the near price as the sale proceeds and each deferred price as the replacement cost. The notional exposure lets you translate the resulting percentage return into dollars; it does not change the price comparison or its sign. The diagram traces that sequence for the long position.
- For contango, subtract the deferred price from the near price. This mirrors the long investor's sale followed by purchase and produces the price gap $100 - 104 = -4.00$ USD per commodity unit.
- Divide that gap by the near price to scale it to the expiring contract price. The decimal roll return is $\frac{-4.00}{100} = -0.0400$.
- Multiply the decimal by $100$ to report percentage points. Contango produces $100 \times -0.0400 = -4.00$ percentage points.
- For backwardation, repeat the same price comparison. The long investor sells at $100$ and buys at $96$, so the gap is $100 - 96 = 4.00$ USD per commodity unit.
- Divide the favorable gap by the near price. The decimal roll return is $\frac{4.00}{100} = 0.0400$.
- Convert the decimal to percentage points. Backwardation produces $100 \times 0.0400 = 4.00$ percentage points.
- Translate each decimal into the stated exposure. Contango gives $100,000 \times -0.0400 = -4,000.00$ USD, while backwardation gives $100,000 \times 0.0400 = 4,000.00$ USD.
At the same notional exposure, contango contributes a gross roll loss of USD 4,000.00, while backwardation contributes a gross roll gain of USD 4,000.00. For a long exposure, backwardation is the favorable roll environment and contango is the drag.
Changed condition
| Item | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Contango deferred price | USD 104 per commodity unit | USD 106 per commodity unit |
| Contango roll return | -4.00 percentage points | -6.00 percentage points |
| Contango dollar effect | -4,000.00 USD | -6,000.00 USD at USD 100,000 exposure |
As a prediction, raising the deferred contango price from USD 104 to USD 106 makes $F_{\mathrm{near}} - F_{\mathrm{deferred}}$ more negative because the long investor must buy a more expensive replacement. The roll return moves from -4.00 to -6.00 percentage points, and the dollar effect moves from -4,000.00 to -6,000.00 USD. Backwardation stays unchanged because its deferred price did not change. Before reading on, calculate the contango dollar effect at USD 100,000 exposure yourself.
Common error
A candidate sees the deferred price of USD 104 above the near price of USD 100 in contango and records a positive roll return, as if buying later at a higher price were a gain. That feels natural if you focus on the higher future price and forget that a long position must sell the expiring futures before buying the next contract. The action gives it away because the long sells the expiring futures and buys the deferred futures at USD 104, so the gap from USD 100 is negative.
Calculator
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 2ND CLR TVM | 0.00 |
| 100 ENTER | 100.00 |
| 104 - | -4.00 |
| 100 / | -0.04 |
| 100 x | -4.00 |
Check yourself
Practice
A long futures position has a near futures price of USD 100 per commodity unit. The contango deferred price is USD 104, the backwardation deferred price is USD 96, and the notional exposure is USD 100,000.
Question 1
Calculate the gross contango roll return for the long position.
Question 2
Which action explains the contango result for the long position?
Question 3
Calculate the gross backwardation roll return for the long position.
Question 4
Which contrast is correct for a long futures position?
Classify each market for a long futures position.
| Negative roll return | Positive roll return | |
|---|---|---|
| Contango | ||
| Backwardation |
Revision snapshot
For a long futures position, gross roll return is approximately the near futures price minus the deferred futures price, divided by the near futures price. The same relationship appears below.
$$ \text{Gross roll return} \approx \frac{F_{\mathrm{near}} - F_{\mathrm{deferred}}}{F_{\mathrm{near}}} $$
| Market | Deferred versus near | Long sign |
|---|---|---|
| Contango | Deferred exceeds near | Negative |
| Backwardation | Deferred below near | Positive |
Contango means the deferred futures price exceeds the near futures price, producing a negative roll return for a long position. Backwardation means the deferred futures price is below the near futures price, producing a positive roll return for a long position.
A higher deferred price is a cost when a long position rolls. On the exam, use the supplied prices, position direction, and roll convention to calculate or contrast the sign. Roll return is a component of return, not the complete net or levered investor return. Exclude collateral return, fees, financing and transaction costs unless stated.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more