Commodity index construction and index returns

Commodity index construction and index returns

Published September 28, 2026

Commodity index construction and index returns

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Describe how the construction of commodity indexes affects index returns.

On the exam: You get an index methodology, commodity weights, price and roll conditions, collateral income, and fees. You calculate a component or total return, then compare how a construction choice changes the result.

An index is a rules-based basket of commodity futures rather than a single contract. Its rulebook chooses the contracts, assigns weights, sets roll and rebalancing rules, and charges implementation costs. Those choices can change the reported return even when indexes refer to the same commodity sectors.

The image shows that construction decisions feed different parts of the return calculation. Use the table to connect each rule to the layer it can affect: weighting changes component influence, while collateral and fees enter after futures performance. This distinction helps you identify which inputs belong in a component calculation and which belong in the final index return.

Construction choiceWhat changesReturn layer
WeightingExposure across componentsPrice and roll returns
Contract selectionCommodity and maturityPrice and roll returns
Roll scheduleReplacement timingRoll return and trading costs
RebalancingRestores target weightsPrice, roll, and costs
CollateralCollateral held against futuresCollateral return
FeesImplementation costsNet return

Weighting decides which component can move the result most. Contract selection, roll timing, and rebalancing alter the futures leg, while collateral income is added and fees are removed after that leg.

The weighted price return is $P$, found by multiplying each component's price return by its index weight and adding the products. The weighted roll return is $R$, found by applying the same weighting to roll returns. Collateral return is $C$, while fees and implementation costs are $f$. Net return is $N$, and the chain below adds the futures pieces, adds collateral, and removes fees.

$$ \begin{aligned} \text{Futures return}&=P+R \ \text{Gross collateralized return}&=P+R+C \ N&=P+R+C-f \end{aligned} $$

Read the first line as the futures return, with a positive price or roll component lifting it and a negative component lowering it. The second line adds collateral on the full index notional because the futures position is fully collateralized, and the last line removes fees and implementation costs to produce the net figure an investor should compare. At a roll, a long position sells the expiring contract and buys a later one, so contango generally makes the roll return negative and backwardation generally makes it positive.

Worked example

You are handed a fully collateralized index with energy and agriculture components. The methodology uses beginning-of-period weights over a monthly roll period and supplies each component's price and roll returns, collateral return, and index fee. Calculate the weighted price return, weighted roll return, futures return, gross collateralized return, and net index return.

InputValue
Energy weight$0.6$
Agriculture weight$0.4$
Energy price return$0.08$
Agriculture price return$0.02$
Energy roll return$-0.03$
Agriculture roll return$0.01$
Collateral return$0.005$
Index fee$0.002$
CollateralizationFully collateralized
Weight timingBeginning-of-period
Holding intervalMonthly roll period
Return scaleDecimal return
PerspectiveInvestor gains positive

Treat the inputs as a sequence rather than one undifferentiated list. First use the weights with each component's price and roll return; those two weighted results form the futures return. The timeline that follows places those calculations alongside the later collateral and fee adjustments, so you can keep the order straight when moving from component data to the investor's net result.

Loading diagram…
  1. Weight the price returns because the index gives energy and agriculture different exposures. The weighted price return is $P=0.6\times0.08+0.4\times0.02=0.0560$.

  2. Weight the roll returns for the same reason. The weighted roll return is $R=0.6\times(-0.03)+0.4\times0.01=-0.0140$.

  3. Add the weighted price and roll pieces to capture the futures leg. It produces $0.0560+(-0.0140)=0.0420$.

  4. Add collateral income because the index is fully collateralized. Gross collateralized return is $0.0420+0.005=0.0470$.

  5. Subtract the index fee because net return is after implementation costs. Net index return is $0.0470-0.002=0.0450$.

The investor should use net index return $0.0450$ for the decision, rather than gross collateralized return $0.0470$.

Changed condition

Only the energy roll return changes from the main case to the roll shock. All other inputs remain unchanged.

