A citizen of State A sued a corporation incorporated and headquartered in State B in federal court under diversity jurisdiction, seeking $500,000 for injuries caused by an allegedly defective product. State A law permits compensatory damages but provides that punitive damages are unavailable in product-liability actions. No federal statute or Federal Rule addresses the availability of punitive damages. The plaintiff nevertheless requested punitive damages, arguing that federal courts traditionally exercise discretion over remedies and that allowing punitive damages would encourage careful manufacturing. The corporation moved to strike the punitive-damages request. Which of the following is the strongest argument supporting the corporation's motion?
- AThe state restriction governs because it defines the available remedy and disregarding it could produce materially different outcomes in state and federal court.
- BThe state restriction governs because federal courts must apply every state rule whenever jurisdiction is based solely on diversity of citizenship.
- CFederal law governs because the requested relief appears in a pleading, and pleading matters are necessarily procedural under federal law.
- DFederal law governs because a federal court may disregard state law when the court believes a different remedy would advance deterrence.
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. The state restriction governs because it defines the available remedy and disregarding it could produce materially different outcomes in state and federal court.
Rationale
The state restriction governs because it defines the available remedy and disregarding it could produce materially different outcomes in state and federal court.
- State A’s bar on punitive damages in product-liability actions limits the available remedy, and no federal statute or Federal Rule conflicts with it.
- Allowing the plaintiff to seek punitive damages only in federal court could materially change the outcome and encourage forum shopping, contrary to Erie principles.
The state restriction governs because federal courts must apply every state rule whenever jurisdiction is based solely on diversity of citizenship.
- Diversity jurisdiction does not require federal courts to apply every state rule; federal procedural law still governs procedural matters.
- State A’s restriction applies because it limits damages in this product-liability action, not simply because the parties are citizens of different states.
Federal law governs because the requested relief appears in a pleading, and pleading matters are necessarily procedural under federal law.
- Federal rules may govern how the plaintiff pleads a request for relief, but they do not create an entitlement to punitive damages.
- The motion concerns whether State A permits punitive damages for this product-liability claim, not how the request appears in the complaint.
Federal law governs because a federal court may disregard state law when the court believes a different remedy would advance deterrence.
- A federal court’s preference for stronger deterrence does not override State A’s substantive limit on damages.
- Because no federal statute or Federal Rule addresses punitive-damages availability, the court cannot supply a different remedy merely as a policy choice.