Learning Outcome Statement
Describe how the construction of commodity indexes affects index returns.
On the exam: You get an index methodology, commodity weights, price and roll conditions, collateral income, and fees. You calculate a component or total return, then compare how a construction choice changes the result.
An index is a rules-based basket of commodity futures rather than a single contract. Its rulebook chooses the contracts, assigns weights, sets roll and rebalancing rules, and charges implementation costs. Those choices can change the reported return even when indexes refer to the same commodity sectors.
The image shows that construction decisions feed different parts of the return calculation. Use the table to connect each rule to the layer it can affect: weighting changes component influence, while collateral and fees enter after futures performance. This distinction helps you identify which inputs belong in a component calculation and which belong in the final index return.
| Construction choice | What changes | Return layer |
|---|---|---|
| Weighting | Exposure across components | Price and roll returns |
| Contract selection | Commodity and maturity | Price and roll returns |
| Roll schedule | Replacement timing | Roll return and trading costs |
| Rebalancing | Restores target weights | Price, roll, and costs |
| Collateral | Collateral held against futures | Collateral return |
| Fees | Implementation costs | Net return |
Weighting decides which component can move the result most. Contract selection, roll timing, and rebalancing alter the futures leg, while collateral income is added and fees are removed after that leg.
The weighted price return is $P$, found by multiplying each component's price return by its index weight and adding the products. The weighted roll return is $R$, found by applying the same weighting to roll returns. Collateral return is $C$, while fees and implementation costs are $f$. Net return is $N$, and the chain below adds the futures pieces, adds collateral, and removes fees.
$$ \begin{aligned} \text{Futures return}&=P+R \ \text{Gross collateralized return}&=P+R+C \ N&=P+R+C-f \end{aligned} $$
Read the first line as the futures return, with a positive price or roll component lifting it and a negative component lowering it. The second line adds collateral on the full index notional because the futures position is fully collateralized, and the last line removes fees and implementation costs to produce the net figure an investor should compare. At a roll, a long position sells the expiring contract and buys a later one, so contango generally makes the roll return negative and backwardation generally makes it positive.
Worked example
You are handed a fully collateralized index with energy and agriculture components. The methodology uses beginning-of-period weights over a monthly roll period and supplies each component's price and roll returns, collateral return, and index fee. Calculate the weighted price return, weighted roll return, futures return, gross collateralized return, and net index return.
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Energy weight | $0.6$ |
| Agriculture weight | $0.4$ |
| Energy price return | $0.08$ |
| Agriculture price return | $0.02$ |
| Energy roll return | $-0.03$ |
| Agriculture roll return | $0.01$ |
| Collateral return | $0.005$ |
| Index fee | $0.002$ |
| Collateralization | Fully collateralized |
| Weight timing | Beginning-of-period |
| Holding interval | Monthly roll period |
| Return scale | Decimal return |
| Perspective | Investor gains positive |
Treat the inputs as a sequence rather than one undifferentiated list. First use the weights with each component's price and roll return; those two weighted results form the futures return. The timeline that follows places those calculations alongside the later collateral and fee adjustments, so you can keep the order straight when moving from component data to the investor's net result.
Loading diagram…
-
Weight the price returns because the index gives energy and agriculture different exposures. The weighted price return is $P=0.6\times0.08+0.4\times0.02=0.0560$.
-
Weight the roll returns for the same reason. The weighted roll return is $R=0.6\times(-0.03)+0.4\times0.01=-0.0140$.
-
Add the weighted price and roll pieces to capture the futures leg. It produces $0.0560+(-0.0140)=0.0420$.
-
Add collateral income because the index is fully collateralized. Gross collateralized return is $0.0420+0.005=0.0470$.
-
Subtract the index fee because net return is after implementation costs. Net index return is $0.0470-0.002=0.0450$.
The investor should use net index return $0.0450$ for the decision, rather than gross collateralized return $0.0470$.