MeasureMain caseRoll shock
Energy roll return$-0.03$$-0.06$
Weighted roll return$-0.0140$$-0.0320$
Net index return$0.0450$$0.0270$

Predict the direction before calculating. The weighted price component stays fixed because neither weights nor price returns changed. The more negative energy roll return pulls the weighted roll component lower, so every later return layer falls. Before reading on, recompute the weighted roll return using the unchanged weights and the changed roll returns.

Common error

You report the weighted futures return as the index's total return. It feels right because the futures basket shows the commodity exposure, and the price-plus-roll calculation looks complete. The supplied collateral income and index fee expose the mistake: you must distinguish the gross collateralized return from the net index return.

Calculator

KeysDisplay
0.6 ENTER0.6
0.4 ENTER0.4
0.08 ENTER0.08
0.02 ENTER0.02
-0.03 ENTER-0.03
0.01 ENTER0.01
0.005 ENTER0.005
0.002 ENTER0.002
0.6 × 0.08 + 0.4 × 0.02 CPT0.0560
0.6 × (-0.03) + 0.4 × 0.01 CPT-0.0140
0.0560 + (-0.0140) CPT0.0420
0.0420 + 0.005 CPT0.0470
0.0470 - 0.002 CPT0.0450

For the roll shock, keep the price inputs, weights, collateral return, and fee exactly as shown in the first calculation. Replace only energy's roll return with the changed value. This isolates the effect of the roll assumption: the weighted roll result changes first, then futures return, gross collateralized return, and net return follow in order. The second sequence records that recalculation.

KeysDisplay
0.6 ENTER0.6
0.4 ENTER0.4
0.08 ENTER0.08
0.02 ENTER0.02
-0.06 ENTER-0.06
0.01 ENTER0.01
0.005 ENTER0.005
0.002 ENTER0.002
0.6 × 0.08 + 0.4 × 0.02 CPT0.0560
0.6 × (-0.06) + 0.4 × 0.01 CPT-0.0320
0.0560 + (-0.0320) CPT0.0240
0.0240 + 0.005 CPT0.0290
0.0290 - 0.002 CPT0.0270

Check yourself

Practice

A fully collateralized commodity index uses energy weight 0.6 and agriculture weight 0.4. Energy has price return 0.08 and roll return -0.03. Agriculture has price return 0.02 and roll return 0.01. Collateral return is 0.005 and the index fee is 0.002.

Question 1

What is the weighted price return?

Question 2

What is the weighted roll return?

Question 3

What is the gross collateralized return?

Question 4

Which statement best describes the construction effect?

Classify each input's direct effect on net index return.

Raises net returnReduces net return
Energy roll return -0.06
Collateral return 0.005
Index fee 0.002

Revision snapshot

$\text{Futures return}=\text{price return}+\text{roll return}$. $\text{Fully collateralized index return}=\text{futures return}+\text{collateral return}$. $\text{Net return}=\text{gross collateralized return}-\text{fees and implementation costs}$.

Construction choiceReturn consequence
WeightingChanges component influence
Contract selectionChanges exposure and roll
Roll scheduleChanges roll return and costs
RebalancingChanges component weights
FeesReduce net return

Weighting, contract selection, roll schedule, rebalancing, and fees can change index returns. Contango generally creates negative roll return for a long position. Backwardation generally creates positive roll return. The trap is reporting weighted futures return as total return. When collateral income and fees appear, separate gross collateralized return from net index return.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Commodity index construction and index returns

  1. 1. A hedge fund begins with NAV of USD 100 million and a USD 105 million high-water mark. The fund's incentive fee is subject to an 8% hard hurdle rate, meaning the incentive fee applies only to gains above the higher of the high-water mark or the hurdle-rate-adjusted beginning NAV. Before fees, year-end NAV is USD 112 million. The fund charges 2% of beginning NAV and 20% of post-management-fee gains above this threshold. The investor's net return is closest to:

    • A. 9.0%
    • B. 9.2%
    • C. 9.6%
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 9.6%

    > Key point: Apply the hard hurdle to beginning NAV, use the higher threshold, then calculate incentive fees on post-management-fee gains. Why 9.6% is correct - The hurdle-adjusted NAV is USD 108 million, higher than the USD 105 million high-water mark. - The USD 2 million management fee leaves USD 110 million. The incentive fee is 20% × (USD 110 million − USD 108 million) = USD 0.4 million. - Net NAV is USD 109.6 million, so the return is (USD 109.6 million − USD 100 million) / USD 100 million = 9.6%. Working | Step | Working | Result | |---|---|---| | Hurdle threshold | USD 100 million × 1.08 | USD 108 million | | Fee threshold | Higher of USD 105 million and USD 108 million | USD 108 million | | Management fee | USD 100 million × 2% | USD 2 million | | Incentive fee | 20% × (USD 112 million − USD 2 million − USD 108 million) | USD 0.4 million | | Net return | (USD 112 million − USD 2 million − USD 0.4 million − USD 100 million) / USD 100 million | 9.6% | Answer: 9.6% Why the other options are wrong - 9.0%: Uses the USD 105 million high-water mark instead of the higher USD 108 million hurdle threshold, producing a USD 1 million incentive fee and USD 109 million net NAV. - 9.2%: Calculates the incentive fee before deducting the management fee, producing a USD 0.8 million incentive fee and USD 109.2 million net NAV.

  2. 2. Aster University Endowment allocates to hedge funds, commodity derivatives, and digital assets. The investment committee asks analyst Priya Raman to review selected positions and assess whether the reported risks and performance measures are being interpreted correctly. Strategy H, described in Exhibit 1, was initiated after a binding acquisition announcement. The manager expects the target's share price to converge toward the stated transaction value if the acquisition closes. Because consideration will be paid in shares of the acquirer, the manager shorts the acquirer's shares in a transaction-related hedge. The principal risks include deal failure, a change in transaction terms, and an extension of the expected completion date. The strategy is not designed as a broad directional forecast of the overall equity market. A second event-driven position, Strategy D, involves a long position in senior secured bank debt of a company currently under Chapter 11 protection, sized to reflect the manager's estimate of ultimate recovery value. No offsetting short position is taken, and the strategy's primary risks relate to the outcome of the reorganization process and the eventual recovery amount, rather than to a pending stock-financed acquisition. The endowment also obtains tactical natural gas exposure using fully collateralized futures. For the specific trade in Exhibit 1, however, Raman is instructed to calculate only the percentage change in the quoted futures price from purchase to sale. The position is closed immediately before expiration, and collateral income and transaction costs are explicitly zero. The observed increase is consistent with a market in which a contract purchased at a lower price gains value as it approaches a higher spot price, although no separate spot-return calculation is required. Beyond the marked-to-market price change on the closed position, Raman is separately asked to characterize the shape of the natural gas futures curve. Exhibit 3 reports quotes for the one-month and two-month contracts observed at the same time, which Raman will use to compute the roll yield an investor would earn by extending exposure from the nearer to the more distant contract. A small digital asset allocation is held directly rather than through a regulated pooled vehicle. Control of the tokens depends on control of the associated private key. The key is stored only in an internet-connected wallet, with no offline backup or institutional multi-signature arrangement. Raman notes that this structure enables rapid transactions but creates a custody exposure distinct from protocol governance disputes or questions about reserves backing a stablecoin. Finally, the committee is considering an external hedge fund index for benchmarking. The database methodology is described in Exhibit 2. Raman cautions that voluntary reporting, fund closures, backfilled histories, and infrequent valuation can each distort hedge fund index statistics, but the committee asks her to identify the bias arising specifically from the removal of funds that stopped operating. Each issue is to be evaluated independently. The committee does not require assumptions about taxes, leverage, exchange rates, or collateral returns beyond the facts expressly provided.

    • 3. Meridian Pension Plan is reviewing a real assets allocation consisting of a directly owned office building, shares of a publicly traded real estate investment trust, infrastructure projects, and timberland. The plan has a long investment horizon and values inflation sensitivity, but its investment committee requires each holding to be evaluated using the method appropriate to its structure and stage of development. For the office property, the committee directs analyst Samuel Ortiz to use direct capitalization. The stated net operating income is a stabilized forward annual amount after normal property operating expenses but before financing costs, income taxes, depreciation, and capital expenditures. The market capitalization rate is derived from recent transactions involving comparable stabilized properties. No separate adjustment for debt is required because the requested value is the unlevered property value. The listed REIT reports funds from operations using the standard adjustment to accounting net income. Ortiz is asked to estimate adjusted funds from operations by deducting recurring capital expenditures needed to maintain the existing properties. No other AFFO adjustments are required, and all outstanding shares are common shares. The committee wants a per-share amount and cautions Ortiz not to treat recurring capital expenditures as an addition to cash available for distribution. The infrastructure review compares a toll road development with an operating airport. The toll road has received necessary initial permits, but physical construction has not started. Construction cost, completion timing, and traffic after opening remain uncertain. The operating airport has an established passenger base and is operated under a long-term concession. Its tariff schedule includes contractual inflation linkage, although passenger demand can still vary with economic activity. The committee is particularly interested in how the toll road's pre-construction stage affects its risk relative to the operating asset. Finally, Meridian's timberland manager explains that trees continue to grow biologically while standing. If lumber prices are temporarily unattractive, harvesting can generally be postponed, subject to biological maturity, property expenses, and portfolio liquidity needs. Postponement can increase future merchantable timber volume, although it does not eliminate exposure to long-term changes in lumber demand, weather, fire, disease, or land values. The committee asks Ortiz to identify the feature that most directly provides short-term operating flexibility when lumber prices are weak. Relevant numerical and operating information is presented in the exhibits.

      • 4. A commodity's convenience yield rises sharply, pushing the futures curve from contango into backwardation. Holding the spot price and collateral return constant, the resulting effect on the futures roll return is most likely to be:

        • A. More negative
        • B. More positive
        • C. Unchanged
        Show answer

        Answer: B. More positive

        > Key point: A shift from contango toward backwardation makes futures roll return more positive, holding spot and collateral return constant. Why More positive is correct - Higher convenience yield lowers the futures price relative to the unchanged spot price, shifting the curve into backwardation. - As the futures price converges toward spot, that shift makes roll return more positive. Mechanism mermaid flowchart TD A[" Convenience yield rises "]:::input --> B[" Futures price falls relative to spot "]:::step B --> C[" Curve shifts into backwardation "]:::step C --> D[" Roll return becomes more positive "]:::outcome Why the other options are wrong - More negative: A more negative roll return is associated with contango, the opposite of the stated shift. - Unchanged: Holding spot and collateral return constant does not hold roll return constant; the change in futures price relative to spot affects it.

      • 5. Northbridge Partners is marketing interests in Northbridge Fund III, a closed-end private equity fund that acquires controlling positions in established middle-market companies. The fund uses capital calls as investments are completed and distributes proceeds following portfolio-company exits. Investors cannot redeem interests from the fund, although an investor may seek to sell an interest in the secondary market with the general partner's consent. A pension plan is reviewing the fund's current-year performance and the terms of its distribution waterfall. The pension plan's analyst notes that management fees are paid before carried interest is calculated. The analyst also confirms that the hurdle is a hard hurdle: the general partner earns carried interest only on annual profit exceeding the hurdle, and there is no catch-up provision. The current year contains no capital calls or distributions, so the beginning invested-capital amount in Exhibit 1 remains the applicable base for the management fee and hurdle calculation. The analyst separately evaluates the fund's since-inception performance. Northbridge reports cumulative paid-in capital, cumulative distributions, and the remaining portfolio's residual value in Exhibit 1. These figures are reported before deducting current-year fees so that the annual fee calculation and the since-inception multiples can be evaluated independently. The analyst intends to calculate total value to paid-in capital and distributions to paid-in capital directly from the reported amounts. One existing limited partner is also considering selling its entire interest. A prospective secondary-market buyer observes that the portfolio companies are valued quarterly using models and comparable-company inputs rather than continuously observable transaction prices. The buyer would assume the selling partner's remaining contractual obligations, including any future capital calls, and would have no contractual redemption right after acquiring the interest. The buyer therefore proposes a purchase price below the latest reported NAV. Northbridge's general partner states that such discounts may vary with market liquidity, the age and quality of the portfolio, uncertainty surrounding reported valuations, and the size of the remaining unfunded commitment. The pension plan evaluates the fee calculation, the reported performance multiples, and the proposed secondary transaction separately. It does not assume that the answer to any one analysis changes the data used in another analysis.