Changed condition
Only the energy roll return changes from the main case to the roll shock. All other inputs remain unchanged.
| Measure | Main case | Roll shock |
|---|---|---|
| Energy roll return | $-0.03$ | $-0.06$ |
| Weighted roll return | $-0.0140$ | $-0.0320$ |
| Net index return | $0.0450$ | $0.0270$ |
Predict the direction before calculating. The weighted price component stays fixed because neither weights nor price returns changed. The more negative energy roll return pulls the weighted roll component lower, so every later return layer falls. Before reading on, recompute the weighted roll return using the unchanged weights and the changed roll returns.
Common error
You report the weighted futures return as the index's total return. It feels right because the futures basket shows the commodity exposure, and the price-plus-roll calculation looks complete. The supplied collateral income and index fee expose the mistake: you must distinguish the gross collateralized return from the net index return.
Calculator
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 0.6 ENTER | 0.6 |
| 0.4 ENTER | 0.4 |
| 0.08 ENTER | 0.08 |
| 0.02 ENTER | 0.02 |
| -0.03 ENTER | -0.03 |
| 0.01 ENTER | 0.01 |
| 0.005 ENTER | 0.005 |
| 0.002 ENTER | 0.002 |
| 0.6 × 0.08 + 0.4 × 0.02 CPT | 0.0560 |
| 0.6 × (-0.03) + 0.4 × 0.01 CPT | -0.0140 |
| 0.0560 + (-0.0140) CPT | 0.0420 |
| 0.0420 + 0.005 CPT | 0.0470 |
| 0.0470 - 0.002 CPT | 0.0450 |
For the roll shock, keep the price inputs, weights, collateral return, and fee exactly as shown in the first calculation. Replace only energy's roll return with the changed value. This isolates the effect of the roll assumption: the weighted roll result changes first, then futures return, gross collateralized return, and net return follow in order. The second sequence records that recalculation.
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 0.6 ENTER | 0.6 |
| 0.4 ENTER | 0.4 |
| 0.08 ENTER | 0.08 |
| 0.02 ENTER | 0.02 |
| -0.06 ENTER | -0.06 |
| 0.01 ENTER | 0.01 |
| 0.005 ENTER | 0.005 |
| 0.002 ENTER | 0.002 |
| 0.6 × 0.08 + 0.4 × 0.02 CPT | 0.0560 |
| 0.6 × (-0.06) + 0.4 × 0.01 CPT | -0.0320 |
| 0.0560 + (-0.0320) CPT | 0.0240 |
| 0.0240 + 0.005 CPT | 0.0290 |
| 0.0290 - 0.002 CPT | 0.0270 |
Check yourself
Practice
A fully collateralized commodity index uses energy weight 0.6 and agriculture weight 0.4. Energy has price return 0.08 and roll return -0.03. Agriculture has price return 0.02 and roll return 0.01. Collateral return is 0.005 and the index fee is 0.002.
Question 1
What is the weighted price return?
Question 2
What is the weighted roll return?
Question 3
What is the gross collateralized return?
Question 4
Which statement best describes the construction effect?
Classify each input's direct effect on net index return.
| Raises net return | Reduces net return | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy roll return -0.06 | ||
| Collateral return 0.005 | ||
| Index fee 0.002 |
Revision snapshot
$\text{Futures return}=\text{price return}+\text{roll return}$. $\text{Fully collateralized index return}=\text{futures return}+\text{collateral return}$. $\text{Net return}=\text{gross collateralized return}-\text{fees and implementation costs}$.
| Construction choice | Return consequence |
|---|---|
| Weighting | Changes component influence |
| Contract selection | Changes exposure and roll |
| Roll schedule | Changes roll return and costs |
| Rebalancing | Changes component weights |
| Fees | Reduce net return |
Weighting, contract selection, roll schedule, rebalancing, and fees can change index returns. Contango generally creates negative roll return for a long position. Backwardation generally creates positive roll return. The trap is reporting weighted futures return as total return. When collateral income and fees appear, separate gross collateralized return from net index return.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more