        • 6. A blockchain-based token entitles each holder to a pro rata share of a real estate fund's rental income and has been registered with securities regulators as an investment contract. The token confers no voting rights over the fund's management decisions. The token is best classified as:

          • A. A utility token
          • B. A security token
          • C. A governance token
          Show answer

          Answer: B. A security token

          > Key point: A token registered as an investment contract and representing a claim on fund income is a security token. Why a security token is correct - The pro rata rental-income entitlement is an investment interest, and the token is registered as an investment contract. - The lack of management voting rights does not change its security classification. How they compare | Token type | Defining feature | Fit with the stem | |---|---|---| | Security token | Investment interest | Income claim; registered as an investment contract | | Utility token | Access to a product or service | No access right is described | | Governance token | Voting or decision-making rights | The token has no management voting rights | Why the other options are wrong - A utility token: It provides access to a network product or service, not the stated claim on rental income. - A governance token: It confers voting or decision-making rights, which the stem explicitly says are absent.

        Flashcards: Commodity index construction and index returns

        1. 1. What is the Insurance Theory of commodity futures returns?

          Show answer

          - desire of commodity produces to reduce their price risk drives commodity futures returns - selling futures drives down prices - states that futures prices will be less than current spot prices to provide a return to those buying futures from producers ("normal backwardation") - theory lacks empirical findings

        2. 2. roll return =

          Show answer

          (price of expiring futures contract - price of new futures contract) / (price of expiring futures contract)

        3. 3. What is contango market?

          Show answer

          - futures > spots - calendar spread is negative - basis is negative

        4. 4. According to theory of storage, markets are in backwardation when?

          Show answer

          costs of storage \< benefits of holding physical inventory

        5. 5. According to theory of storage, markets are in contango when?

          Show answer

          costs of storage > benefits of holding physical inventory

        6. 6. What is the Hedging pressure hypothesis of term structure for commodity markets?

          Show answer

          - adds the hedging behavior of commodity consumers to the Insurance Theory - when producers' hedging behavior dominates, the market will be in backwardation - when users' hedging bahavior dominates, the market is in contango

        7. 7. What is a commodity volatility swap?

          Show answer

          buyer receives payment if the volatility of the commodity's price is higher than the expected level of volatility specified in the swap

        8. 8. What is the theory of storage for term structure of commodity futures?

          Show answer

          - whether a futures market is in backwardation/contango depends on the relationship between the costs of storing the commodity for future use and the benefits of holding physical inventory of the commodity

        9. 9. What factors are swaps created for payments based on?

          Show answer

          - excess returns on a commodity - the total return on the commodity - measure of price volatility

        10. 10. Shortcomings of the hedging pressure hypothesis?

          Show answer

          - producers face more concentrated price risk than consumers - both producers and consumers may be speculators in the market, not just hedgers - hedging pressure isn't observable (cannot directly test that relative heding pressure is the cause of backwardation and contango)

        Everything you need for CFA prep

        Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

        GET STARTED FOR FREE
        75% OFFLimited time offer
        GET 75% OFF